Mato just raised pre-seed Read more

Thursday: The Brawler Won and Democrats Said Lawyer Up

  • Nov 12, 2026
  • 19 min

Show notes

What the episode covers

On Thursday, November 12, House Republicans buried the Hegseth impeachment 211-204, and the leadership fights behind it are only getting louder.

Jordan over Scalise. The House conference picked a fighter, 106-73, and Jordan's minority job is to shield Trump. Thune stays. He kept the Senate gavel by acclamation, but 15 senators voted to delay. Lawyer up. The White House letter to incoming Oversight chair Garcia, and his reply, show how the subpoena fight will start. Hegseth, round two? A January revival hinges on attendance and on a hedged report of 11 absent Democrats.

Rush Lindell and Reagan also grade last Tuesday's predictions, each other's included. Rush claims an A. Reagan has the math, and it is less flattering.

Sponsored by Lear Capital.

Now it's your turn: who actually won this argument, the gloater or the calculator? Cast your vote and tell us what you think.

📣 We Want to Hear from You!

Timeline

In this episode

9 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.

  1. 0:15Introduction
  2. 1:37Jordan Over Scalise, 106-73
  3. 4:04Thune Survives the Daylong Fight
  4. 6:24Mid-Show Parody and Sponsor: The Leadership Fight Club
  5. 9:11The Turn: Lawyer Up
  6. 12:40The Subpoena Cannon in Practice
  7. 14:12Hegseth Impeachment Buried 211-204
  8. 16:39Scorecards: Who Called It Better?
  9. 18:09Outro

Quick answers

Straight from the episode

The questions this one settles, without the listen.

What was the vote count when Jim Jordan beat Steve Scalise?
Jordan beat Scalise 106-73 on Nov 10, a 33-vote margin. The hosts noted that 73 Republicans still backed Scalise, and Reagan said the conference wanted a fighter. Reagan framed Jordan's minority job as acting as Trump's shield.
How did John Thune keep his Senate leadership job?
Thune was re-elected by acclamation after hours of debate. He had no challenger. Fifteen senators voted to delay the election, roughly a third of the next conference. Johnson demanded the delay and Hawley joined. Senators also blamed Trump's unpopularity for the midterm losses.
What did the Scharf letter to Robert Garcia say, and how did Garcia respond?
The Nov. 9 letter to incoming Oversight chair Garcia argued that committee investigations are limited to a legislative purpose and warned of criminal exposure. Garcia replied 'Lawyer up' and made a separation-of-powers response. NBC noted that courts rarely stop broad committee authority. Jeffries called the letter outrageous and factually inaccurate. Reagan conceded the legislative-purpose point but said the letter works as a threat whose leverage is pressure, not courtroom wins.
What does a Democratic-controlled House mean for subpoenas and investigations?
Citing CBS News, the hosts said a Democratic Congress means more investigations, a struggle to confirm nominees, and maybe some bipartisanship. Reagan tied this to Garcia's vow to keep investigating and the possible January revival of Hegseth impeachment articles, while hedging and not naming invented targets.
What happened with the Hegseth impeachment resolution?
Massie's eight-article resolution to impeach Hegseth was defeated 211-204 and referred to the Judiciary Committee. TIME read the result as Trump still holding House Republicans. Latin Times reported 11 Democrats were absent, which is hedged and unconfirmed. Democrats could force another vote in January, and Hegseth would be only the third Cabinet secretary impeached.
How did the hosts grade each other's predictions?
Both hosts leaned toward the fighter and Thune keeping the gavel. Rush gave Reagan a B-plus. Reagan gave Rush a pass on outcome but an incomplete on process, citing the 33-vote margin, the acclamation and the 15 delay votes.

Transcript

The full conversation

Every word of the episode, 2,847 of them, in the order they were said.

Read the transcriptHide the transcript

Rush LindellThe brawler won. Say it with me, one listener at a time. The brawler won.

ReaganRush, you've been warming up that line since Tuesday.

Rush LindellSince the second the votes came in. Oh, man, I haven't felt this good since... Actually, I don't remember. Let me enjoy it.

ReaganEnjoy it. I'll be counting.

Rush LindellOf course you will. I'm Rush Limbaugh. She's Reagan, and this is the show where one of us gloats and the other one brings a calculator.

