Week 45: The Pen Without the Majority
Show notes
What the episode covers
On Saturday, November 7, 2026, the pattern is clear: the party that lost still holds the levers until January, while the winners can't pass anything alone.
This conservative news analysis covers four stories:
- The result: Democrats won the House and Senate, Johnson is stepping aside, and Republicans must decide how to lead a minority.
- Scalise versus Jordan: The Nov. 10 leadership vote shows what a minority conference chooses to fight for.
- Lame-duck calendar and veto math: Dec. 11 is the only hard deadline, and the 60-vote Senate threshold and presidential veto set constitutional limits on what passes.
- Debt and premiums: The debt ceiling is $41.1 trillion and likely to be hit soon, while ACA open enrollment brings higher premiums that won't wait for Congress.
Throughout, we ask who is accountable and where limited government priorities fit. Local action: do the one thing we name at the end, because your town needs you in the room.
New episodes every Saturday.
Timeline
In this episode
8 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.
- 0:15Introduction
- 1:17The Result and the Rebuke
- 3:50Scalise Versus Jordan
- 6:28The Lame-Duck Calendar
- 9:13The Turn: Veto Pen and 60 Votes
- 11:45The First 100 Hours and the Debt Limit
- 15:11Premiums Don't Wait for Congress
- 17:38Outro
Quick answers
Straight from the episode
The questions this one settles, without the listen.
- Who is competing for House Republican leadership after the Democratic wins?
- Per Axios's Nov. 4 report cited in the episode, Steve Scalise and Jim Jordan are competing in the Nov. 10 House GOP leadership vote. It is a second attempt for both, and the episode frames the race as a choice about what a minority conference will fight for, not just a personality contest.
- What is on Congress's lame-duck calendar before January?
- Republicans still run Congress until January. Per No Labels, Congress returns Nov. 9 with a Thanksgiving break, and Dec. 11 is the only hard deadline. The main fight is the record $1.5 trillion defense request, which Senate Democrats reject.
- Why can't Democrats just pass their agenda after winning the House and Senate?
- Divided government still applies. Per NPR, most bills need 60 Senate votes. Per Time, Democratic bills must also get past Trump, and a veto override needs Senate Republicans, which is more a favor than a procedure.
- What are the Democrats' first-100-hours priorities?
- Per NPR, the four priorities are ACA subsidies, reversing the OBBBA Medicaid cuts, tariff authority, and Iran war powers. The episode notes near-total agreement across the Democratic caucus on them.
- When will the debt limit be hit, and how high is it?
- Per CRFB, the debt ceiling is $41.1 trillion after a $5 trillion OBBBA increase, and it is likely to be hit within about six months. No Labels says it could be as soon as February 2027, and Thune has floated a lame-duck increase.
- What is happening with ACA open enrollment, and should families wait for Congress to act?
- Per KFF's Nov. 6 piece, open enrollment began Nov. 1 with higher premiums, fewer insurer options in some states, less subsidy access, and less help finding coverage after broker-fraud actions. The episode argues families should not plan around an unwritten rescue, since any fix would likely have to ride on the Dec. 11 funding bill.
Transcript
The full conversation
Every word of the episode, 3,053 of them, in the order they were said.
Read the transcriptHide the transcript
MaxWho's accountable for the next 60 days when the party holding the gavel just got fired?
BlakeHold on. Fired is strong.
MaxBlake, they're still writing the calendar. Voters already wrote the ending.
BlakeFair. Both things are true at once.
MaxWelcome to The Common Thread. I'm Max.
BlakeAnd I'm Blake. Last week, we mapped scenarios. One of them actually happened.
MaxThe big one.
BlakeThe big one. So now you have a party drafting rules for a Congress it won't run.
MaxAnd across the aisle, a party that already has its first week planned out.
BlakeOh, man. Imagine showing up with the homework done before the exam. No victory laps from us, no doom either. Just the plain read.
MaxRight. Just who actually holds the pen?
BlakeAnd that's the test for every story today. When something passes or stalls, whose name is on it?
