LC 45: Democratic Congress and the $24.4B Floor
Show notes
What the episode covers
November 4, 2026: Democrats won both chambers of Congress, but NASA's funding clock did not move. The current stopgap spending bill expires December 11, about five weeks away.
Max and Blake grade their episode 43 scenarios, all still pending until December 11, and cover:
- The $24.4B House figure for NASA versus the $18.8B White House request, why a flat number is likely the FY2027 floor, and the 17% cut to Science in the House bill
- Why Artemis hardware schedules follow appropriations rather than majorities, and the April 22 House Science hearing where both parties signaled they would reject the proposed 23% cut
- The lame-duck options: full-year bills, another continuing resolution, or a hybrid. The hosts note their sources do not address SLS or Moon Base lines, so those remain open FY2027 questions
The hosts disagree on grading. Max offered a provisional B-plus for the stopgap scenario, and Blake refused it. Blake predicts another continuing resolution, while Max predicts a hybrid with NASA parked.
In the coming week, watch for signals from congressional leaders on whether they will finish bills or wait, and how floor time is scheduled ahead of December 11.
Timeline
In this episode
8 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.
- 0:15Introduction
- 1:50The Scorecard: LC 43's Three Scenarios
- 4:23The $24.4B vs. $18.8B Gap and the December 11 Cliff
- 7:32Max's Question: Does Anything Change on the Engineering Side?
- 10:23The Turn: The Cuts Were Already Bipartisan
- 13:37Lame Duck: Omnibus, CR or Hybrid?
- 16:57Grades and Exposure: What a Flat Number Protects
- 19:20Outro
Quick answers
Straight from the episode
The questions this one settles, without the listen.
- What is the gap between the House NASA budget and the White House request for FY2027?
- The House bill holds NASA at the enacted $24.4 billion, while the White House requested $18.8 billion, a gap of about $5.6 billion. The flat House number is seen as the likely floor for FY2027, and the request is treated as an opening bid that neither the stopgap nor the House bill adopts.
- Does a continuing resolution cut NASA's funding?
- No. The hosts explain that the CR itself is not the fiscal hit, since FY2027 started flat under a stopgap. The real risk is a shutdown, and a late bill can delay things even when the number is safe from a cut.
- Will the midterm elections change NASA's engineering work or funding?
- Probably not much. Blake argues hardware runs on funding, not majorities, so a majority flip changes little for engineering. A slipped milestone changes the hearing conversation, not the funding line. Max summed it up as majority flips, engineering shrugs.
- Was the proposed 23% NASA cut opposed by both parties?
- Yes. At the April 22, 2026 House Science hearing, members of both parties, including chair Babin, told Isaacman that Congress would likely reject the 23% cut. Senate Commerce also passed a unanimous bipartisan authorization at $24.7B/$25.3B, led by Cantwell and Cruz. Authorizers only recommend, so appropriators hold the pen.
- What are the lame-duck options for funding NASA after the midterms?
- The hosts lay out three exits: full-year bills (an omnibus), another CR, or a hybrid. Floor time is the scarce resource. Jeffries preferred finishing bills before the election, while a new majority has an incentive to wait, which the hosts leave as a tension between certainty and authorship.
- Which part of NASA is most exposed inside the flat budget, and what did the hosts predict?
- Blake infers science is the most exposed line, since the House bill is flat overall but cuts Science 17%. The sources don't address SLS or Moon Base lines, which remains an open FY2027 question. Blake predicts another CR, while Max predicts a hybrid with NASA parked. All grades remain pending on December 11.
Transcript
The full conversation
Every word of the episode, 3,317 of them, in the order they were said.
Read the transcriptHide the transcript
MaxOkay, so get this. Democrats woke up this morning owning both chambers of Congress, and NASA's calendar did not get the memo that anything changed.
BlakeIt's November fourth, 2026. The ballots are barely counted, and the clock is already running.
MaxWait for it. December 11th.
BlakeThe date the current stopgap fiscal bill runs out.
MaxOh, man, I love a deadline that shows up before the confetti is swept.
BlakeDemocrats can celebrate for about five weeks.
MaxFive weeks? That's not a honeymoon. That's a long weekend with homework.
BlakeCongress tends to use every last day of a deadline, so I wouldn't count on any of them being spare.
MaxWelcome to Landing the Moon. I'm Max. That's Blake. And yes, we are going to talk about money again.
BlakeCBS News published live updates this morning saying Democrats won control of both chambers in an election widely viewed as a rebuke of President Trump. That's the headline. What it means for Artemis is a separate question.
MaxAnd my question is simple: Does anything change on the engineering side? Same rocket, same lander, same hardware sitting in a building somewhere.