ReaganSomebody has to.

Rush LindellAnd before the calculator comes out, a word from our sponsor, brought to you by Lear Capital, America's precious metals leader since 1997.

ReaganSmooth. Very smooth.

Rush LindellI've been practicing.

ReaganSo here's the job today. We grade last Tuesday's picks, each other's predictions included.

Rush LindellOh, mine's gonna be an A. Hold on. I'll hand you a pen for yours.

ReaganKeep the pen. And then you get a vote, listener. You decide who actually won this argument.

Rush LindellWhich will be me, obviously.

ReaganWe'll see what the count says.

Rush LindellBumper music, please. Start with the House vote that Jordan won.

ReaganNumbers first, Rush. Always numbers first. The gloating can wait until the grades are in, and we'll see who's gloating then.

Rush LindellHundred and six to 73. Say it slowly, Reagan. Savor it.

ReaganI'll say it accurately. House Republicans picked Jim Jordan over Steve Scalise 106 to 73 on Tuesday, November 10th.

Rush LindellAccurately. She says accurately like it's a medical term.

ReaganAnd note Axioss' framing. Scalise is the majority leader Jordan beat. That title is the oddity because the majority is exactly what Republicans are about to lose.

Rush LindellOh, man. Don't spoil my morning.

ReaganI'm not. Your side of it holds up. Jordan won by 33 votes. That's not a squeaker. That's a conference telling you what it wants.

Rush LindellAnd what does it want?

ReaganSomeone who fights. I'll give you that completely.

Rush LindellWrite it down. She gave me that completely.

ReaganI also have a second sentence. Fighting for whom, Rush?

Rush LindellOh, here it comes.

ReaganThink about what a minority leader does. He can't pass anything. He can't schedule anything. What he can do is stand between the president and whatever the other side drags into a hearing room.

Rush LindellA shield.

ReaganA shield. Jordan's job is to be Trump's shield, and the 106 members who voted for him know it.

Rush LindellGood. A shield with a loud voice and a bad attitude. I want that guy.

ReaganSure. But a shield gets hit constantly.

Rush LindellThat's what it's for. Nobody's ever complained a shield got too much use.

ReaganFair. Fine, that one's yours.

Rush LindellAnd the 73 who backed Scalise? Sore losers?

ReaganSeventy-three people is a real chunk of the conference, Rush. Those members still sit in the same room, and Jordan has to lead them, too.

Rush LindellLeading them is easy. Point at the Democrats and say, "That's the enemy."

ReaganThat works until it doesn't. A conference that just lost its majority has plenty of reasons to argue, and a common enemy is the cheapest glue there is.

Rush LindellCheap glue holds. Ask anybody who's built a model airplane.

ReaganAnd ask anyone who's inhaled it. Let's keep going.

Rush LindellHold on. Let me enjoy it. Jordan hates being polite. Democrats are about to find that out, and the whole thing starts in January.

ReaganNot quite. They've got a lot of paperwork to get through before the gavel changes hands.

Rush LindellPaperwork. Reagan, that's a subpoena with a stapler.

ReaganOkay, that's good.

Rush LindellBumper. Now the Senate, where the leaders' fight lasted all day. Reagan, you wanted to count. Count the Senate, because I heard it took all day, and the man still walked out holding the gavel.

ReaganHe did. Thune was reelected by acclamation, Rush, but that came after hours of contentious debate, according to The Hill's reporting.

Rush LindellAcclamation, after hours of yelling. That's a family dinner.

ReaganHere's the number. 15 Republican senators voted to delay the election.

Rush Lindell15.

ReaganRoughly a third of the next GOP conference.

Rush LindellOh, man. A third of the room wanted to hit pause on the boss.

ReaganAnd pause is the operative word. Ron Johnson demanded the delay, and Josh Hawley joined the calls.

Rush LindellHawley. Of course he did. Show me a microphone, and I'll show you Hawley.

ReaganFair, but notice what happened next. No challenger stood up.

Rush LindellWait, wait. Nobody?

ReaganNobody. 15 people wanted more time, and not one put his name against Thune.

Rush LindellThat's a brawl where everybody showed up to the bar and nobody threw a punch.