MaxFirst, the result itself and what it did to the party that now has to pick a new leader. Variety reported on November fourth, the Democrats won the House and the Senate and described it as a broad backlash against Donald Trump.
BlakeBoth chambers?
MaxBoth. And the first domino's already down. Speaker Johnson is stepping aside.
BlakeStepping aside, not waiting to be asked.
MaxAs of this weekend, that's where it stands.
BlakeAnd that matters beyond the headline. A speaker stepping aside means the conference has to answer a question it would probably rather postpone. Who leads us now that we're about to be the minority?
MaxWhich is a very different job from running the House.
BlakeHold on. I wanna push on the word wave, because that's the word the coverage keeps reaching for. Wave, rebuke, drubbing.
MaxIt's a fair word. Backlash is Variety's framing, and the headline is hard to argue with.
BlakeThe headline, sure. But a wave is a story about November. What's the story about the next two months?
MaxMeaning?
BlakeMeaning the party that just lost still holds the gavel in both chambers until January. Every lever, the calendar, the floor, the committee rooms.
MaxHuh.
BlakeThe press is mostly covering who won. Almost nobody is asking what the people who lost are allowed to do with the keys still in their pockets.
MaxThat's a strange spot to be in. You've been fired by the voters, and your badge still works.
BlakeYour badge works, but your boss is already measuring the office for new carpet.
MaxRight, because the incoming side isn't waiting around either.
BlakeWhich makes the next few weeks odd, and that's where I'd spend the time, not on the victory lap.
MaxOkay. Give me the plain English version. If I'm just someone who wants to know whether anything changes this month, what do I tell them?
BlakeTell them the same members are in the same seats until January, so the votes this month are still cast by people who already know how the election ended. That changes the incentives, even if it doesn't change the roster.
MaxSo a vote somebody would have dodged in a normal year might look different now.
BlakeOr safer, because there's nothing left to lose. Both readings are plausible, and I wouldn't bet the house on either.
MaxAgreed. But first things first, because a party that just took a beating doesn't get to pass anything until it figures out who's in charge of it.
BlakeAnd there's a vote coming on that.
MaxThere is. The losing side has to choose who leads it, and that choice tells you a lot about whether they heard the voters or just survived them.
BlakeTwo names, two very different answers, and we'll take them one at a time.
MaxOkay. The leadership fight. Axios reported on November fourth that Scalise and Jordan are competing to lead House Republicans, and the vote is November tenth.
BlakeHold on. Scalise and Jordan. Those two names have been in the same sentence before.
MaxThey have. Axios says it's the second attempt at the top House Republican job for both of them.
BlakeBoth. Neither one gets to say they're the fresh face.
MaxDoes that help them or hurt them?
BlakeProbably both. They know what the race demands, and nobody has to introduce them to the conference. But a second try also invites the obvious question of what's different this time.
MaxA leadership race run entirely by the people who just lost the election. It's like the losing team voting on the captain before they've even left the field.
BlakeAnd the captain gets a very specific job: lead a minority.
MaxWhich is a different job than what either of them was doing last week.
BlakeRight. So I don't care much about who's better on cable. That's the personality contest, and it's the boring one.
MaxFine. So what's the interesting one?
BlakeWhat does a conference that can't pass anything choose to fight for? Because a minority can't win votes. It can only decide which votes it makes everyone else sit through.
MaxOh, that's a good way to see it. Same two guys, but the job is about picking battles.
BlakeExactly. And you can read each man's pitch as an answer to that. Which fights are worth the energy? Which ones are just noise?
MaxMm. And I'd add, Blake, they're picking before anyone's said what the fights are.
BlakeThat's every leadership race I've ever watched. Vote first, platform later.
MaxSo what's the tell? How does a regular person know which kind of race it was?
BlakeWatch what the winner talks about in the first week. If it's a short list of specific fights, that was strategy. If it's mostly gratitude and unity, that was comfort, and you can check that yourself. No cable panel required.
MaxWait, though. Is a conference this rattled even gonna treat it as strategy or just a vote on who they feel safest with?
