LC 46: Flight 15's Double Catch vs. Refueling
Show notes
What the episode covers
November 11, 2026: SpaceX is targeting Friday, Nov. 13 for Starship Flight 15, the first attempt to catch both the Super Heavy booster (Booster 22) and the ship (Ship 42) at the tower at Orbital Launch Pad 2. The ship catch can be waived in favor of a splashdown, so the double catch is an objective, not a guarantee.
Hosts Blake and Max discuss:
- The Flight 14 baseline and what Flight 15 adds, including the slip from Nov. 8 to Nov. 13
- Why refueling gates the lander, and why no public date exists, with reported estimates of 2027 held loosely
- An unconfirmed report that docking hardware is tested on Flight 15, and the Starship HLS docking test with Orion
The hosts disagree on what a clean catch means for the Moon landing. Max scores it four out of ten for a clean double catch and three for a booster catch with ship splashdown. Blake gives one in both cases. Blake predicts a slip and no refueling date this year; Max expects a launch within the week.
Watch this week: whether Flight 15 holds Nov. 13, whether the ship is caught or splashes down, and any confirmation on docking hardware.
Timeline
In this episode
8 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.
- 0:15Introduction
- 1:25Flight 14 Baseline: Orbit, With an Asterisk
- 3:54What Flight 15 Adds: The Plan and the Waiver
- 6:21Max's Score: Great for Starlink Economics
- 8:58The Turn: Refueling Gates the Lander
- 12:55Counterpoint: Docking Hardware on Flight 15?
- 15:24Final Scores and Predictions
- 17:54Outro
Quick answers
Straight from the episode
The questions this one settles, without the listen.
- What is planned for Starship Flight 15?
- Flight 15 uses Booster 22 and Ship 42 from Orbital Launch Pad 2. It was announced Oct. 21 with a 5:45 p.m. ET window of 75 minutes, 14 orbits over about 22 hours, and a slip from Nov. 8 to Nov. 13. The goal is a double catch of booster and ship, but the ship catch can be waived in favor of a splashdown if conditions are off-nominal.
- Is the Starship ship catch on Flight 15 guaranteed?
- No. The ship catch is waivable in favor of splashdown, with the trigger described only as off-nominal conditions. The double catch is an objective, not a guarantee.
- Does a clean double catch bring Starship closer to a Moon landing?
- Only partly. The hosts said a clean catch validates tower infrastructure but does not prove rapid reflight or orbital refueling. Max scored a clean double catch a four out of ten for the lander, Blake a one. Max argued it helps Starlink economics by recovering stages, while Blake separated that from the lander's schedule.
- When will Starship orbital refueling happen?
- There is no public date. A Wikipedia summary of a NASA IAC schedule says early 2027 (tentative), and Advanced Television (Oct. 20) says 2027, maybe first half, after the catch and LC-39A. A possible December Flight 16 could be the first LC-39A launch. The hosts advised holding the date loosely and watching the near-term links in the chain.
- Will Flight 15 test docking hardware?
- Wikipedia's Flight 15 page reportedly says docking and hatch mechanism aspects of the transfer demo are tested, but this was unconfirmed as of Nov. 11. The hosts noted that a hatch test would show the mechanism works, not that two ships can meet and connect. It is also separate from the revised 2026 HLS plan to dock a test article with Orion in low Earth orbit.
- What were the hosts' final scores and predictions?
- Max gives a clean double catch a four and a booster catch plus ship splashdown a three. Blake gives one for both. Blake predicts Flight 15 slips and no public refueling date appears by year end. Max predicts it flies within the week with a ship splashdown and that a tentative 2027 date appears.
Transcript
The full conversation
Every word of the episode, 3,167 of them, in the order they were said.
Read the transcriptHide the transcript
MaxA launch tower, two giant steel catchers, and a launch date that lands on Friday the 13th.
BlakeWhich is either a bold marketing choice or a dare.
MaxA dare. Definitely a dare.
BlakeAnd it's only a target, Max. Launch dates in this program slip like it's a hobby.
MaxFair, but SpaceX is targeting Friday, November 13th for flight 15, the first attempt to catch both the Super Heavy booster and the ship at the tower.
BlakeBoth, same day.
MaxBoth.
BlakeWelcome to Landing the Moon. I'm Blake, that's Max, and we're the two people who will argue about whether any of that gets astronauts onto the lunar surface.