ReaganOr they know you can't beat somebody with nobody. I'd say that's the sober read.

Rush LindellFine. I'll give you that. So what did the delay crowd actually want?

ReaganCritics pressed for a lame duck reconciliation bill, and they wanted the SAVE America Act.

Rush LindellBefore the new Congress sits. Squeeze it through while you still hold the cards.

ReaganRight. And there's a second argument underneath. Many GOP senators blame the midterm wipeout on Trump's unpopularity.

Rush LindellHold on. Say that again, because that's a spicy one.

ReaganMany of them think Trump's unpopularity cost them the midterms.

Rush LindellOut loud, in a room with a vote.

ReaganIn a room where the leader they just kept is the one standing between them and a very angry president.

Rush LindellOoh, that's a nice job. Thune gets the title. 15 colleagues who wanted a delay And a conference that blames the boss.

ReaganCongratulations all around.

Rush LindellYou ready for what comes next? 'Cause the other side has been sharpening knives while we sat here.

ReaganThey have. But first, Rush, we owe people some silliness.

Rush LindellBumper. Time for the mid-show parody, then a word from the sponsor. Reagan, I've been sitting on something, a mock briefing. Leadership Fight Club. You get a folder, I get a mouth guard.

ReaganOf course you do. Go ahead, Rush.

Rush LindellRule one of Leadership Fight Club, you do not talk about Leadership Fight Club. Rule two, you do talk about it, loudly, on cable, for hours.

ReaganAnd the punching?

Rush LindellNobody throws one. That's rule three. Everybody walks in, rolls up their sleeves, and then somebody raises a hand and says, "Point of order, can we delay?"

ReaganWait for it.

Rush LindellRule four, the delay motion is a sacred object. You pass it around the circle like a casserole nobody ordered.

ReaganAnd rule five is the snacks are in committee.

Rush LindellRule five, correct. Last rule, if this is your first night, you have to hold a press gaggle.

ReaganFine, that's funny. I'm keeping the folder, though. Somebody in this building has to file the minutes.

Rush LindellKeep it. Now, speaking of things that hold their value while Washington argues about a casserole.

ReaganOh, no. Here it comes.

Rush LindellReagan, my friends at Lear Capital are doing something I've never seen before. They're selling a one-ounce silver American Eagle below spot price.

ReaganBelow spot?

Rush LindellThat's right, below what silver is actually trading for right now, and Lear is covering the shipping and taxes.

ReaganOkay, what's the catch?

Rush LindellHere's what you need to know. It's priced below spot. Lear is selling this at a loss to get silver in your hands. Limit one per person, new customers only.

ReaganAnd shipping?

Rush LindellFree, fully insured by Lear. And this is a 24-hour offer only. Just so you understand how rare this is, spot price doesn't include the cost to mint the coin, ship it, or any dealer overhead. Buying at spot is already a deal. Buying below spot almost never happens.

ReaganI'll admit, I like a tangible thing.

Rush LindellYou and me both. This isn't some obscure bullion piece. The silver American Eagle is one of the most recognizable and sought-after coins in the world, backed by the US government for weight and purity. One ounce of .999 fine silver, IRA-eligible, a tangible asset you can hold in your hand.

ReaganWhere do people go?

Rush LindellGo to www.rushcoinoffer.com right now. This is a 24-hour offer. The URL goes dark after that, and when it's gone, it's gone. That's www.rushcoinoffer.com.

ReaganGot it. Now, Rush, we have a letter to get to.

Rush LindellThe White House one, the one that sounds like a threat with a postage stamp.

ReaganBumper, then the main event.

Rush LindellOkay, so the letter. A White House lawyer writes to a congressman who hasn't even been sworn in as chairman yet, and the message is basically, "Nice subpoena pad. Shame if somebody investigated you back."

ReaganWho's the lawyer, though? Name him.

Rush LindellWill Scharf, White House Counsel, dated November 9th, addressed to Robert Garcia, the incoming oversight chair.

ReaganPunchbowl News had the first report. It says the letter argues Congress can investigate only for a legislative purpose, and that Democratic probes could cross into criminality.

Rush LindellCriminality? Reagan, they're not even in the building, and the lawyers are already reading them their rights.

ReaganPunchbowl called the claim audacious, and it noted there's broad precedent for congressional investigations. That part matters.

