LC 47: The Dec. 11 CR Cliff and Artemis III
Show notes
What the episode covers
November 18, 2026: The Senate Commerce-Justice-Science subcommittee has proposed $24.874 billion for NASA, while a continuing resolution holding the agency at $24.4 billion expires December 11. Max and Blake on Landing the Moon examine what that gap means for Artemis.
Topics covered:
- The Senate report's SLS funding, about $2.5 billion across two separate buckets, and Congress again rejecting the $18.8 billion request's science cuts
- The Artemis III SLS core stage, mated to its boosters in October, and the planned roll to Pad 39B for a core-stage-only tanking test
- How a freeze, a deal or a shutdown could affect Artemis III, Artemis IV and the Moon Base
The hosts disagree on the main risk. Blake argues a long stopgap, with no new starts and room for OMB spending drift, is the quiet schedule threat. Max argues hardware keeps moving regardless. Both agree the late-2026 tanking test date is still soft. They also score earlier LC 45 scenarios against current events.
Watch for: any revised date for the tanking test, and whether appropriators move toward a short stopgap before December 11.
Timeline
In this episode
8 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.
- 0:15Introduction
- 1:34The Senate Number: $24.874B and SLS
- 3:39Appropriators Far Apart, Stopgap Likely
- 6:39Blake: The Long CR Is the Quiet Risk
- 9:50Max: The Tanking Test Won't Wait
- 13:10Scoring LC 45 Against This Week
- 15:56Freeze, Deal or Shutdown: Artemis III, IV and the Moon Base
- 18:38Outro
Quick answers
Straight from the episode
The questions this one settles, without the listen.
- How much does the Senate appropriations bill give NASA's SLS rocket?
- The Senate CJS report has $1.495B for SLS plus $1.025B in reconciliation money, about $2.5B total. They are two separate buckets, so the headline number undercounts. The Senate's overall NASA figure is roughly $24.9B (about $24.874B, per SpacePolicyOnline), versus the $18.8B administration request.
- Will there be a government stopgap (continuing resolution) instead of a full NASA budget?
- A stopgap looks likely. The House has passed three of twelve FY27 bills and the Senate none. DeLauro says a CR is most likely, Murray favors a short CR into January, and Rounds expects February or March. Collins is pushing separate bills toward an omnibus.
- Why could a long continuing resolution be risky for NASA and Artemis?
- Blake argues that a CR at about $24.4B means no new starts, meaning lines the last bill never funded can't begin. It also gives OMB room to drift spending toward the $18.8B request without a vote. The hosts stress this is a theory of risk, not an observed delay.
- What is OMB underspending and why does it matter?
- It is the concern that OMB could slow spending toward the lower $18.8B request instead of the higher congressional number. A cut needs a vote, but a drift doesn't. The episode flags this as a possibility, not something observed.
- What is the status of the Artemis III SLS core stage and the tanking test?
- NASA says the Artemis III core stage mates to its boosters in October, then rolls to Pad 39B for a core-stage-only tanking test, a procedure rehearsal. New Space Economy reports the late-2026 target has no revised date, so the test can proceed while its timing stays soft.
- How might the midterm elections affect NASA funding?
- Per NASA Watch (Nov 4), Democrats gain the committees that fund NASA, NOAA and Space Force. That supports the argument for a short CR into January, so incoming Democrats have leverage. The hosts scored their earlier prediction as a hit on a CR, partial on an omnibus and a hybrid, with no misses.
Transcript
The full conversation
Every word of the episode, 3,135 of them, in the order they were said.
Read the transcriptHide the transcript
MaxOkay, so get this. December 11th, that's the day NASA's money runs out, and two numbers are fighting over it.
Blake$24.4 billion and 24.874.
MaxDude, you said it like a hostage negotiation.
BlakeIt kinda is.
MaxWelcome to Landing the Moon. I'm Max, that's Blake, and it's November 18th, 2026.
BlakeThe first number is what a continuing resolution, a CR, is holding NASA at right now. That stopgap expires December 11th.
MaxAnd the second?
BlakeThe Senate Commerce Justice Science Subcommittee, CJS, proposed it for NASA. Space Policy Online reported the report came out November 12th.
MaxWait for it, because Blake thinks the boring stopgap is the villain.
BlakeA long CR is the quiet schedule risk, Max. Nobody films that one.
MaxMeanwhile, I say hardware doesn't check the congressional calendar. Tanks get tested either way.