BlakeHonestly, I don't know. The reporting says reeling. People who are reeling tend to pick comfort.
MaxOuch.
BlakeI said tend to.
MaxNoted. But here's what bugs me. The ten days between the election and that vote aren't empty. These same Republicans still run Congress.
BlakeAnd the calendar is short. They're choosing their future boss while the present job is still sitting on the desk, and the desk doesn't care who wins.
MaxOkay, calendar time. HNGN's reporting is simple: Republicans run the place until January. Congress comes back November ninth.
BlakeRun it, sure, but with a lot less runway than people assume.
MaxWalk me through it.
BlakeThere's a Thanksgiving break in the middle, according to No Labels, and the December eleventh funding deadline is the only hard deadline on the whole calendar.
MaxOnly one?
BlakeOnly one that forces anything. Everything else is optional until it isn't.
MaxOptional until it isn't. That's a polite way to describe Congress.
BlakeIt's the accurate way too.
MaxOh, man. So it's a one-lane road with a holiday in the middle of it.
BlakePretty much. And the big fight on that road is the administration's request for a record one point five trillion dollars in defense spending.
MaxTrillion with a T. And that's the fight sitting on the one deadline that forces anything. Who's saying no?
BlakeSenate Democrats reject it. That's what the No Labels write-up of the lame duck session lays out.
MaxWait, they don't take over until January, do they?
BlakeRight. Not until January. How much their no counts before then is Senate math, and that belongs to the next stretch of this conversation.
MaxHmm. So the party that just got hammered has to pass a funding bill whose biggest fight is a request Senate Democrats reject.
BlakeWhich is why I'd watch the funding bill more than any leadership vote. A funding bill is a vehicle. Things hitch a ride.
MaxLike what? Give me an example a normal person would care about.
BlakeHealthcare. STAT reported on November fourth that any healthcare legislation passed this year would almost certainly have to ride on that December eleventh bill.
MaxAlmost certainly. So no standalone vote, no big moment.
BlakeRight. If you're hoping Congress fixes something on health before the new year, it's going to be a paragraph buried in a funding bill.
MaxNothing says democracy like a paragraph buried in a funding bill.
BlakeAnd STAT also says expiring health programs have to be funded, and Republicans want to confirm several Trump health nominees before Democrats take charge.
MaxSo the outgoing team is racing to fill jobs and keep programs alive at the same time, in a few weeks with a break for Turkey?
BlakeYes.
MaxAnd what does that mean for someone who isn't a Hill staffer?
BlakeIt means the date to watch is December eleventh, the funding deadline, not any speech between now and then. If you wanna know what Congress actually decided on health, read what's in that bill, not the press release about it.
MaxWhich makes me wonder how much of this survives the other end of Pennsylvania Avenue, because even if they pass something, somebody has to sign it.
BlakeThat's the next conversation.
MaxRight. The lame duck isn't the only squeeze here. Okay, so picture the Democrat side of this. They've got a majority in both chambers and a to-do list. Does that mean they get to do the list?
BlakeNo.
MaxThat was fast.
BlakeNPR stressed exactly that. Divided government still applies because most bills need 60 votes in the Senate. A majority doesn't clear that bar by itself.
MaxAnd NPR also says Trump has wavered. One day he's promising vetoes, the next he's offering to work with Democrats.
BlakeWhich is a lot of weather for anyone trying to plan a legislative calendar.
MaxOh, man, yes. You can't count votes against a mood.
BlakeTime's reporting adds the second lock. Democratic bills would still need to get past Trump, and a veto override would need Republican votes in the Senate.
MaxRepublicans who just lost.
BlakeRepublicans who just lost and who may or may not feel like helping the winners embarrass the president.
MaxWhich makes the override less a procedure than a favor.
BlakeRight. On paper, it's a math problem. In practice, it's a request to people who may not owe the winners anything.
MaxHold on, though. Congress can pass things the president ignores, right? Time says that's already happened.
BlakeIt has. Congress passed non-binding war powers measures, and Trump ignored them.
MaxIgnored them, deadpan. Strongly worded letter, but with a roll call.