BlakeMine is less simple, Max. I think whoever writes the fiscal 2027 bill matters more than any hardware milestone you can name.
MaxFighting words from a guy who's never torqued a bolt.
BlakeFighting words backed by a spreadsheet.
MaxHa. Fine. And we're not just trading hot opinions. We made predictions last time in episode 43, and we're grading them live.
BlakeOut loud with our names on them.
MaxNames, grades, the whole thing. If I whiff, you get to say so.
BlakeTerrifying. So first, the scorecard. What did LC 43 actually bet on?
MaxOkay, so get this. LC 43 went out on October 28th, titled Who Pays for the Moon After Midterms. And I laid out three scenarios, all before a single ballot was counted.
BlakeThree scenarios and a host who sounded very sure of himself.
MaxI sounded sure about all three. That's the problem.
BlakeRemind people what they were, briefly.
MaxHonest answer, I'm working from memory of the framing, not reading my own script back. So here's the mapping we're applying today, not a quote from that episode. Think of it as the ways December 11 can resolve: a full year deal, another stopgap, or some mix of the two.
BlakeSo that's our yardstick now, not LC 43's recorded wording. Each one is really a bet on how the lame duck session handles a single date, and I'd rather admit the paraphrase up front than get caught on it later.
MaxA bet with three chances to be right. Very convenient. Sure of myself, but not that sure.
BlakeSo we need rules before we start. Otherwise, you grade yourself on a curve.
MaxOoh, rules. Go on, Blake.
BlakeSimple. A scenario gets scored on what has actually happened so far. Votes counted, seats called, statements made.
MaxAnd if it hinges on something that hasn't happened?
BlakeThen it's marked pending. Not a pass, not a fail.
MaxHold on. Pending is a very comfortable grade for me.
BlakeIt would be, which is why it has a hard edge. Anything that depends on how December 11th plays out goes in that column. No partial credit for vibes.
MaxPlayfully, no vibes. Hmm. Rough.
BlakeAnd no retroactive rewriting. If a scenario said something specific, we hold it to that wording, not to what it should have meant.
MaxFair, although I reserve the right to wince.
BlakeWince all you like, just don't edit.
MaxSo what's actually gradable today?
BlakeThe setup, not the finish. Who won, what numbers are on the table, what people said before the vote. Those are on the record. The December outcome is not.
MaxOkay, but here's my worry. If half my scenarios land in pending, we've basically graded nothing.
BlakeMaybe. Or maybe that tells us something. If the most important parts of the forecast can't be scored yet, that's information about where the real decisions sit.
MaxHuh. That's annoyingly good.
BlakeI'll take annoyingly.
MaxFine. Then to grade anything, we need the numbers and the cliff. Walk me through the money first. Okay. So get this. Money first. The Planetary Society's tracker says this fiscal year began with NASA flat, running on a stopgap.
BlakeFlat at $24.4 billion. That's the enacted number. And the House bill holds NASA right there.
MaxAnd the White House asked for what?
Blake$18.8 billion.
MaxWhoa. That's a hole you could park a Falcon Heavy in.
BlakeIt's about $5.6 billion. Think of it as roughly the gap between a healthy agency and one that starts canceling things.
MaxCanceling things. Love that for us.
BlakeThe Planetary Society tracker also treats the flat house number as the likely floor for this year. Floor, Max, not a ceiling.
MaxHold on. If the floor is the same number the stopgap already gives NASA, why is December 11th a cliff at all?
BlakeBecause a stopgap and a shutdown are different animals. A Space Foundation analysis dated October 21st says a continuing resolution keeps NASA at that same flat figure. So the CR itself isn't a big fiscal hit.
MaxHuh.
BlakeThe real risk, that analysis says, is a shutdown if nobody reaches a deal.
MaxSo the money isn't the cliff, the calendar is.
BlakeMostly. And that same piece says the White House sought deep cuts of as much as $6 billion. A CR doesn't grant those cuts. It just refuses to grow anything.
MaxRefuses to grow, like a very expensive houseplant.
BlakeSure. The Space Foundation points to the stalled National Security Space Growth Plan as the example of a CR blocking growth.
MaxOkay, but flat sounds safe. Flat sounds like everybody goes home happy.
BlakeFlat in total, yes. Inside the total is another story. The Planetary Society says the House Appropriations bill keeps NASA flat with the enacted budget but reprioritizes across the agency.
MaxReprioritizes. That word always means somebody's losing.
BlakeScience, in this case. The bill includes a 17% cut to science.
Max17? Wait, in a bill that's flat?
BlakeIn a bill that's flat. The headline number holds and the money moves underneath it.