BlakeThen we'll see who's right. We also owe people a scorecard on LC-45 scenarios.
MaxOh, you're gonna love that part. But first, let's lay out what the Senate actually put on the table.
BlakeStarting with that bigger number and what's inside it.
MaxInside that $24.874 billion, the Senate subcommittee carves out $1.495 billion just for the SLS. That's the big orange rocket.
BlakeAnd that's not the whole SLS pot.
MaxNot even close. There's another $1.025 billion sitting on top of it from reconciliation money.
BlakeReconciliation meaning the earlier big budget bill. So SLS gets two buckets, and the committee number only shows you one of them.
MaxRight. Add them up and it's roughly $2.5 billion aimed at one rocket.
BlakeWhich is a lot of rocket per dollar of headline.
MaxWait for it, because Blake has a spreadsheet face on.
BlakeI do, because Space Policy Online, which wrote at the report after it came out November 12th, said the subcommittee recommended about $24.9 billion for the agency. Rounded, that's a bump. A bump from what, though?
MaxFrom the freeze and from the request, which is the funny part.
BlakeFunny is generous. The administration asked for $18.8 billion.
Max18.8 against 24 point something.
BlakeAnd the Ace of Space newsletter put the sharpest point on it. For the second year running, Congress has refused the White House plan to nearly half NASA science.
MaxTwo years in a row. Go, Congress.
BlakeHold on. That same newsletter adds the part people skip. Refused isn't the same as funded.
MaxOh, that's good, because nobody's cutting a check yet.
BlakeExactly. A committee saying no to the cut is a statement of intent. The money only moves when a bill passes, and the White House still has that $18.8 billion request on the books as its preference.
MaxAnd an agency that prefers a smaller number has ways to get there without a vote, right?
BlakeHold that thought. I'm saving it for my side of the argument.
MaxOf course you are.
BlakeSo the Senate has a number with a nice SLS line in it and a pointed rebuke of the request.
MaxWhich sounds like a win until you remember the calendar.
BlakeA number in a committee report isn't a law.
MaxSo who's actually getting a bill done? Okay, so get this. 12 spending bills for the year, and the whole building has finished almost none of them.
BlakeQuantify almost none.
MaxA law firm analysis on Lexology says the House has passed three of the 12 FY27 bills. The Senate has passed none.
BlakeNone.
MaxZero. Not a rounding error, an actual zero.
BlakeSo the Senate subcommittee number we just went through is a very nice number attached to no bill at all.
MaxPlot twist, the one thing that does move is the stopgap. Senator Murray is pushing another one.
BlakeHow long?
MaxShort. The Lexology piece says she favors a CR into January, and The Hill has her publicly pushing a short-term CR at current levels into early next year.
BlakeWhy would a Democrat want the short one? That's the part I had once sourced.
MaxLeverage. The Lexology analysis says a short CR gives the incoming Democratic appropriators more leverage. Wait for it. The midterms flipped who holds the gavels.
BlakeAh. So January isn't a deadline, it's a countdown to a better seat at the table.
MaxAnd it may not even be a clean stopgap. Lexology flags a possible fight over war powers riders getting stapled onto it.
BlakeRiders on a CR. Of course.
MaxExplain why that matters for a stopgap.
BlakeA rider is policy language attached to a bill that has to pass. If the stopgap is the only thing moving, then whatever rides on it gets a free trip, and that's why people fight over it.
MaxOh, and The Hill says there are disputes over Iran war demands and a leadership fight among Democrats, which complicates shutdown talks.
BlakeHmm. What about the people who actually write the bills?
MaxSplit. DeLauro told Democrats a CR is the most likely outcome.
BlakeWhich is the top House Democrat on appropriations saying the quiet part to her own caucus.
MaxMeanwhile, Senator Collins is still pursuing separate bills hoping for a larger omnibus.
BlakeHold on. One side is planning for a stopgap and the other is chasing the big package. Those aren't the same finish line.
MaxRight. Top appropriators far apart, like I said earlier.
BlakeAnd then there's how long the stopgap runs. Anybody put a date on that?
MaxSenator Rounds. He expects it to run into February or March.
BlakeFebruary or March, not January.
MaxWhich is a month or two past what Murray wants. Funny how everybody's short stretches.
BlakeEvery temporary measure is temporary until it isn't.
MaxAnd in plain terms, what does a CR actually do?