BlakeWhich tells you what a symbolic vote is worth when the other side doesn't feel bound by it.
MaxSo both parties are stuck. The same wall, opposite sides.
BlakeRight. And I wanna say this plainly because it's the whole turn. The party that lost writes the rules right now. The party that won can't pass anything alone.
MaxMm.
BlakeSo where do limited government priorities live? Not in either caucus. In the gap between them.
MaxThat's a weird place to keep a philosophy.
BlakeIt's a drafty place, but think about what lives there. Anything that needs 60 votes needs some Republicans, and anything that needs a signature needs the president. Spending restraint, tariff authority, who decides on war? Each one is a negotiation, not a victory.
MaxAnd the people who like small government are suddenly in the odd position of defending a veto pen.
BlakeOr defending the filibuster, which they might not have planned on saying out loud in twenty twenty-seven.
MaxNobody puts that on a campaign mailer.
BlakeExactly. But the incentives flip fast when you're the one in the minority.
MaxIs that a criticism or just an observation?
BlakeObservation. Principles are easiest to hold when you're the one who benefits from them. The test is whether they still hold when the seats swap.
MaxOkay, but the Democrats aren't waiting around for permission. They've got a list they wanna move right away.
BlakeThey do. And that list sets up a question about borrowing that neither party loves answering.
MaxSo what does the incoming majority actually want to vote on first, and what does that do to the borrowing question? Okay, the incoming majority has a list. NPR reports the first one hundred hours priorities are restoring the enhanced ACA subsidies, reversing the OBBBA Medicaid cuts, reasserting congressional authority over tariffs, and forcing votes on Iran war powers.
BlakeFour items.
MaxFour. And NPR says Democrats are in near total agreement on them.
BlakeNear total agreement in that caucus. Hold on. Write that down. That almost never happens.
MaxRight? A unified list is a gift to a new majority. They can move on day one, at least on paper.
BlakeMove, sure. Two of those are spending items, though. Subsidies and Medicaid both cost money. Who pays?
MaxThat's the question for the rest of this segment, and the borrowing side starts with a number nobody mentions at dinner. The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, a budget watchdog, says the debt ceiling is now forty-one point one trillion dollars.
BlakeForty-one trillion.
MaxAfter OBBBA raised it by five trillion. That's the exact figure worth remembering.
BlakeFive trillion is a lot of headroom. So why are we talking about it at all?
MaxBecause the clock is short. CRFB says Treasury will likely hit it within about six months.
BlakeHmm. And No Labels has a tighter estimate, doesn't it?
MaxIt does. No Labels says the limit could be hit as soon as February twenty twenty-seven. So the estimates differ, but both land in the first half of next year.
BlakeOh, man. So the new majority walks in, and the first thing on the table is a borrowing vote.
MaxUnless the old majority does it first. No Labels says Thune has said a debt limit increase could come in the lame duck.
BlakeWait, so the party that just got fired raises the limit on the way out?
MaxThat's the possibility on the table, and only a possibility. CRFB's headline is basically a plea against it. The lame duck shouldn't be an excuse to borrow more.
BlakeBold of them to assume anyone is listening.
MaxCRFB also notes that press reports say Congress may raise it for the rest of Trump's term.
BlakeOkay, so let me lay out the problem. Outgoing side raises the ceiling and bundles spending into the December bill. Incoming side arrives promising subsidies and Medicaid money. Both parties spend or borrow on the way out and on the way in.
MaxYeah.
BlakeSo who is the check? If you believe in limited government, which of these actors is saying no?
MaxHonestly, nobody has volunteered.
BlakeNobody. Not a single raised hand. That's the part that bothers me. The old majority has a reason to avoid a fight on the way out, and the new one has promises to keep.
MaxIs that cynical or just how the incentives work?
BlakeStructural, mostly. Nobody in either caucus gets rewarded for being the one who said no on the way out the door or day one. That's why I keep asking who the check is.
MaxThen maybe the real check is the voter, and the voter is about to get a bill of their own on a schedule of its own.
BlakeWait, what bill?
