Mato just raised pre-seed Read more

Tuesday: Jordan or Scalise, Pick Your Poison

  • Nov 10, 2026
  • 20 min

Show notes

What the episode covers

Tuesday, November 10: House Republicans choose Mike Johnson's successor by secret ballot today, and it's Scalise versus Jordan in a rematch with the party's direction on the line.

The pick. Rush backs Jordan as the fighter who gives an angry base a reason to be loud. Reagan backs Scalise as the vote counter who can actually reach a majority. Each grades the other's choice, and neither goes easy.

The Senate fight. John Thune is running unopposed, but Ron Johnson, Mike Lee and Rick Scott want him judged on how aggressive he is in the lame duck. It's the same argument in a different building.

The Trump factor. CNBC reports Trump is questioning the midterm results and reviving a voting-machine conspiracy. Do posts like that help the winner or hurt the party? We lay out both sides.

The scorecards. Rush gives Scalise a B-minus. Reagan gives Jordan a B. The speaker vote on Jan. 3, 2027 needs 218.

Whose argument held up best? Cast your vote and tell us where we got it wrong.

📣 We Want to Hear from You!

Timeline

In this episode

9 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.

  1. 0:15Introduction
  2. 1:51The Setup: Two Candidates, One Rematch
  3. 4:20Rush Picks Jordan, Reagan Grades It
  4. 6:34Reagan Picks Scalise, Rush Grades It
  5. 9:21Mid-Show Parody and Sponsor: The Desert Search Party
  6. 12:30The Turn: Thune Survives, but the Fight Is Over Aggression
  7. 14:21Trump's Pivot and the Family Fight
  8. 17:02Final Scorecards and Your Vote
  9. 18:38Outro

Quick answers

Straight from the episode

The questions this one settles, without the listen.

Who are the candidates in the House Republican leadership race discussed on The Rush Lindell Show?
The race is between Steve Scalise and Jim Jordan, with Johnson out. Scalise is the number two Republican and Johnson's lieutenant, and Jordan is the Freedom Caucus founder who lost a 2023 bid. Both are Trump allies. Only members who won on Nov. 3 vote, with a forum at 9 a.m. and elections at 1:30 p.m.
Why does Rush back Jim Jordan for speaker?
Rush pitches Jordan as the change candidate. He cites Axios day-of reporting and an anonymous Jordan-backing lawmaker telling NBC the party needs a pivot. He argues Republicans should stop playing defense and give members a reason to be loud. Reagan asks what a fight accomplishes in the minority without a gavel, and Rush points to oversight and messaging.
Why does Reagan support Steve Scalise?
Reagan makes a vote-counting case based on Axios day-of reporting. Scalise allies are confident. Diaz-Balart says delay calls show Jordan lacks votes and that only Scalise appeals beyond the base. She notes the race is expected to be tight, with a majority needed in a secret ballot, and that even a narrow winner must keep a divided conference together.
What is the fight over Senate Majority Leader John Thune about?
Thune is running unopposed and is expected to win. Ron Johnson, Mike Lee and Rick Scott are pushing to judge him on how aggressive he is during the lame-duck period, and a delay vote is possible. Thune opposes that push. The hosts frame it as the same aggression-in-the-minority argument playing out in a different building.
What did the episode say about Trump and the midterm results?
The episode cites CNBC's Nov. 9 report that Trump questions midterm results and revives a voting-machine conspiracy. It also cites The Hill tying his complaint about the Senate getting nothing passed to the Johnson, Lee and Scott delay push. The hosts leave open whether election-doubt posts help or hurt the winner and who bears blame.
When is the next speaker vote, and how many votes are needed?
Per ABC News, the speaker vote is on Jan. 3, 2027, and a candidate needs 218 votes. The leadership elections in this episode use a secret ballot. Rush gave Scalise a B-minus, Reagan gave Jordan a B, and listeners are invited to vote on whose argument held up best.

Transcript

The full conversation

Every word of the episode, 3,134 of them, in the order they were said.

Read the transcriptHide the transcript

Rush LindellTuesday morning, folks. Somewhere in a house basement, a room full of Republicans is about to cast a secret ballot. Secret. In Washington. Nobody has ever kept a secret there, and they're gonna try it with a leadership vote.

ReaganRush, the secret part is the only reason anyone will tell the truth.

Rush LindellOh, I'll tell you the truth. I'm Rush Lindell, that's Reagan, and this show exists for mornings exactly like this one, and it's brought to you by Lear Capital, America's precious metals leader since 1997.

