Mato just raised pre-seed Read more

Book a demo

LC 23: The FY2027 Budget Fight That Could Break Artemis

  • Jun 3, 2026
  • 19 min

Show notes

What the episode covers

June 3, 2026. ESA Director General Josef Aschbacher's op-ed demanding that Europe stop being a passenger in NASA's decisions sets the tone for this episode of Landing the Moon, as Max and Blake examine how the Artemis alliance is straining under repeated unilateral architecture changes.

Max and Blake work through three converging pressure points: the White House FY2027 budget request cutting NASA to $18.8 billion — the same number Congress rejected last year — the House Appropriations Committee's $24.4 billion counteroffer that still cuts science 17%, and the hardware dependencies that make those spreadsheet lines harder to separate than they appear. ESA modules 5 and 6 are still in production in Bremen. Starship HLS hasn't completed human-rating. The crewed Moon landing has slipped to Artemis IV in 2028.

  • Max and Blake disagree on whether Isaacman's cost-overrun argument justifies the proposed cuts
  • Blake raises OMB's spending-delay mechanism as the risk that could let Congress win the vote but lose the real spending battle

Watch the Senate FY2027 markup closely. Blake predicts the final enacted NASA budget lands below $22 billion. Max predicts the Senate science line beats the House figure. Both predictions are on the record.

Timeline

In this episode

8 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.

  1. 0:15Introduction
  2. 2:01Europe Calls NASA's Bluff
  3. 4:35The White House Bet: Gut Science, Fund the Moon
  4. 7:29Congress Shows Up With a Counteroffer
  5. 9:38The Engineering Problem Nobody Is Funding
  6. 12:22The Groundhog Day Problem: Why This Budget Keeps Failing
  7. 15:06What Happens Next: Senate, Senates, and Skepticism
  8. 17:47Outro

Quick answers

Straight from the episode

The questions this one settles, without the listen.

Why did ESA publicly criticize NASA over the Gateway space station?
ESA Director General Josef Aschbacher wrote an op-ed asking whether Europe was 'pilots or passengers' after NASA paused the Gateway program without consulting its partners. ESA had already built hardware for Gateway, leaving it in institutional limbo, and an anonymous ESA insider was quoted calling NASA 'an abusive spouse.'
How much would NASA's budget be cut under the White House FY2027 proposal?
The White House proposed cutting NASA's budget by 23% to $18.8 billion, including a 47% slash to the Science Mission Directorate and a plan to phase out SLS with no named replacement. Notably, the $18.8 billion figure is the same number Congress already rejected in the FY2026 request.
What did the House Appropriations Committee propose for NASA's FY2027 budget?
The House Appropriations Committee proposed $24.4 billion for NASA, passing on a party-line 32-28 vote. It boosted exploration funding by $1.14 billion while still cutting science by 17%, which the hosts describe as a smaller catastrophe rather than a real fix.
Is Artemis on track for a crewed Moon landing, and what are the technical risks?
The crewed Moon landing has slipped to Artemis IV in 2028. Key unresolved risks include Starship HLS not yet completing human-rating or orbital refueling certification, and ESA's service modules 5 and 6 still in production in Bremen, where political will to continue could erode even after contracts are signed.
What is the 'consensus trap' in NASA's annual budget cycle?
The consensus trap is the assumption that Congress will always restore NASA's cuts, which makes each year's damaging budget proposal read as manageable. The hosts argue this cycle causes real institutional harm even when Congress intervenes, because the repeated uncertainty erodes planning, partnerships, and hardware timelines.
What are the hosts' specific predictions for NASA's FY2027 enacted budget?
Max predicts the Senate science funding number will beat the House's $6.0 billion figure, citing China competition framing as a key political variable. Blake predicts NASA's final enacted FY2027 budget will land below $22 billion, and both flag OMB's spending-delay mechanism as a way the administration could undercut a congressional win even after a vote is secured.

More episodes

Keep listening

Other episodes of Landing the Moon, newest first.

All episodes of Landing the Moon

Sources

Where this came from

28 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.