MaxOh, man, so a flat number can hide a lot of rearranging.
BlakeIt can, which is why I'd hold off on cheering for 24 point four.
MaxOkay, translate that for someone who just wants to know whether the moon program gets a haircut.
BlakeIn total dollars, the stopgap and the House bill land in the same place, 24 point four. The haircut is the 18 point eight, the number the White House asked for. Neither the stopgap nor the House bill adopts it.
MaxSo the request is a bid, not a budget.
BlakeRight. A bid is just where one side wants the negotiation to start, and that loops back to the shutdown. If the calendar runs out with no deal, the problem isn't the number on the page, it's the lights going out.
MaxLights out versus lights on at the same wattage. Fine, I'll put the pom-poms down. But I've got a different itch. Does any of this touch the hardware, SLS, the lander, the moon base?
BlakeThat's your question, and you'll get it. First, though, I wanna be precise about what the flat number does and doesn't tell us.
MaxDeal. Make it quick.
BlakeNo promises.
MaxOkay, so get this. Money's flat, fine, but I build things in my head, Blake. Does a single bolt change because a different party runs the Senate?
BlakeShort answer, no.
MaxNo?
BlakeHardware milestones run on the money, not the majority. Contractors cut metal against a funded line, and that line hasn't moved since the stopgap started.
MaxSure, but you're skipping the part where I get to be dramatic. New Congress, new energy, new launch dates.
BlakeMax, have you met this program's launch dates?
MaxOh, I've met them. They show up late and apologize in a press release.
BlakeRight. So a Democratic majority doesn't pull a schedule in by a week. The only thing that moves a schedule is dollars arriving on time, and on that, the Planetary Society's tracker is useful.
MaxGo on.
BlakeThe tracker treats the flat House number as the likely floor for FY27. Likely floor, not a promise, but that's how they read it.
MaxHold on. Floor means the number can't drop.
BlakeIt means the people tracking this don't expect it to go under that line. What happens above it is a separate fight.
MaxAbove it being the part where a space fan like me gets to hope for more.
BlakeHope is allowed. Just don't schedule a launch around it.
MaxPutting that on a mug. Okay, but engineers hear floor and they hear safe. Is it safe?
BlakeSafe from the budget cuts, sure. Not safe from a late bill. A floor on paper still has to get signed by December 11th.
MaxAh, so the hardware waits on a calendar, not a ballot.
BlakeExactly. A floor is a statement about the bottom, not about when the check clears.
MaxWait, so what do I tell the folks bolting things together, nothing changed?
BlakeTell them the work they're funded for is funded.
MaxOkay, but let me push on that. Say a milestone does slip, a test gets pushed. Doesn't that change the politics?
BlakeIt changes the conversation, not the funding line. A slip gives people something to point at in a hearing, but the number that pays the contractors is set somewhere else by people who weren't in the test room.
MaxSo engineers get a vote on the schedule, and Congress gets a vote on the checkbook.
BlakeAnd the schedule has a long history of disagreeing with itself. I'm skeptical of any launch date I hear in November, with or without a new majority.
MaxSkeptical is the official mood of this show.
BlakeIt's the only mood the track record supports.
MaxSo here's my read. Majority flips, engineering shrugs.
BlakeMostly. And you'd expect the new majority to be the one riding to the rescue, right? Democrats arrive, the White House cuts get blocked.
MaxThat's the obvious story, yeah.
BlakePlot twist for you. The pushback you'd expect from a Democratic Congress was already in that House bill before anyone voted.
MaxWait, already there before the election?
BlakeBefore the election.
MaxOkay, so get this. I'm still waiting for the Democratic wall of resistance to show up. Where is it?
BlakeIt showed up in April, before anyone voted.
MaxApril? Walk me through that.
BlakeSpace Policy Online covered an April 22 House science hearing. Republicans and Democrats both told Administrator Jared Isaacman that Congress would almost certainly reject the 23% proposed NASA cut.
MaxBoth parties in the same room.
BlakeIncluding the chair, Brian Babin, a Republican.
MaxWow, okay. That's a Republican chair telling his own administration's NASA chief the request is dead on arrival.
BlakeAnd the Democrats had a more specific complaint. Zoe Lofgren and Whitesides pressed Isaacman not to repeat last year's de facto implementation of proposed cuts before Congress acts.
MaxHold on. De facto implementation, meaning the agency just starts living inside the cut?
BlakeThat's how Space Policy Online describes the worry. The request acts like a budget before it's a budget.
MaxCool. Very reassuring for anyone holding a purchase order.