MaxPlot twist, I'm gonna be nicer about it than Blake.
BlakeWe'll see. Spacecom is already calling it the world's first full recovery of an orbital rocket.
MaxWhich sounds huge, so the question is whether a perfect double catch actually moves the Moon landing.
BlakeHuge for the rocket, sure, but recovering a rocket and landing people on the Moon are two different jobs, and the second one is the one we're scoring.
MaxEach of us is putting a score on it.
BlakeMine will be stingier.
MaxShocking.
BlakeBefore we grade flight 15, we need the flight 14 baseline.
MaxRight. Orbit with an asterisk. Flight 14 is the one where Starship finally got to orbit. First time on its 14th test flight.
Blake14th. I'd like to see anyone else's rocket program get that much patience.
MaxFair. SpaceNexus wrote that it deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites and then splashed down in the Pacific.
Blake26. That's a real payload, not a ballast block.
MaxRight, and Astronomycom called it the first operational payload, so the satellites matter as much as the orbit does.
BlakeOkay, but you teased an asterisk before the break. Pay it off.
MaxHere it is. One of Ship 41's six Raptor engines shut down early on ascent.
BlakeOne of six? Hold on, that's a sixth of your thrust gone.
MaxYep, and the Teslarati account says the live stream host told viewers the team would not commit to orbit at first.
BlakeMm, that's a careful sentence for a rocket company.
MaxBecause SpaceX had a rule set in advance: fire the orbital insertion burn only if enough hardware remained to de-orbit afterward.
BlakeSo the decision wasn't in panic, it was a checklist someone wrote on a calmer day.
MaxExactly. And the ship cleared it. It reached orbit anyway.
BlakeWhy does a rule like that matter so much? Because the failure you're guarding against isn't really the engine, it's a ship stuck in orbit that can't come home.
MaxRight. The insertion burn is the commitment. Once you fire it, you own whatever happens next, so you want the way home guaranteed before you commit.
BlakeI like that more than a clean flight, honestly. A clean flight tells you nothing about what the rules do under stress.
MaxPlot twist, we agree. Now, the other piece. Teslarati says the flight was cut from about 10 hours to about three.
BlakeSeven hours of planned flying gone.
MaxAnd splash down moved to the North Pacific near Hawaii.
BlakeWhich is a different place than planned. So the headline is orbit, and the footnote is a shortened day with one engine out.
MaxBoth true at once. It's a real step, and it's also a flight that bent its own plan.
BlakeAnd that's the part I'd carry into flight 15. A flight that bends its plan and still finishes is a better data point than one that never gets pushed.
MaxThough the engine out is a thing to keep an eye on. One of six is survivable once. It's not a pattern you wanna see twice.
BlakeFine, I'll grant the orbit, but nobody's catching anything yet, are they?
MaxNope. So what does flight 15 add on top of that? Flight 15 is expected to fly Booster 22 and Ship 42 off orbital launch pad two at Starbase, and the tower, the big one with the chopstick arms, has to grab both of them.
BlakeBoth. Same day.
MaxSame day. Wikipedia says SpaceX announced the plan on October 21st, which is a secondary source, so hold it loosely.
BlakeHolding loosely. What's the clock look like?
MaxLiftoff is targeted for 5:45 PM Eastern inside a 75-minute window. Gadget Review describes the mission as 14 orbits over about 22 hours.
Blake22 hours after a flight that got trimmed that short last time? Ambitious.
MaxAmbitious is the polite word.
BlakeMax, that plan is as of November 11th. The earlier target was the 13th, and it already slid to the 13th, so I'm treating every one of those timestamps as a wish.
MaxFair. Wishes with a countdown clock.
BlakeWhich is why I keep two columns in my head, what's announced and what's happened. Right now, everything on this page lives in the first column.
MaxThat's the healthy way to read a launch preview. The announcement is a plan, and the plan only becomes a fact when the vehicle leaves the pad.
BlakeAnd the catch itself, walk me through what the ship is actually being asked to do.
MaxPicture a very tall, very expensive fish being caught by a pair of giant metal arms, except the fish is coming down from orbit and the arms don't move. The ship has to line up with them.
BlakeNo pressure.
MaxNone. Here's the part people skip, though. Gadget Review says the ship catch can be waived in favor of an ocean splash down if things look off-normal.