Rush LindellAudacious is a polite word for it, and Garcia's reply, two words.

ReaganGo ahead.

Rush LindellLawyer up.

ReaganOkay. That's a good line. I'll give him that.

Rush LindellHold on, you're supposed to be the skeptic.

ReaganI am, of the letter. NBC News got it from the White House, and it cites Supreme Court rulings saying a probe needs a legitimate legislative purpose and can't be used to punish opponents.

Rush LindellWhich is true.

ReaganIt is true. That's the strongest piece of the argument, and I won't pretend otherwise. But NBC also notes that committees of both parties have broad investigative authority, and courts rarely stop them.

Rush LindellRarely, not never.

ReaganRush, rarely is carrying a lot of weight in that sentence, and not in your favor.

Rush LindellSo you're telling me the White House has no case? Counter-investigate the investigators. That's the play. You go after the people holding the shovel.

ReaganI'm telling you a legal principle and a threat aren't the same document. Which one is this?

Rush LindellBoth. That's the beauty of it.

ReaganHmm. And what does Garcia say to the legal part?

Rush LindellSeparation of powers. Democrats will keep investigating. Done.

ReaganHe's invoking the same doctrine the White House is leaning on, just pointed the other direction. Congress is a co-equal branch, the argument goes, and the executive doesn't get to supervise it.

Rush LindellAnd Hakeem Jeffries?

ReaganCalled the letter outrageous and factually inaccurate.

Rush LindellOutrageous and factually inaccurate. That's two adjectives and zero concessions. I respect the discipline.

ReaganLet me press on the counter-investigation idea, Rush. What would it even look like in practice?

Rush LindellSame thing they'd do to us. Letters, document requests, hearings about the people holding the hearings.

ReaganAnd the White House is a different kind of player than a committee. The letter's whole theory is that Democratic probes could cross into criminality. That's a heavy word to put in writing to a congressman.

Rush LindellHeavy words are the point. You want him to think twice before he signs the first subpoena.

ReaganWhich is why I call it a threat as much as a legal argument. And since courts rarely stop committee investigations, the practical leverage isn't in a courtroom. It's in the pressure.

Rush LindellPressure works. Ask any lawyer.

ReaganAsk Garcia. His answer was two words and a doctrine, and he didn't blink.

Rush LindellHe sure didn't.

ReaganFair, but notice nobody in that exchange has subpoenaed anything yet.

Rush LindellGive them time. They've got a calendar and a grudge.

ReaganBumper. So what does a Democratic Congress actually do with the subpoena machine once it's switched on?

Rush LindellOkay, Reagan, picture it. Democrats take the gavels, and the subpoena cannon rolls out of storage, wheels squeaking, somebody's wiping the dust off the barrel.

ReaganCannon, sure. CBS News ran a piece on what Trump's last two years look like with Democrats in charge, and it boils down to three items.

Rush LindellThree. Hit me.

ReaganInvestigations, a struggle to confirm nominees, and maybe some bipartisanship.

Rush LindellMaybe some bipartisanship. Hold on. That's the line they slipped in at the end, like a mint on the pillow.

ReaganIt's in there. CBS wrote it with a maybe, and I'd keep the maybe.

Rush LindellYou'd keep it? I'd frame it and hang it next to the Fight Club rules.

ReaganFine, but the first item isn't a mystery. Garcia has already said he's going to keep investigating, and the letter didn't change that.

Rush LindellNo, it handed him a fundraising email.

ReaganProbably. The Hegseth articles are the other piece. They could come back in January, and I want to be careful there. I can't tell you they will. I can tell you nothing I've read rules it out.

Rush LindellCareful, Reagan. You sound like a woman who's been burned by a prediction.

ReaganBy one of yours, mostly.

Rush LindellOh, that's cold. I love it.

ReaganAnd no targets. No names, no dates from me. CBS lays out the shape. Nobody's published the witness list.

Rush LindellSo the cannon's loaded, and nobody knows where it's pointed, which is the scariest kind of cannon.

ReaganHmm, fair enough.

Rush LindellBumper, one more vote, the Hegseth impeachment. Okay, the Hegseth vote, two-eleven to two-oh-four. Dead on arrival, and nobody had to lift a finger.