ReaganFine. The facts first. NPR, in a piece carried by GPB, reports that after sweeping midterm losses, House Republicans vote today to pick a successor to Mike Johnson.

Rush LindellWho says he's stepping down as the top Republican in the chamber.

ReaganSays. That's the word NPR used.

Rush LindellYou heard that pause, listener. Reagan doesn't believe in anything until it's notarized.

ReaganI believe in counting, which, for the record, is my entire argument today.

Rush LindellAnd mine is simple: brawler versus operator, a fighter or a bookkeeper. I know which one I'm picking.

ReaganAnd I'll be grading that pick, out loud, with a red pen.

Rush LindellHold on, hold on, be gentle.

ReaganNo.

Rush LindellFair. And somewhere behind all this, there's a pile of Trump posts about whether this election was even honest. Do they help the winner or sink them?

ReaganHold that thought. We'll get there.

Rush LindellBumper. First, who's actually on the ballot, and how does this vote even work?

ReaganRush, start with the plain facts. Two names are on the ballot: Steve Scalise and Jim Jordan.

Rush LindellAnd one name that isn't. Mike Johnson is not running. He stepped aside.

ReaganABC News laid out the day. A candidate forum starts at 9:00 this morning, and the leadership elections start at 1:30 this afternoon.

Rush LindellWho gets to vote?

ReaganOnly members who won on November 3rd. If you lost your seat, you're a spectator.

Rush LindellOh, man. Sweeping defeat, and the losers don't even get a ballot. Brutal.

ReaganIt is the rule, though. Now, resumes. Jordan was first elected in 2007, and he lost the 2023 speaker bid.

Rush LindellLost it. Noted.

ReaganScalise was first elected in 2008, and he has been the number two since 2023.

Rush LindellAnd he's in remission from multiple myeloma. Say that part out loud. That's a man who has been through something harder than a caucus meeting.

ReaganAgreed. It doesn't decide a leadership race, but nobody should skip it.

Rush LindellHere's what gets me. Whoever wins this thing is picked by people who just got through an election that went badly for them.

ReaganRight, and that's worth pausing on. The ones voting are the survivors, so the mood in that room is part of the contest, not just the resumes.

Rush LindellWait, so what's the actual difference between them? They're both Trump guys.

ReaganThey are. NBC News describes both as Trump allies, and both ran for speaker in 2023. But NBC calls Scalise Johnson's trusted lieutenant.

Rush LindellAnd Jordan?

ReaganThe Founding Freedom Caucus chairman.

Rush LindellThere it is. One is the lieutenant of the guy who just led them off a cliff. The other helped found the group that bites the leadership.

ReaganCareful, you're arguing before the segment starts.

Rush LindellFine, but I'm saying it now. Two guys, same side of the aisle, and it's still a rematch of 2023.

ReaganA rematch, yes. Both ran for speaker then, and both are back asking their colleagues for a promotion.

Rush LindellHold on, one more thing. Does today's winner become speaker?

ReaganNo. Whoever wins today leads the minority. The full House still votes on the speaker on January 3rd, 2027.

Rush LindellAnd that takes?

Reagan218 votes.

Rush LindellSo today is a warm-up, and nobody knows what happens on January 3rd. Fine. Bumper. I'm making the case for the fighter.

ReaganI'll be taking notes.

Rush LindellReagan, I'm gonna talk for a minute. Don't touch your pen.

ReaganNo promises.

Rush LindellAxios has the day-of reporting. Jordan is pitching himself as the change candidate, tapping the frustration over the midterm losses. Change, that's the whole product.

ReaganMm. And it's a decent product.

Rush LindellDecent? Oh, man, it's a siren. Think about the member who lost a neighbor's seat last week. He doesn't want a better spreadsheet. He wants somebody who walks into that room and says, "We got beaten, and we are done being polite about it."

ReaganOkay.

Rush LindellAnd NBC had a lawmaker backing Jordan, anonymous naturally, say the party needs a pivot. A pivot, not a tune-up, not a listening tour.

ReaganHold on. Anonymous?

Rush LindellSecret ballot, Reagan. Everybody's anonymous today.

ReaganFair. I'll give you that one.

Rush LindellHere's my case. You don't climb out of a desert by asking the desert nicely. Jordan fights. He fought the old order. He fights the press. He fights anybody holding a clipboard. You want a leader who makes the other side flinch or a leader who makes them a sandwich?

ReaganKeep going. I want the whole argument on the record.