BlakeWait, say that again?
MaxThe ship catch is waivable. If things look off, it goes in the water instead.
BlakeSo the double catch is a planned objective. It is not a promise.
MaxRight, which means the headline everyone's going to type, "Double catch," has an exit door built into it.
BlakeSo what trips the door? Is it weather? The ship? The tower?
MaxThe source only says off-normal conditions, so I'm not going to pretend I know the trigger. What matters is that the option is part of the plan.
BlakeI like exit doors. Honest ones, anyway. It means a splash down wouldn't automatically be a failure.
MaxDepends who you ask and what they bet on. Some people will call it a miss the second it touches water.
BlakeThose people also believe the date.
MaxOuch. Okay, enough about the exit door. Oh, you're gonna love where the money shows up. Let me give you my first score. Okay, so my number. Catch alone scored for the lander. I'm giving it a four out of 10.
BlakeFour?
MaxFor a catch. Hear me out. A clean double catch is huge for Starlink economics. Reusing both stages is how you make a satellite constellation pay for itself.
BlakeWalk me through that. Why does a catch move the economics as opposed to just dropping it in the ocean?
MaxBecause a stage you get back is a stage you don't have to build again. Flight 14 put up 26 Starlink V3 satellites in one go, and a constellation is a numbers game. If the hardware keeps coming back, you can keep launching without the bill resetting every time.
BlakeSure. And the lander?
MaxThat's where the four comes in. Gadget Review says a clean catch would validate the tower recovery infrastructure. The tower is the same tower, the arms, the pad, the whole choreography. If it can't take a ship out of the sky, nothing downstream works. Infrastructure is not nothing.
BlakeMm. But the same source says the catch would not by itself prove rapid reflight. One is a photo, the other is a turnaround schedule.
MaxOkay, but the photo is a prerequisite to the schedule.
BlakePrerequisite to a thing the lander doesn't even hinge on. So I'm at a one, maybe a zero with a generous rounding error.
MaxA one? Dude, you dock points from a sunrise.
BlakeOnly if the sunrise claimed to fix orbital logistics. Here's my real quarrel, though. Starlink economics is a business argument, and the lander is a schedule argument. Cheaper launches don't buy you calendar time on the moon.
MaxFine. That's the framing of the whole episode, honestly. A perfect double catch is great for Starlink and proves nothing about orbital refueling, and refueling is the step that matters for Artemis.
BlakeSo the four is generous.
MaxThe four is for Starlink bleeding into the lander column. I'll defend that. Cheaper launches, more flights, more practice. Practice is not worthless.
BlakePractice at catching, sure. But does the lander get one extra day of schedule out of it? That's what I would want you to defend.
MaxMaybe not a day, but more flights means more chances to find problems before they matter to a crew. That's the bleed I'm scoring, and I'd call it a learning rate argument, not a milestone.
BlakeWhich is a fair argument, and I'd put it at the margin. A margin is not a gate.
MaxOkay. Okay. You've dragged me right to the cliff.
BlakeThen let's look over it. Where does the propellant transfer actually stand?
MaxOh, you're gonna love this part because the answer is a lot quieter than the catch. Okay, so the catch is the flashy part. Refueling is the part with the paperwork. Ship-to-ship propellant transfer is the milestone that actually gates the lander.
BlakeAnd as of today, November 11th, the creator brief for this episode frames it as having no public date.
MaxNone. Zero. Which is a strange place to be for the step Artemis leans on.
BlakeHold on. Is that strictly true? I've seen a date floating around.
MaxOf course you have. Go ahead.
BlakeThe Starship HLS page on Wikipedia says a NASA schedule shown at the International Astronautical Congress in October put the transfer demo in early 2027.
MaxEarly 2027. Oh, man.
BlakeCareful, though. That's a wiki page summarizing a NASA slide. It isn't NASA speaking, so I'd call it a tentative date and leave it there.
MaxFair. A slide at a conference is a wish with good lighting.
BlakeOkay. That's mine now.
MaxTake it. There's a second source too.
BlakeGo.
MaxAdvanced Television, in an article dated October 20th, puts the orbital refueling demo in 2027, possibly the first half. And notice the order. It comes after the dual catch and after the Florida pad.
BlakeThe Florida pad being LC-39A.
MaxRight. That article also floats a possible flight 16 in December as the first Starship launch from LC-39A.