BlakeIt keeps agencies running at last year's rate so the lights stay on. That's the whole trick. No new number, no new vote, just a reset of the clock. The catch is that the clock keeps coming due.
MaxSo the vote you'd expect to be the cliff, the big up or down on a number, may never happen.
BlakeAnd that's the part that bothers me, Max. Nobody votes against a stopgap on principle, so nobody fights about what it quietly freezes.
MaxOkay, now you're making the case for your own segment. Go. Here's a nice beat.
BlakeMax, let me start with the mechanics. A CR at current levels holds NASA at twenty-four point four billion. Nothing falls off a cliff on day one. The money keeps flowing at last year's pace.
MaxSounds fine. Boring even.
BlakeBoring is the danger. A flat rate means no new starts. Anything that wasn't already running last year can't begin, even if the Senate wants it.
MaxHmm.
BlakeAnd there's a second piece. OMB, the White House budget office, controls how fast agencies actually spend. Under a long stopgap, it has room to drift spending toward the eighteen point eight billion request.
MaxDrift, not cut.
BlakeRight, and that's what makes it quiet. Nobody votes on the drift. Nobody has to own it.
MaxOkay, so get this. You're building a villain out of an absence. Nothing happens, and that's the crime.
BlakeFair. So I'll test my own claim. Walk the math with me. Flat twenty-four point four billion against a Senate number of twenty-four point eight seven four billion. The gap between those is the amount the stopgap can't deliver.
MaxThat's about half a billion dollars.
BlakeRoughly, yes. On a budget that size, it sounds small, which is why I'd ask the other question. What does flat protect and what can't it start?
MaxGo on. I'm curious which side you land on.
BlakeFlat protects everything already in motion: contracts, staff, the work underway. It cannot start something new, and a new line is exactly what a growing program needs.
MaxHmm. Name one.
BlakeI can't name one with a date on it. That's my honest weak spot. I'm describing a mechanism, not a measured delay.
MaxHa, there it is.
BlakeI gave you that one for free.
MaxAnd I'll take it. This is a theory of risk. Nobody's clocked a single week lost to the freeze yet. You're pricing a storm that hasn't got a name.
BlakeSure, but the risk compounds. A stopgap that ends in January is a shrug. One that runs deep into spring changes what can be planned.
MaxIf OMB actually underspends, that's an if with a lot of weight on it.
BlakeAgreed. It's an if. I'm saying the room exists, and the longer the CR, the bigger the room.
MaxFine, you get the room. You don't get the delay.
BlakeNot yet.
MaxGive me the plain English version of a new start then so listeners know what we're actually fighting about.
BlakeA new start is a line the last bill never funded. Under a CR, the default is last year's list, so a program that wants to grow past it has to wait for a real bill. Meanwhile, everything on the existing list keeps getting paid, which is why it feels like nothing is wrong.
MaxOkay. Because now I've been sitting on this. You keep talking about the calendar in Washington. Meanwhile, the rocket is on its own calendar.
BlakeOh, here it comes.
MaxThe hardware doesn't read appropriations bills, Blake. Tanks don't care about writers.
BlakeThen let's see what your calendar actually looks like.
MaxOkay, so get this. Artemis III's SLS core stage got mated to its boosters inside the Vehicle Assembly Building back in October. That's the real thing, stacked.
BlakeStacked, not flying.
MaxNot flying, no. NASA's item says that after checkouts, the stack rolls out to Pad 39B for a tanking test.
BlakeRemind me what tanking means in practice. Do they light anything?
MaxNope. Propellant goes into the core stage only, and the team rehearses the countdown procedures. Think dress rehearsal where the actor is a very expensive tank.
BlakeSo what do they actually learn, besides that the tank holds liquid?
MaxThat the people and the procedures work together with a loaded core stage. It's a rehearsal, so a clean one is good news and a messy one is information. Either way, nothing about it needs a vote.
BlakeFine, I'll give you that one. It proceeds. Nobody in an appropriations office is going to stop a rocket from being filled.
MaxThank you.
BlakeBut Max, answer me this. Say the test goes perfectly. What does that buy you on the day the money for the next steps is frozen?
MaxWait, say that again.
BlakeA milestone passed on the pad is a fact about the rocket. It isn't a dollar. If the stopgap freezes what comes after, the clean tanking test just sits there proud and unfunded.
MaxHmm. Okay, that stings a little.
BlakeGood. Now, the date. You keep saying year-end.
MaxI do say year-end.
BlakeWhere does that come from?