Rush LindellGladly. Every time this party plays defense, the other side gets to write the story. Jordan doesn't take that deal. A conference that just got beaten doesn't need a mediator. It needs somebody who gives members a reason to get out of bed and be loud, and the loud ones are the ones who show up when it counts.

ReaganRush, that's a good speech.

Rush LindellI know.

ReaganAnd here's what you've got right. The base is angry, and a leader who ignores that anger is a leader who gets run over. Jordan reads that room better than anyone. The change pitch isn't a gimmick.

Rush LindellThank you.

ReaganNow the question you skipped. We're in the minority. Democrats run the floor. What does a fight actually accomplish there?

Rush LindellIt sets the terms.

ReaganOf what? You can't schedule a vote. You can't write the bills. A brawler with no gavel is a man shouting at a locked door.

Rush LindellLocked doors get kicked in.

ReaganBy whom? That takes votes, and the pivot lawmaker in NBC's story is one voice on a secret ballot.

Rush LindellOh, she's good.

ReaganI'm asking what the fight buys. Name one thing.

Rush LindellOversight, messaging, a reason for voters to show up in two years.

ReaganThose are real, but they all depend on holding the conference together, and that's counting, not shouting.

Rush LindellCounting. Thrilling radio.

ReaganThen let me make it thrilling. Give me my turn.

Rush LindellBumper, go count your votes.

ReaganFine. My turn, and I'll make it without a bullhorn. Axios has the day-of reporting, and it says Scalise allies are increasingly confident.

Rush LindellAllies of Scalise? Shocking. Next you'll tell me the bakery is bullish on bread.

ReaganThen listen to what one of them argues. Axios reports Representative Mario Diaz-Balart says the calls to delay the vote show Jordan lacks the votes.

Rush LindellHold on.

ReaganThink about it, Rush. If you have the votes, you vote today. You don't ask for more time.

Rush LindellOr you ask for time because you're building a movement, and movements take a minute.

ReaganMaybe. I'll concede that delay can be strategy, but Diaz-Balart goes one step further, and Axios says he argues only Scalise can appeal beyond the base.

Rush LindellBeyond the base? Reagan, the base is the only people who still return our calls.

ReaganThe base didn't win the swing seats. Those voters are the reason there's a minority to lead in the first place.

Rush LindellOoh.

ReaganAnd the job today isn't a rally. It's a room full of colleagues, and each of them has to believe you can count to a majority.

Rush LindellYou wanna know what that is? That's Steve "Spreadsheet" Scalise, the man who brings a calculator to a cage match.

ReaganI'll take it. A calculator has never lost a vote.

Rush LindellIt's never won a crowd either. Nobody ever got misty-eyed at a whip count.

ReaganNobody has to. They have to raise a hand, or mark a ballot in this case.

Rush LindellAnd what about the members who want the guy who yells? Some of that room has to feel that way.

ReaganSome do, and that's part of why it's tight, but even a leader who wins narrowly has to hold everybody together afterward. The job after the vote is keeping a divided conference pointed the same direction, and that's a different skill from winning applause.

Rush LindellFine. So who's winning?

ReaganAxios expects it to be tight.

Rush LindellTight how? Give me a number.

ReaganThere isn't one. It says the race is expected to be tight, and the winner needs a majority in the secret ballot.

Rush LindellWhich means every confident ally in this story could be wrong by lunch.

ReaganExactly. Confidence is a claim, and the ballot is the evidence.

Rush LindellOh, that's good. I'm stealing that for my fridge magnet line.

ReaganYou don't have a fridge magnet line.

Rush LindellI do now. Grade card, Reagan gets a B+ for the case and A- for making a bookkeeper sound sexy.

ReaganI'll live with a B+ from you.

Rush LindellYou better because the show needs a break. Bumper, time for the mid-show parody and a word from our sponsor.

ReaganPlease let the sponsor be real this time.

Rush LindellReagan, I've been saving this. Ladies and gentlemen, the House Republican search party. Cue the wind.

ReaganOh, no, we're doing the bit.

Rush LindellPicture it. Sand, heat, a caravan of exhausted Republicans, and two guides at the front, both waving a map.

ReaganLet me guess. Yours has a skull drawn on it.

Rush LindellJordan's guide pitch is simple. "Follow me. I don't know where the water is, but I will yell at the horizon until it appears."

ReaganFine. That's fair. Mine?

Rush LindellScalise pulls out a clipboard. "Folks, gather around. Before we walk, I'd like a head count of everyone who's still thirsty."

ReaganHey, in a desert, knowing who's still standing is useful.

Rush LindellHold on. A camel walks up.

ReaganOf course it does.