BlakeDecember. After a flight 15 that hasn't flown yet and whose own date already moved once. And that article was written when the target was November 8th, so its calendar is already moved.
MaxYeah. I'm not booking a hotel.
BlakeSo here's what I wanna know. What has to be true for early 2027 to hold? Walk me through the engineering because I only know the finance version of this, where the schedule is always fine until it isn't.
MaxOkay, this is where it gets good. Transfer means two ships in orbit at the same time, meeting up, connecting, and moving propellant between them.
BlakeHmm. So what's the order of operations?
MaxPer that article, the sequence is the dual catch first, then the Florida pad, then the demo. Flight 15 has to fly, then a possible flight 16 in December has to be the first launch from LC-39A, and only after that does the demo come into play.
BlakeSo a December flight 16 is the hinge. If it slides, everything behind it slides.
MaxRight. And before any transfer, you need a ship that reliably reaches orbit and then a second one that does too. Flight 14 got one there with an engine out.
BlakeOne ship, not a pair.
MaxExactly. Every extra step in that chain is another place for a date to slide. None of the sources we have describes the in-orbit steps as done yet.
BlakeSo the early 2027 claim is stacking assumptions. Catch works, pad ready, flights keep coming at pace.
MaxAnd none of those has happened yet. Honestly, I'd bet on slippage before I'd bet on the demo.
BlakeMe too. Though I'll say it in a more measured tone.
MaxYou always do.
BlakeLet me put that in finance terms for a second. When a schedule has a chain of dependencies and each link is still in the future, you don't get to average the optimism, you multiply the doubt.
MaxThat's painfully accurate. And the engineering version is the same. Every link is a separate thing that has to work, and a problem in any one of them pushes the whole line right.
BlakeSo what would a sensible listener do with an early 2027 date?
MaxHold it loosely, like we said, and watch the near links. Does Flight 15 fly? Does the pad question get answered? Does anyone official say a date out loud?
BlakeNow, here's what bugs me. Everyone is talking about catching hardware, but does Flight 15 touch any refueling at all?
MaxWait for it. There's actually a counterpoint on that. Okay, so get this. The Wikipedia page for Flight 15 says aspects of the propellant transfer demo are reportedly being tested on this flight, the docking and hatch mechanism.
BlakeSpecifically, reportedly. Carry that word with you.
MaxOh, I'm carrying it. But if it's true, my four out of 10 starts looking a little stingy.
BlakeWait, why? A docking mechanism on a single ship in orbit has nobody to dock with.
MaxSure, but hardware still gets flown though. You test the latch before you test the handshake.
BlakeSure, but the page is secondary. It doesn't name a document, and nothing from SpaceX confirms it as of November 11th.
MaxFair. So I'm not moving the score. I'm leaving a little pencil mark next to it.
BlakeA pencil mark. I can live with that.
MaxSo what would a hatch test actually prove? Best case, that the mechanism works the way it was built to with the parts that eventually have to open and seal.
BlakeOpening and sealing a hatch on one ship tells you the hatch works. It doesn't tell you two ships can find each other, line up, and hold a connection while propellant moves. That's a different list of unknowns.
MaxDude, it gets better. A different Wikipedia page, the one on Starship HLS, the human landing system, describes a revised 2026 Artemis architecture.
BlakeRevised how?
MaxAn HLS test article docks with Orion in low Earth orbit.
BlakeHuh. That's a lander-shaped thing meeting the crew capsule close to home.
MaxRight? Docking rehearsal, no moon required.
BlakeThough notice that's still a description on a page. It doesn't say it's been done, only what the architecture looks like.
MaxAnd if it is the architecture, it leans on docking practice early. That's worth a pencil mark of its own, not a score change.
BlakeHold on. That's a docking between a lander and Orion. Refueling is a docking between two Starships, different pair of partners, different plumbing.
MaxOkay, but you're telling me nothing transfers? Latches, alignment, hatch work?
BlakeYou're telling me one unconfirmed line on one page doesn't rewrite what gates the lander. If the hatch test is real, it's a good sign. A good sign isn't a propellant transfer.
MaxYou just conceded and then took it all back in one breath.
BlakeConcede, then complicate. It's a house specialty.
MaxUh, fine. My read, it nudges the catch angle from proves nothing to proves a little, maybe.
BlakeMine, it stays at one until somebody with a badge says so.