MaxA secondary report from New Space Economy dated October 28th. It says NASA has targeted the tanking test for late 2026.
BlakeTargeted.
MaxTargeted. And here's the part I like less. It says the October 28th announcement confirmed the integration, the short stack, but didn't set a revised test date.
BlakeSo the date my favorite unstoppable milestone is supposed to hit-
MaxHas no firm date, yeah.
BlakeAh, this is delicious. All episode, you've told me the hardware ignores the calendar, and the hardware has no calendar.
MaxOkay. Okay, the skepticism we apply to every Artemis date applies to this one too. I'll eat it. Program history says a target is a hope with a font.
BlakeHa. Put that on a mug.
MaxMeanwhile, the honest version of my argument is smaller than the one I walked in with. The test proceeds whatever Congress does, but the target is the soft part.
BlakeThat I can work with. A smaller claim you can defend beats a bigger one you can't.
MaxBut hold on. Slipping on engineering grounds isn't the same as slipping because a bill didn't pass. Those are different clocks.
BlakeThey are. And that's my point, because now I can't tell you which clock is running the show. If the test slides into January, is that a valve or is that a freeze?
MaxHonestly, from the outside, we may never be able to tell.
BlakeHmm. Which is the uncomfortable bit. Two open questions, and both lead to the same place.
MaxWho sets the pace, Congress or the hardware?
BlakeAnd neither one will give us a date.
MaxWhich is a great setup, because last time we put numbers on this exactly. Time to hold LC forty-five to account against this week's news.
BlakeBring the scorecard. I brought a red pen.
MaxOkay, so before we grade anything, one wrinkle from the midterms. NASA Watch ran a piece on November fourth saying the elections hand Democrats the committees that fund and oversee NASA, NOAA, and the Space Force.
BlakeWhich changes who's sitting across the table come January.
MaxAnd that's why a stopgap isn't just a stopgap.
BlakeRight. And we already walked through the leverage point. The Lexology law firm analysis says Murray's short CR into January would give incoming Democratic appropriators more leverage.
MaxOkay, scorecard time. I'm using only the labels: CR, omnibus, hybrid. No quoting ourselves, because I'm not about to invent what we said.
BlakeSmart. Start with CR.
MaxHit. DeLauro calls a CR most likely, and Rounds expects one into February or March. Both point the same way.
BlakeI'd hold a full hit. The label says a CR happens. It says nothing about how long, and January versus March is a very different winter.
MaxFine. Hit on direction, and the length is still open.
BlakeHmm. Honest enough. Omnibus.
MaxPartial. Collins is pursuing separate bills towards an omnibus, so the road exists. But the House has passed three bills and the Senate none, so it's a road with no cars on it.
BlakeAnd a road you can only reach after a stopgap, which is awkward for anyone who called the omnibus as the first move.
MaxOh, that's cold.
BlakeAccurate, though.
MaxSo the omnibus grade is really a grade on timing, not on the idea.
BlakeRight. The idea is alive because Collins is working on it. The sequencing is what hasn't happened, and sequencing is most of what a budget fight is.
MaxOkay, hybrid. Some bills, some CR.
BlakeMm. That one's the sneaky survivor.
MaxWait for it.
BlakeCollins' separate bills are the bills part, and the stopgap is the rest. If the Senate's separate bill push moves while a CR holds everything else, that's a hybrid.
MaxSo grade it?
BlakePartial leaning hit. Nothing has passed yet, so I'm not handing out a full one.
MaxShut up. That's exactly my grade. Ugh.
BlakeThen we agree, which is suspicious.
MaxDon't make it weird. So the tally is a hit with an asterisk, two partials, and zero outright misses.
BlakeWhich is flattering, and I distrust flattery.
MaxYou distrust everything.
BlakeIt's my job. The easy part was grading the past, though. Everything we just scored was a matter of what's visible this week.
MaxRight. Grading is cheap. Now the part where we put our names on predictions.
BlakeFine. I'll go first, and I'm already nervous.
MaxOkay, so get this. Three roads out of December eleventh, and none of them has a launch date painted on it. Freeze, deal, shutdown. Blake, start with the boring one.
BlakeFreeze. A long stopgap. Artemis III keeps moving on money already in the pipe. Artemis IV and the moon base are the ones waiting on anything new.
MaxWaiting how?
BlakeQuietly. Nobody announces a slip. A start date just doesn't arrive. And OMB, the White House budget office, has room to spend slowly.