MaxAll of this is Washington math until it hits a kitchen table, and that is happening right now. Open enrollment is open. Okay, so while Congress argues about calendars, there's a window on a laptop somewhere that is already opened. KFF published a piece on November sixth called Nine Things to Watch for the Twenty Twenty-Seven ACA Open Enrollment Period.
BlakeAnd the opening line is blunt: "Enrollment began November first."
MaxRight. KFF says that season brings higher premiums-
BlakeAgain?
MaxAgain, plus fewer insurers' options in some states because more insurers are exiting the market.
BlakeWait, exiting? So in some places, the menu just gets shorter.
MaxThat's what KFF says. And it adds less access to subsidies and less help finding coverage after federal actions on broker fraud.
BlakeHold on. Less help? So you pay more, you have fewer plans, and the person who used to walk you through it is harder to find.
MaxOh, man, when you stack it like that...
BlakeI'm not exaggerating. I'm reading your own source back to you. KFF listed all of it.
MaxFair. Okay, think of a family at our church: two adults, self-employed, one kid. They sit down Sunday night with the laptop and a cold cup of coffee.
BlakeAnd the plan they had last year is gone, or it costs more.
MaxOr the insurer they liked left their state. Nobody on that couch cares who wins the Scalise and Jordan vote.
BlakeHmm. They care what the number on the screen says.
MaxExactly, and the number doesn't pause for a lame duck.
BlakeAnd that's the part I'd underline. The window is already open, so the family's clock and Congress's clock are running separately.
MaxSo what does that family do? Wait for Washington?
BlakeI wouldn't plan around a rescue that hasn't been written yet. A possible amendment to a bill that hasn't passed isn't a premium.
MaxThat's blunt, but it's the same accountability question we keep coming back to. Someone votes, someone signs, and a family pays in between.
BlakeSo can Congress even touch it in time? Because the new majority want votes on the subsidies.
MaxWanting votes and changing the price are different things. Any fix has to ride on the December eleventh bill. That's the only vehicle with a deadline attached.
BlakeSo that family signs up on whatever the screen says now and finds out in December whether somebody hitched a rescue onto the funding bill.
MaxWhich brings us to what you can do about it this week, and it's simpler than you'd think. So the whole episode comes down to one line, Blake. You wanna say it, or should I?
BlakeGo ahead, Max.
MaxUnder divided government, whoever can't pass anything alone still has to answer for what they vote for, and so does the one holding the pen.
BlakeRight, and you can check that yourself. Call your own House member's office and both senators' offices before December eleventh.
MaxAsk two things: What will you vote for, and what does it cost me?
BlakeStaffers write down every call. That part is real.
MaxThen share this with one person who'd actually make the call. Subscribe so Saturday shows up on your phone.
BlakeAnd go be in the room. Somebody's going to be, so it might as well be you.
MaxThat's the common thread. See you Saturday.
More episodes
Keep listening
Other episodes of The Common Thread, newest first.
- Week 47: The Bill at the TableNov 21, 2026 · 18 min
- Week 46: Extending the ClockNov 14, 2026 · 19 min
- Week 44: The Morning After PlanOct 31, 2026 · 19 min
- Week 43: Legislating for Their Own AbsenceOct 24, 2026 · 20 min
Sources
Where this came from
9 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.
- After sweeping midterm wins, here's what Democrats hope to get done in the majoritynpr.org
- Scalise, Jordan vie to lead House Republicans reeling from midterm rebukeaxios.com
- The 2026 Lame-Duck Session: What Congress Still Has to Pass After the Midtermsnolabels.org
- 9 Things to Watch for the 2027 ACA Open Enrollment Periodkff.org
- A looming deadline to fund the government will shape Congress' unusual lame duck sessionstatnews.com
- Inside the Democrats' Plans to Take On Trumptime.com
- Lame Duck Session Shouldn't Be an Excuse to Borrow Morecrfb.org
- Lame-Duck Congress Returns With Funding Deadline, Democrats Waitinghngn.com
- Midterm Election Results: Democrats Win House and Senatevariety.com