Rush LindellThe camel says, "Secret ballot?" And the whole caravan goes quiet. Nobody admits who they're backing.

ReaganOkay, that one landed. Wait, is that a mirage or a lawmaker who just changed his vote?

Rush LindellSame thing, Reagan. Same thing. And speaking of deserts and things that hold value out there...

ReaganOh, you did not just segue into the sponsor.

Rush LindellI did. My friends at Lear Capital are doing something I've never seen before. They're selling a one-ounce silver American Eagle below spot price. That's right, below what silver is actually trading for right now, and Lear is covering the shipping and taxes.

ReaganBelow spot. Okay, that actually got my attention. What's the catch?

Rush LindellPriced below spot. Lear is selling this at a loss to get silver in your hands. Limit one per person, new customers only, free shipping, fully insured by Lear, and this is a 24-hour offer only.

ReaganWhy does below spot matter so much?

Rush LindellBecause spot price doesn't include the cost to mint the coin, ship it, or any dealer overhead. Buying at spot is already a deal. Buying below spot almost never happens.

ReaganAnd it's the Eagle, not some mystery coin. Right.

Rush LindellThis isn't some obscure bullion piece. The silver American Eagle is one of the most recognizable and sought-after coins in the world, backed by the US government for weight and purity. One ounce of .999 fine silver, IRA-eligible, a tangible asset you can hold in your hand.

ReaganHold in your hand, unlike a House majority.

Rush LindellOuch. Go to www.rushcoinoffer.com right now. This is a 24-hour offer. The URL goes dark after that, and when it's gone, it's gone. That's www.rushcoinoffer.com.

ReaganOkay, back to our caravan. Did anyone ever find the oasis?

Rush LindellStill walking. Sand in the shoes and no oasis in sight. Bummer. Plot twist, Reagan. The Senate side is about the same fight.

ReaganWait, Thune?

Rush LindellThune. Okay, Senate side. Thune. Senate Republicans meet today to decide whether to keep him, a week after losing their majority.

ReaganAnd AP reports he's running unopposed. He's expected to win.

Rush LindellUnopposed? Reagan, that's not an election. That's a hostage video with a ballot box.

ReaganExcept AP also says senators could still seek a vote to delay, so the door isn't fully shut.

Rush LindellWho's knocking?

ReaganRon Johnson, Mike Lee, and Rick Scott. The Hill reports they want to postpone the vote.

Rush LindellOh, I like these guys.

ReaganYou would. They want a fuller discussion of what went wrong, and they want to judge Thune on how aggressively he runs the lame duck session.

Rush LindellHold on, so the vote waits until he proves he's a fighter. That's Jordan's whole pitch in a Senate costume.

ReaganFair, but Thune and his allies oppose a delay, and Thune himself says the leadership is moving ahead, and the decision belongs to Republican senators.

Rush LindellWhich is what every leader says right before he counts on the clock.

ReaganAnd there's a wrinkle. Two Senate races, Alaska and Mississippi, still haven't been called.

Rush LindellSo the Senate picture isn't even finished.

ReaganRight, though that's a separate question from who leads. NBC says Barrasso and Cotton are expected to keep the number two and number three jobs.

Rush LindellNo shakeup underneath them at all?

ReaganNot according to NBC. Same team, same chairs.

Rush LindellThen the delay crowd isn't really fighting over names. Nobody's running against Thune.

ReaganRight. They're fighting over tempo, how hard to push in the lame duck weeks before the gavel changes hands.

Rush LindellSame argument, different building. Over there, it's Thune and a calendar. Over here, it's Jordan and a ballot.

ReaganExcept the Senate has a Trump angle on top. The Hill ties the delay push to his complaint that the Senate is getting nothing passed.

Rush LindellAh, and now we're there.

ReaganBumper music, Rush.

Rush LindellBumper. Because hanging over all of it, every ballot, every senator, every gripe, is one guy with a phone. Trump. Okay. The president weighs in on every one of these fights, so what's the latest?

ReaganNow, CNBC reports he's questioning the midterm results and reviving a voting machine conspiracy theory.

Rush LindellOh, man, a voting machine conspiracy. Eh, that one comes with a lot of mileage on it.

ReaganThe CNBC story is dated November ninth, and it's worth saying what it actually reports. He's questioning the results and bringing back the machine theory. That's all I'll claim.

Rush LindellFine. That's plenty. Reagan, tell me how that helps whoever wins this afternoon.