BlakeSo the Democratic majority arrives to a fight that was already bipartisan. Sharper oversight, sure. A different baseline, unlikely.
MaxSharper oversight. Cute, but what does sharper actually buy?
BlakeA majority can ask harder questions on the record, and those Democrats were already asking one in April. That's leverage on process. It's not a new number.
MaxFine, but Babin chairs an authorizing committee. Doesn't that committee write the number?
BlakeNo. The American Institute of Physics put out an explainer before the election saying authorizers like House Science and Senate Commerce set recommended funding levels, not binding ones.
MaxRecommended, so it's a very polite suggestion.
BlakeA polite suggestion with a lot of signatures. Look at the Senate side. Commerce unanimously passed the NASA Authorization Act of 2026.
MaxUnanimous, with Cruz and Cantwell both on it.
BlakeRight. The release has Cantwell, the ranking member, and Cruz, the chairman, leading it, and it calls the bill bipartisan.
MaxIt authorizes twenty-four point seven billion for fiscal '26 and twenty-five point three billion for fiscal '27. Wait, that's above the flat number.
BlakeAbout two point five percent above the previous year by the committee's own release.
MaxSo the Senate authorizers want more than the House appropriators gave.
BlakeOn paper, and that's my whole point, Max. A unanimous vote on twenty-five point three billion doesn't move a dollar until the Appropriations Committees write the bill.
MaxHmm.
BlakeWhoever holds those gavels decides whether the authorized number or the flat number shows up in the final bill. That matters more than any hardware milestone on the calendar.
MaxSo the number that matters is the one nobody's voted on yet.
BlakeThe one in the final FY2027 appropriations bill. Everything before it is a position, and positions are cheap.
MaxCheap but not worthless. Okay, I'll give you part of that. Nobody welds a tank on a recommendation.
BlakeThank you.
MaxBut I'm keeping my half. A milestone slip still hands the appropriators their excuse.
BlakeFair. They use it as ammunition. They don't write the rules, and ammunition only matters to whoever's holding the pen.
MaxDeal. Ammunition, not authorship. So what does the lame duck actually do with December 11th? Okay, so December 11th. Everybody keeps saying the date like it's a boss height. What are the actual exits?
BlakeThree of them. Holland & Knight's October analysis calls December 11th the main forcing deadline, and it lists full-year appropriations, another CR, or a hybrid package.
MaxHybrid. Sounds like a car I can't afford.
BlakeSome bills finished, the rest kicked down the road, and the same analysis says other expiring authorities compete for floor time.
MaxMeaning NASA is standing in line with everyone else?
BlakeRight. Nobody clears the calendar for a space agency.
MaxSo the lame duck is a crowded bus, and every other expiring authority wants a seat up front. How does anything get done?
BlakeDeadline pressure. Whatever has to pass, passes, and whatever can wait, waits.
MaxAnd "can wait" is a scary phrase when you're a line item. So floor time is the scarce thing here. Not money, not votes, just hours on the calendar.
BlakeThat's how I'd put it, and that's my read, not the analysis's. Every hour spent on another expiring authority is an hour not spent on appropriations. The more crowded the session, the more tempting the short exit.
MaxWhich is the CR.
BlakeThe easiest one to pass, yes. We already covered what a CR does and doesn't cost NASA, so I won't redo it. The short version is that the calendar is the danger, not the number.
MaxFair. So who wants the big finish?
BlakeHolland & Knight reports that House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries favored finishing the appropriations bills in the lame duck.
MaxWait. Before the election or after?
BlakeBefore. That's a wish list from a minority leader, so it's a wish list with some weight.
MaxSure, but a wish list from the guy who leads the House Democrats is a wish list with some weight.
BlakeMaybe. Though a new majority has its own reason to wait. Why finish a bill in December when you can write it in the spring with a gavel in your hand?
MaxOh, that's evil and honestly pretty smart.
BlakeIt's the oldest trick in the building.
MaxBut flip it around. Finishing in December locks in a result and dodges the cliff. If you like where the House number landed, why risk it?
BlakeThat's the counterargument, and it's a real one. Finishing now buys certainty. Waiting buys authorship. Which one a leader prefers is a judgment call, and a preference reported before the election doesn't tell us how he weighs it now.
MaxSo Jeffries' stated preference and the new majority incentive could pull in opposite directions.
BlakePossibly. I'd treat that as an open tension, not a prediction.
MaxOkay, but waiting isn't free for everybody. Who gets leverage from the clock?
BlakeIt cuts both ways. The Space Foundation's October 21st analysis, the one from earlier, says the White House sought deep cuts of as much as six billion. So the side that wanted cuts has its own reason to let things drift. That's my read, not the analysis's.
