Mato just raised pre-seed Read more

Week 46 - Agentic Commerce Checkout: Amazon vs Walmart on Shopping Agents, Ziff Davis' Google Referral Drop, and Early Black Friday Deals

  • Nov 9, 2026
  • 20 min

Show notes

What the episode covers

The Checkout Point, Week 46: hosts Max and Rachel cover how AI shopping agents are changing ecommerce, from agentic checkout and platform policies to Google referral traffic and the 2026 holiday forecast. This episode looks at who controls agent access to your store, how to track AI visibility in search, and what early Black Friday deals mean for merchant margins.

This week's themes:

  • Agents arrive at checkout: A sponsored Retail Dive piece on backend systems and agentic visibility (treat it with the sponsored-content caveat in mind), the Secure Technology Alliance and Merchant Advisory Group partnership on false declines, data sharing and card choice, and firmly's $15M Series A and its Ask Agent one-line JavaScript claim, which are company claims.
  • Amazon vs Walmart, who lets the agents in: Amazon reportedly blocked Meta's agent in September while Walmart rolled out agent infrastructure on Oct. 21. Amazon and Walmart hold about 88% of a projected $74.4B retail media market per Emarketer, and Morgan Stanley's 10-20% by 2030 figure is an estimate. Platforms control agent access, while sellers control product data, pricing and margins.
  • Ziff Davis and the Google referral drop: Ziff Davis says organic Google referrals fell about 37%, with no timeframe or cause given. Google's June update added Search Console reports on impressions in AI Overviews, AI Mode and Discover AI features. AI impressions and referral drops are different measurements, so the episode walks through a simple tracking framework: impressions, visits, orders and a dated check.
  • Holiday forecast and early Black Friday deals: A quick refresher on Adobe's forecast of about $275B in US online sales and a projected 130% rise in AI traffic, framed as a projection to benchmark against your own analytics. Early Amazon deals include the Nespresso Vertuo Pop+ at $50 off and the EcoFlow Delta 3 Max at over $300 off (as of Nov. 9, prices may change). Merchants should do margin math now, know their floor price, and compete on product info, shipping terms and checkout.

Subscribe to The Checkout Point for weekly ecommerce news and practical takeaways for online sellers. Follow the show, leave a review, and share this episode with a merchant who is preparing for the holiday season.

📣 We Want to Hear from You!

Timeline

In this episode

6 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.

  1. 0:28Introduction
  2. 1:46Agents Arrive at Checkout
  3. 6:16Amazon vs Walmart: Who Lets the Agents In
  4. 10:41The Turn: Ziff Davis and the Google Referral Drop
  5. 15:32Holiday Forecast Refresher and Early Black Friday Deals
  6. 17:49Outro

Quick answers

Straight from the episode

The questions this one settles, without the listen.

Why do backend systems matter for AI shopping agents at checkout?
The episode cited a Retail Dive sponsored piece (flagged as sponsored content) arguing that backend systems decide whether a merchant is visible to shopping agents. The takeaway for merchants is to check their own readiness, including card choice and false declines, before agents arrive.
How do Amazon and Walmart differ in letting AI shopping agents in?
The episode said Amazon blocked Meta's agent in September, while Walmart rolled out agent infrastructure on Oct 21. Platform policy controls agent access on those marketplaces, while sellers still control their product data, pricing and margins.
How big is the Amazon and Walmart share of retail media, and what is the agent impact on ads so far?
Per Emarketer, Amazon and Walmart hold about 88% of a projected $74.4B retail media market. Amazon's Jassy said agents have had no meaningful effect on ads so far, and Morgan Stanley's estimate of 10-20% by 2030 is an estimate, not a certainty.
What did Ziff Davis say about Google referral traffic?
Ziff Davis said its organic Google referrals fell about 37%. No timeframe or baseline was given and no cause was claimed. The company only pointed to Search Console's AI report.
What AI reporting did Google add to Search Console?
Google's June announcement added reports on impressions in AI Overviews, AI Mode and Discover AI features, broken out by page, country, device and date. The data stays in the overall report. AI impressions and referral drops are different measurements, so they should not be treated as the same thing.
What is the Adobe holiday forecast, and what should merchants do about early Black Friday deals?
Adobe forecasts about $275B in US online holiday sales, with AI traffic projected up 130% and peaks on Thanksgiving, Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Treat it as a projection to benchmark against your own analytics. With early Amazon deals already live, merchants should do margin math now, know their floor price, and compete on product info, shipping terms and checkout.