ReaganIt doesn't, Rush. Not if you're Scalise and not if you're Jordan. Whoever wins has to build a message about why voters rejected the party, and a boss who says the vote was rigged hands that message to the other side.

Rush LindellSee, I think you're underrating the base. They like it when he swings.

ReaganThey like him swinging at Democrats. They also have to win swing districts again.

Rush LindellHmm.

ReaganAnd think about the new leader, too. Whoever wins this afternoon will be asked about every one of those posts in front of the swing voters the party needs back, and there's the second front. The Hill reports Trump recently complained the Senate is getting nothing passed.

Rush LindellWhich sounds a lot like what Ron Johnson, Mike Lee, and Rick Scott want, a delay on the Thune vote.

ReaganCareful. The Hill ties the delay push to that complaint. That's The Hill's reporting, not the senators' own stated reasoning, so I wouldn't put words in their mouths. But the family fight isn't only House versus Senate. It's the president grumbling from outside while both chambers argue about how hard to swing.

Rush LindellWho takes the blame? I say Trump gets the first slap. He's the one lobbing grenades while his own people try to pick a leader.

ReaganI'd spread it around. Rush, you can't tell me a minority leader who wants to be noticed doesn't enjoy a president who changes the subject.

Rush LindellOoh, that's the nastiest thing you've said all day.

ReaganI'm only asking whether a leader gets rewarded for cleaning up after him or for staying out of the way.

Rush LindellJordan cleans up loud. Scalise cleans up quiet. Which one does Trump tolerate?

ReaganI honestly don't know. Trump posts, and a leader gets asked about it on every Sunday show. Either way, they have to answer the same question. Do you defend the claim, dodge it, or change the subject?

Rush LindellNo way you're leaving that open.

ReaganI am. Listeners can sort it out. Does it help or hurt whoever wins?

Rush LindellSend us your answer. I've got mine, and it's loud.

ReaganOf course it is.

Rush LindellBumper. Final scorecards, then it's your call. Scorecards. Reagan, you gave me a B-plus for the case. Fun. Now I grade yours. Scalise gets a B- from me, and I'm being generous because he's nice to staffers.

ReaganA B-? For the man who counts the votes?

Rush LindellOne-line verdict: He wins every room that has no cameras in it.

ReaganFair, and I'll take it. My grade for Jordan is a B. The anger is real. The base wants him, and I'll give him that. My verdict: He's the best argument for a fight and the weakest argument for a majority.

Rush LindellOoh.

ReaganYou asked for a verdict.

Rush LindellI did. I regret nothing.

ReaganAnd remember, today's result comes by secret ballot. Nobody has to say out loud how they voted.

Rush LindellWhich means everybody gets to be brave in private. Oh, man, my favorite kind of courage.

ReaganThen there's the bigger vote. The full House picks the speaker on January third, twenty twenty-seven, and ABC News reported that takes two hundred and eighteen votes.

Rush LindellSo today is the warm-up lap.

ReaganA warm-up where the winner learns whether the base will actually follow him.

Rush LindellHold on. Listener, this part is yours. Who won the argument today, the fighter or the vote counter, me or Reagan?

ReaganBe honest with it. Don't vote on who sounds louder. Vote on whose argument held up best, even if it was mine.

Rush LindellVote for the louder one. That's me, obviously.

ReaganObviously.

Rush LindellCast your ballot, and unlike the House, we'll let you do it with your name on it. Bumper, then the sign-off. Reagan, the camel never got an answer.

ReaganWait, he's still out there?

Rush LindellStanding in the sand, waiting on a ruling. Somebody check on him.

ReaganHe'll keep waiting. Today's ballot settles the House leader, but not what comes after it.

Rush LindellAnd you know where to vote, listener. Reagan, give the people a closer, something with a little principle in it.

ReaganGladly. Winning a leadership vote is the easy part of a comeback. The hard part is deciding what the party is for once the voting stops. I'd ask for fights that mean something and counts that actually hold. That's the standard worth holding them to, whoever gets the job.

Rush LindellNow, the housekeeping. Subscribe wherever you get your shows.

ReaganLeave a five-star review. It takes one minute, and it helps more than you think.

Rush LindellAnd tell a friend. Drag one person out of the desert with you.

ReaganNew episodes every weekday.

Rush LindellHydrate, folks. If you see a mirage, check the vote count first.

ReaganMm, fair enough, Rush.

Rush LindellI'm Rush Lindell. We'll see you tomorrow.

More episodes

Keep listening

Other episodes of The Rush Lindell Show, newest first.

All episodes of The Rush Lindell Show

Sources

Where this came from

7 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.