MaxDude, that's my favorite kind of danger, the kind with no press release.
BlakeHmm. Though I'm giving you my opinion here, not a measured delay.
MaxFair. And honestly, anybody putting a hard date on Artemis IV right now should be laughed out of the room. This program has slipped everything it ever scheduled.
BlakeAgreed. So the deal scenario.
MaxDeal is the shiny one, a real bill. The Senate number in play, Artemis III gets cover, and the moon base gets something to point at.
BlakeSomething to point at, not something to build.
MaxYou keep the red pen out, I'll keep the optimism. Look, even a deal doesn't fix hardware that isn't ready.
BlakeNo, it doesn't. It fixes the argument about who pays, and that matters for how OMB behaves afterward.
MaxAnd shutdown?
BlakeThat's the ugly one. The Hill reported that disputes over Iran war demands and a Democratic leadership fight are complicating shutdown talks, which is the same pile we looked at earlier.
MaxWow, that's rough. So the moon is a passenger.
BlakeA passenger in someone else's argument. My read, not a forecast, a shutdown wouldn't cancel anything, but it would make every date softer than it already is.
MaxAnd OMB?
BlakeIn a shutdown, the same office decides what counts as essential, and nobody's watching them do it.
MaxHmm. That's a lot of trust to hand over in the middle of a food fight.
BlakeIt is.
MaxAnd a deal doesn't hand the moon base a blank check either. Even the Senate number only buys a seat at the table.
BlakeRight. And Artemis IV is where I'd watch for the first silent signal. If a start slips there, nobody will announce it, so we'd have to read it from what doesn't happen.
MaxOkay, so rank them for the moon, worst to least bad.
BlakeShutdown, long freeze, then deal. But I'd change that order if the leadership fight gets louder.
MaxI'd swap the top two, honestly. A shutdown ends. A long freeze just sits there.
BlakeThen we disagree about timeline, not direction.
MaxWhich is a very polite way to lose an argument, Blake.
BlakeNoted.
MaxAll right, enough ranking doom. What do we actually watch between now and December eleventh? Okay, so we've argued all episode, and nobody's bleeding. Fair summary. Blake says the stopgap is the danger. I say the rocket doesn't read bills.
BlakeFair, and neither of us has a measured delay to wave around yet.
MaxOuch. Accurate, though.
BlakeSo predictions. Opinion only, flagged, dated. Mine, Congress passes a stopgap before December eleventh, and it runs past the end of January.
MaxPast January? Bold for a man who likes footnotes.
BlakeI'll take the footnote if I'm wrong. Max?
MaxOkay, get this. My call, NASA still hasn't announced a firm Tanking test date by December eleventh. Late twenty twenty-six slides into the new year quietly.
BlakeWait, that's your hardware won't wait guy betting on a hardware slip?
MaxHardware moves. It just doesn't always move on schedule. Plot twist.
BlakeHmm. So we're both checkable on the same day.
MaxExactly. We'll score ourselves next time, red pen and all, no mercy.
BlakeAnd if you know someone still asking why we're going back to the moon at all, send them this episode.
MaxDo it, then subscribe wherever you listen. Say you're here when we find out which of us was wrong.
BlakeProbably me.
MaxProbably you. Landing the Moon, see you next time.
More episodes
Keep listening
Other episodes of Landing the Moon, newest first.
- LC 46: Flight 15's Double Catch vs. RefuelingNov 11, 2026 · 19 min
- LC 45: Democratic Congress and the $24.4B FloorNov 4, 2026 · 21 min
- LC 43: Who Pays for the Moon After MidtermsOct 28, 2026 · 21 min
- LC 42: Grading the Artemis III BriefingOct 21, 2026 · 19 min
Sources
Where this came from
7 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.
- A blue wave, Trump's Iran demands and a leadership fight are rattling shutdown talksthehill.com
- Senate Appropriations CJS Subcommittee Proposes $24.9 Billion for NASA in FY2027spacepolicyonline.com
- The Midterms Reset the FY27 Appropriations Endgame - Lexologylexology.com
- Artemis III SLS Core Stage Joins Boosters at Kennedy - NASAnasa.gov
- Five Weeks to Decide How Much NASA Science Survivestheaceofspace.substack.com
- NASA Completes Artemis III SLS Core Stage and Booster Integration Ahead of Tanking Testnewspaceeconomy.ca
- NASA’s new bosses on Capitol Hill: what the midterms mean for spacenasawatch.com