Transcript

The full conversation

Every word of the episode, 3,401 of them, in the order they were said.

Read the transcriptHide the transcript

MaxWelcome to the Checkout Point, your quick dive into this week's eCommerce buzz with me, Alex, powered by Blinket. These 20 minutes pack the latest trends, news, and insights. Let's navigate the digital marketplace together. Ready? Let's go.

RachelOkay, confession, I let my phone suggest a birthday gift last week, and it picked a fondue set.

Speaker 3For whom?

RachelThat's the thing. I don't even know who it was for, but I'm-- I just stared at it.

Speaker 3Max, you're describing the future of retail, a robot with your credit card and no context.

RachelNo way. Don't say it like that.

Speaker 3I'm only asking one thing. What's the actual ROI on a fondue set?

RachelZero, unless cheese is a KPI.

Speaker 3It is for me.

RachelFair. Anyway, welcome to the Checkout Point. I'm Max, and this is Rachel, and it's week 46.

Speaker 3Hi, everyone. We've got four stops today, so grab your coffee: agents at checkout, Amazon versus Walmart, a big publisher's Google traffic, and then the holiday forecast and early deals.

RachelSo basically, my whole December and my whole credit card statement.

Speaker 3And they connect. If the shopper is software, that changes who sees your store and who gets paid.

RachelWait, that's the whole episode in one sentence? Do we even need the rest of the show?

Speaker 3We do because the details are where the money is. Just keep the fondue out of the cart.

RachelNo promises. So anyway, let's start with the agents showing up at checkout. Okay, so agents at checkout. My first question is the boring one. If a robot shops for me, how does a store even know the robot exists?

Speaker 3Boring is my favorite genre, Max, and there's a Retail Dive piece on exactly that.

RachelWait, Retail Dive, the trade site?

Speaker 3Yep. It's labeled sponsored content in the URL, so keep that in mind. It was published November ninth. The argument is that whether your brand surfaces in agentic commerce hinges on the systems behind your storefront.

RachelBehind the storefront, so not the pretty homepage.

Speaker 3Right. An agent doesn't care about your hero banner. It cares whether your catalog, inventory, and checkout plumbing can answer it fast and cleanly.

RachelSo all those years I spent arguing about button colors, wasted?

Speaker 3Not wasted, just not for the robot. Look, I've lived this. At Amazon, we had a listing that looked perfect and had stale inventory data behind it. Customers saw a buy button, then got a cancellation email. An agent would hit that wall 10 times faster.

RachelOuch, and the agent doesn't write an angry review. It just goes to the next store, and you never even find out why.

Speaker 3Exactly. It just moves on quietly, no feedback.

RachelAnd since it's sponsored content, I'm guessing we should treat it like a pitch?

Speaker 3Treat it as a perspective, not a study. Sponsored means somebody paid to put a message there. The argument is still a sensible one, but the label tells you to check it against your own store before you act on it.

RachelSo test it yourself instead of trusting the pitch.

Speaker 3Always. Ask your own team a simple readiness question. If an agent asked for size, price, stock, and delivery date right now, could our systems answer without a human stepping in?

RachelOkay, but that's the front half. What about the money part? Somebody's got to approve the card.

Speaker 3That's the next one. The Secure Technology Alliance and the Merchant Advisory Group are partnering around agentic commerce. This was reported November fifth.

RachelNever heard of the second one. Who's MAG?

Speaker 3I'll stick to what the report says. It's a partnership around the merchant side of checkout, and the list of what they're working on is very specific.

RachelHit me.

Speaker 3False declines, which data merchants must share when an AI makes the purchase, and how cards get chosen in agentic transactions.

RachelHold on. How a card gets chosen? Like, the agent picks which card in my wallet?

Speaker 3That's the question on the table. Yes. The report doesn't say how it'll shake out, but think about it. If the agent picks a card with no points, you'll be mad. If it picks the one the store likes, you'll be suspicious.

RachelMy agent is gonna max out the wrong card, and I'll blame myself.

Speaker 3And false declines. Max, a false decline is a legit customer getting rejected. That's lost margin on a sale you already earned. What's the actual cost when the buyer isn't even a person?

RachelFair, because the bank's fraud systems sees a weird non-human pattern and just panics.

Speaker 3Mm. That's the worry.