MaxAnd the grant rule pause?
BlakeThe Planetary Society tracker says the Senate CR, HR 6500, pauses OMB's proposed grant rule changes only through the CR period. A CR buys quiet, and an omnibus has to decide whether their rule change lives or dies.
MaxDude, so the three exits don't just differ on money, they differ on who gets to say no to the White House.
BlakeAnd for how long. That's what the grades hinge on.
MaxFine. Time to stop talking about what might happen and start handing out marks.
BlakeStarting with the three exits we mapped earlier and then science, since that's where a flat number gets complicated fast.
MaxOkay, report cards. Quick caveat, I'm going from memory of LC 43's framing, so we're grading against the three exits we mapped earlier, not a transcript. First one, the quick full-year deal. Grade?
BlakePending. Everything hangs on December 11th, so I'm not touching it.
MaxCoward. The second exit, another stopgap. Let me offer a provisional B+ because the odds always lean towards delay.
BlakeRefused. A provisional grade is just a pending grade in a nicer font. A prediction that needs a vote that hasn't happened gets no mark from me.
MaxFine, but the hybrid one, that's the one I think is sneakiest.
BlakeAnd you may be right. Still pending, Max.
MaxThree pendings. This is the most polite report card in history.
BlakeAccuracy over drama. Your B+ goes in the drawer until the vote, and we take it back out then.
MaxSo our disagreement is whether a hunch counts as a grade.
BlakeYour hunch counts as a prediction. A grade is for something that has happened.
MaxNoted, grudgingly.
BlakeNow here's what we can grade: exposure. The Planetary Society's write-up of the House bill says it keeps NASA flat but reprioritizes across the agency, including that seventeen percent cut to science.
MaxSo inside a flat total, science is the line holding the short end.
BlakeThat's my inference, not theirs. But if the total can't move, a cut somewhere has to be absorbed somewhere.
MaxWhich is why flat is such a slippery word. Everybody here is safe.
BlakeFlat protects the total. By itself, it says nothing about any one line.
MaxAnd SLS, the Moon base?
BlakeThe sources we have don't address either line item. Nothing there to claim.
MaxSo whether a new Congress protects them is open, and it rides on the FY twenty twenty-seven bill.
BlakeExactly, which is my thesis in one sentence. The pen matters more than the wield. Prediction time. I say the lame duck ends in another CR, and the real fight moves to the spring.
MaxOoh, I'm saying hybrid. A few bills get done. NASA's gets parked.
BlakeBold for someone with three pendings.
MaxWritten down on the record. Okay, onto the sign-off. Quick scorecard for the road. All three scenarios still say pending until December eleventh.
BlakeRight, and the marker for next month is simple. My call is another CR with the real fight moving to the spring.
MaxMine is hybrid, the few bills done and NASA's parked. Put it on the board, Blake.
BlakeAlready written down by hand. We revisit both calls the day the stopgap runs out.
MaxHonestly, being on the record with a hybrid call makes me a little nervous.
BlakeGood. Nervous keeps you honest.
MaxOkay, so get this one ask. Find the friend who still asks why we're going back to the Moon and send them this episode.
BlakeAnd subscribe so the grays actually get graded.
MaxPlot twist, I'll be wrong, and I'll say so on air.
BlakeI'm holding you to that, Max.
MaxLanding the Moon. See you after the deadline.
More episodes
Keep listening
Other episodes of Landing the Moon, newest first.
- LC 47: The Dec. 11 CR Cliff and Artemis IIINov 18, 2026 · 20 min
- LC 46: Flight 15's Double Catch vs. RefuelingNov 11, 2026 · 19 min
- LC 43: Who Pays for the Moon After MidtermsOct 28, 2026 · 21 min
- LC 42: Grading the Artemis III BriefingOct 21, 2026 · 19 min
Sources
Where this came from
8 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.
- Save NASA Science Action Hub (The Planetary Society)planetary.org
- Beyond the Midterms: Congress Faces Converging Year-End Deadlines (Holland & Knight)hklaw.com
- Fiscal Cliff Looms for Federal Space Spending Amid Budget Delay (Space Foundation)spacefoundation.org
- House Appropriators advance key NASA funding billplanetary.org
- 2026 midterm election results as Democrats decisively win control of House and Senatecbsnews.com
- Commerce Committee Passes Landmark NASA Authorization Act - U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, & Transportationcommerce.senate.gov
- House Science Committee Opposes Cuts in NASA's FY2027 Budget Request (SpacePolicyOnline)spacepolicyonline.com
- Midterms 2026: Authorizing Committee Leaders Up for Reelection (AIP FYI)aip.org