ReaganWell, somebody lifted a finger. Thomas Massie's resolution had eight articles against Hegseth, and it went down anyway.

Rush LindellEight? Eight articles, and the thing still sank like a cinder block.

ReaganTIME reads that vote as proof Trump still has a hold on House Republicans, even after the midterm losses. I'd say that's fair. The party just lost the chamber and still voted as one bloc.

Rush LindellOh, man, and that's my whole point. Brawler's in charge. Nobody wants to cross him.

ReaganRush, I'll give you that one, but look at the margin before you throw a parade.

Rush LindellSeven votes. I can do math, Reagan.

ReaganSeven votes, and the Latin Times reports 11 House Democrats didn't vote at all. Their own leadership backed the effort.

Rush LindellWait, 11? 11 Democrats just wandered off?

ReaganThat's one outlet. Latin Times is a secondary source, so I'd treat the 11 as a report until somebody checks it against the official roll call.

Rush LindellFine, fine, but if it holds up, that's the funniest thing I've heard all week. You're trying to impeach a cabinet secretary, and your own side goes to get coffee?

ReaganAnd it matters for the arithmetic. Seven votes is a margin 11 missing members could cover.

Rush LindellHuh. So the absent Democrats are the story.

ReaganOne piece of it. The Latin Times also says the articles went to the Judiciary Committee, which effectively ends them for this Congress.

Rush LindellBuried. Shovel, dirt, little headstone.

ReaganExcept TIME says Democrats could force another vote once they take control in January. Hegseth would be only the third cabinet secretary ever impeached.

Rush LindellThird ever. That's a club nobody wants a jacket from.

ReaganExactly. So the vote that looked like an ending may just be a preview.

Rush LindellA preview with a seven-vote margin and a coffee break caucus. That's a sequel I'd buy a ticket for.

ReaganIf the 11 holds up, and that's an if, a second vote could look different, but all of that depends on who actually shows up in January.

Rush LindellWhich means everybody's been predicting things all week, and somebody's about to get graded for it.

ReaganYou've been waiting on that all week, haven't you?

Rush LindellSince Tuesday. Bumper, time to hand out grades. Report cards, Reagan. Mine first, because I'm the one holding the red pen. We both leaned toward the fighter, and the fighter won, 106 to 73. That's a pass. I'll even give you a B+ for being right and polite about it.

ReaganI'll take the B+, but the margin was 33 votes, Rush. We ended up in the same place. You just got there louder.

Rush LindellLouder is a skill.

ReaganIt's a skill. It's not a grade. Now yours. We both leaned toward Thune keeping the gavel, and he did, by acclamation. I'll give you the pass on the outcome.

Rush LindellSurvived. Still holding it.

ReaganBut 15 senators voted to delay, so I'm giving you an incomplete on the process.

Rush LindellAn incomplete? Oh, man, I've never been so insulted by a polite woman.

ReaganAnd a leader who wins with roughly a third of the conference wanting a pause is on a short leash.

Rush LindellShort leash, long bark. I like him.

ReaganSo we both got the winners. We just disagree about how loudly to celebrate.

Rush LindellI'm gonna celebrate until somebody turns off my microphone.

ReaganWhich is why the listeners get a vote. Who called it better? Rush with the swagger, or me with the arithmetic and the leash?

Rush LindellVote for me. Vote early. Tell your friends. Tell your mother. Tell the guy at the diner who doesn't care.

ReaganOr vote with the numbers. They're sitting right there.

Rush LindellBumper, last word. Well, Reagan, the red pen is capped. The brawler won, Thune kept the gavel, and I'm still not reading it twice.

ReaganAnd I'm still counting. Subscribe, leave a five-star review, and tell one friend who argues about politics at dinner. New episodes land every weekday.

Rush LindellYou heard the vote pitch, listener. Cast it and make it loud.

ReaganAnd make it honest.

Rush LindellNext time, we're back with a fresh batch of Washington's finest and a fresh batch of my opinions.

ReaganFair warning on the opinions.

Rush LindellBumper, please. Good night, everybody, and thanks for listening.

More episodes

Keep listening

Other episodes of The Rush Lindell Show, newest first.

All episodes of The Rush Lindell Show

Sources

Where this came from

7 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.