RachelAnd the data sharing thing. Merchants have to hand over what exactly?

Speaker 3The report just says which data merchants must share. It's a to-do item, not an answer yet.

RachelSo the rules are still being written, and the agents are already shopping. Great. Love that for us.

Speaker 3For a merchant, that means you can't wait for the final rule book. Look at your own decline reasons now. Do you even know which of your declines were real customers?

RachelI'd guess most stores don't separate those out. They just see declined and move on.

Speaker 3Which brings us to somebody selling a shortcut.

RachelOh, there's always a shortcut.

Speaker 3A company called Firmly raised a $15 million Series A led by Squarepoint Capital, and it launched a tool called Ask Agent.

RachelAsk Agent. What does it do?

Speaker 3Per the press release, it's a conversational shopping and checkout tool. A merchant can add it to their site with one line of JavaScript.

RachelOne line? Come on, nothing in eCommerce is one line.

Speaker 3Right, and that's the company's own claim. It's a press release. I'd wanna know what happens after that one line, like integration, support, and conversion, but what's the actual ROI?

RachelThere she is.

Speaker 3I'm just saying, a funding round isn't a result. It does show that investors think merchants want an easy on-ramp.

RachelFair, and it's a signal of where the money's heading. Plug in a widget, get into the AI shopping channel.

Speaker 3Mm-hmm. Whether it works is a different story, and a funding announcement alone can't tell you.

RachelIf I'm a small merchant, do I buy the shortcut or fix my own house first?

Speaker 3Fix your own house first, then judge any vendor against it. A tool can't answer questions your data can't. Garbage in Confident garbage out

RachelSo you've got the plumbing, you've got the payments rules, you've got the vendors with a one-liner. Everybody wants a seat at this table.

Speaker 3Sure, but the biggest retailers aren't all treating agents the same way. Speaking of agents, some are rolling out the welcome mat, and some are bolting the door.

RachelWait, really? Who's doing which? Okay, so Amazon blocked Meta's shopping agent back in September, just shut the door.

Speaker 3Wait, really? Meta's agent specifically?

RachelYep, and then Walmart goes the other way. On October twenty-first, it rolled out infrastructure for agents.

Speaker 3So one retailer says, "No, thanks," and the other builds a ramp.

RachelThat's the coverage from Technology.org in a piece about technology shopping agents putting retail ad revenue at risk. It was reported November fifth.

Speaker 3Mm, okay, but why would Amazon block anybody? Walk me through the motive because I spent years at Amazon and Walmart, and nobody does anything without a margin reason.

RachelAds. Follow the ad money.

Speaker 3There it is.

RachelThe same piece says Amazon and Walmart together hold about eighty-eight percent of a projected US retail media market. That market is projected at seventy-four point four billion dollars.

Speaker 3Hold on, eighty-eight percent of seventy-four billion. That's two companies sitting on the whole pie.

RachelRight? And that figure's from eMarketer, which the piece cites. So the sponsored listings you scroll past are basically the profit engine.

Speaker 3And an agent doesn't scroll. An agent doesn't look at a sponsored listing and go, "Ooh, shiny."

RachelNope. It just wants the ple- cheapest blender with decent reviews, zero impulse buys.

Speaker 3So if I'm Amazon, a third-party agent skipping my ads is a supply chain bottleneck in my own revenue line. I'd be nervous.

RachelExcept, plot twist, Jassy doesn't sound nervous.

Speaker 3Andy Jassy, the CEO?

RachelYeah. The article reports him saying agents have no meaningful effect on Amazon's ads so far.

Speaker 3So far. Those are doing a lot of work in that sentence.

RachelTotally. It's the corporate version of, "The water's fine. Please don't look at the water."

Speaker 3But what's the actual ROI of blocking then? If there's no effect yet, why bother?

RachelMaybe that's the point. You block before there's an effect. Walmart's betting the other way, that being open gets it in front of the agents.

Speaker 3Mm, and neither of us can say who's right because there's no result to point to. It's two strategies and a lot of ad revenue riding on them.

RachelWhatever the reasons, it shows the platform decides which agents get to read its pages. That's a big deal for sellers.

Speaker 3And it's a risk if your whole business lives on one platform. Your visibility becomes a policy decision somebody else can change.

RachelMm, and neither of us can say who's right because there's no result to point to. It's two strategies and a lot of ad.

Speaker 3Oh, no, the forecast.