MaxCold. Okay, enough arguing about maybes.
BlakeAgreed. Time for final grades and predictions. Max, you go first, and put a date on something.
MaxOkay, final scores. Last time I said four out of 10 for the catch alone. Now I need two numbers, a clean double catch and the messy version where the booster gets caught and the ship goes in the ocean.
BlakeThe messy version is not exotic, Max. The Gadget Review piece says the ship catch can be waived for a splashdown if conditions are off nominal. So a partial outcome is a live scenario.
MaxRight, and that's the one I'd bet on, honestly.
BlakeOh?
MaxClean double catch, I stay at four. The docking hardware report is a pencil mark, and I said I wasn't moving the score on an unconfirmed line. Booster catch plus ship splashdown, I drop to three, because the ship catch is the half that would tell us more about the tower handling the vehicle the lander resembles.
BlakeHold on. You lose a point for the ship going in the water?
MaxOne point. The booster catch is the part that mostly helps Starlink. The ship catch is the part with any lander relevance at all. Plot twist, I'm consistent.
BlakeFine. Mine stay stingy. Clean double catch, I stay at one. I'd rather round to zero, but I'm a man of my word.
MaxAnd the partial?
BlakeAlso one. Neither outcome moves a single propellant molecule between two ships. The catch scores the tower, and the lander needs the transfer.
MaxYou're a tough room.
BlakeI read the filling, Max. It's a hobby.
MaxOkay, predictions so we can get graded later. Flight 15 launches Friday?
BlakeI say it slips, even a day. The date has moved once already, and I won't bet against a second move.
MaxOoh, spicy. I say it flies within the week, booster gets caught, and the ship takes the splashdown option.
BlakeSo you're hedging against the waiver.
MaxI'm reading the waiver. Different thing.
BlakeAnd refueling. My call, no public date for the transfer demo by the end of the year. Same fog, new month.
MaxMine's a little braver. A date shows up, tentative, and it lands in 2027. Then we all squint at it.
BlakeWhat would change my mind on that call? An actual date from NASA or SpaceX themselves, not a summary of a slide. Anything short of that, and I'm staying in the fog.
MaxAnd mine flips if the date comes with a tentative label and a source we can name. That's the standard I'll hold myself to so nobody can accuse me of grading on a curve.
BlakeWrite those down. We will check them.
MaxOh, we absolutely will. All right, Friday is almost here, so let's close with what to watch when that countdown starts. Quick wrap, and I promise it's short. Both of our lander scores are on the record, so I won't read them back.
BlakeGood. Mine's still the stingy one, and the tower footage will have to earn anything more.
MaxHere's the thought I'm leaving you with. The catch is the part we can watch, and refueling is the part that decides the landing. Friday gives us a show, not a verdict.
BlakeThree watch items. Does flight 15 leave the pad on the 13th? Is the ship catch tried or waived? Does anyone name a firm refueling date?
MaxThat's the list, and if you've got a friend who still asks why we're going back to the moon, send them this episode.
BlakeSubscribe too, so you're here when we find out who owes who a coffee.
MaxLoser buys. See you after Friday.
More episodes
Keep listening
Other episodes of Landing the Moon, newest first.
- LC 47: The Dec. 11 CR Cliff and Artemis IIINov 18, 2026 · 20 min
- LC 45: Democratic Congress and the $24.4B FloorNov 4, 2026 · 21 min
- LC 43: Who Pays for the Moon After MidtermsOct 28, 2026 · 21 min
- LC 42: Grading the Artemis III BriefingOct 21, 2026 · 19 min
Sources
Where this came from
8 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.
- SpaceX Will Attempt Its First Double Catch of Starship and Its Booster On... Friday The 13th? (Gadget Review)gadgetreview.com
- SpaceX turned a heralding moment for Starship into its greatest (Teslarati)teslarati.com
- Starship flight 15 (Wikipedia)en.wikipedia.org
- Starship HLS (Wikipedia)en.wikipedia.org
- Starship #15 scheduled for November with dual catch (Advanced Television)advanced-television.com
- Starship reaches orbit on 14th test flightastronomy.com
- Starship Reaches Orbit: What Flight 14 Changes for Starlink, the Moon and Launch Costsspacenexus.us
- What time will SpaceX launch Starship Flight 15, its 1st double landing test, on Nov. 13? (Full mission timeline)space.com