RachelMorgan Stanley researchers estimate agents could account for ten to twenty percent of US e-commerce by twenty-thirty.

Speaker 3Okay, say that again slower. Ten to twenty.

RachelTen to twenty by twenty-thirty.

Speaker 3That's a wide range. It's like a delivery estimate that says, "Sometime this decade."

RachelSometime between now and your kid's graduation.

Speaker 3And it's an estimate, not a result. Nobody has measured that.

RachelRight. It's researchers projecting forward, so treat it as a scenario, not a scoreboard.

Speaker 3But even the low end is big. Ten percent of US e-commerce going through an agent means a chunk of shoppers never see your carefully tuned product page.

RachelWait, so who does the agent see?

Speaker 3Whatever it can read, whatever the retailer lets it read, which loops right back to Amazon and Walmart picking doors to open or lock.

RachelAnd that's the thing for anyone selling on those platforms. Their rules decide whether the agent even shows up.

Speaker 3So for a small brand, the ad budget question changes. If an agent isn't clicking sponsored placements, what are you paying for?

RachelHonestly, nobody's answered that yet. Jassy says no effect so far, and the forecast says maybe a fifth of spending later. That's a big gap to plan inside.

Speaker 3So practically, if you sell on Amazon, an agent's access isn't your call. It's the platform's. You can't negotiate with the door. Ask your platform contacts what their agent policy means for your listings, and if nobody can answer yet, that tells you something.

RachelRight. So what can a seller actually control if the door isn't theirs?

Speaker 3Your product data, your pricing, and your margins. Whichever door is open, an agent that can read your listing will compare everything it can read.

RachelAnd if you also have your own site, there's a question of whether you want agents in at all.

Speaker 3Exactly. Amazon blocking one agent and Walmart building infrastructure are two different bets, and a merchant with its own storefront gets to place its own. Just place it on purpose.

RachelPlace it on purpose. Love that. I'm putting it on a sticky note.

Speaker 3Mm, and that gap gets nastier once you ask where shoppers were coming from before any of this. Because if answers from AI sit in the middle, what happens to the traffic you used to get from Google?

RachelWhich is exactly where we're going next, a publisher is watching that traffic drop. And stick around after that because we'll close on the holiday run-up and the early deals. Okay, so Ziff Davis, big publisher. Search Engine Journal in a piece by Matt Southern says the company reports its organic Google referrals fell about thirty-seven percent.

Speaker 3Thirty-seven per what, though? Over what period?

RachelYeah, the piece doesn't give a timeframe or baseline, so I'm not going to pretend it does.

Speaker 3Fair. That's the company's own number then.

RachelRight, and here's the part that matters. Ziff Davis pointed to Search Console's AI report. It didn't say AI features caused the drop.

Speaker 3Mm, so it's a pointer, not a diagnosis.

RachelExactly. Like a doctor saying, "Go look at the X-ray," but not telling you the break.

Speaker 3Max with the medical metaphors.

RachelI contain multitudes, mostly spreadsheets and a little bit of coffee.

Speaker 3Okay, so what is this AI report? Because I've heard people say it like it's one magic dashboard.

RachelGoogle's developer blog has the announcement from June, if you trust the URL. It's called Search Generative AI Performance Reports in Search Console.

Speaker 3And it covers what?

RachelImpressions. How often your pages show up in AI Overviews, in AI Mode, and in the AI features inside Discover.

Speaker 3Impressions, not clicks.

RachelWell, hold on. Google says you can slice it by page, country, device, and date. That's the breakdown.

Speaker 3Page, country, device, date. Okay, that's useful. That's something I could actually act on.

RachelAnd one more detail, the data also stays in the overall performance report. It isn't pulled out and hidden in some separate bucket.

Speaker 3Wait, so it's counted in the main numbers and also broken out?

RachelThat's how Google describes it. The dedicated reports are a view, and the data still lives in the overall report.

Speaker 3Let me say what this does and doesn't tell you, because people will overread it. It's a report of impressions in those AI features, cut the ways Google listed. That alone doesn't explain why anybody's referrals moved.

RachelRight. And it's the same reason the Ziff Davis number needs care. A drop in organic referrals and a count of AI impressions are two different measurements. Putting them side by side is a starting point for a question, not an answer.

Speaker 3Hmm. That matters for how you read it, because now my question is the one I always ask: What's the actual ROI of staring at this?

RachelOh no, here we go.

Speaker 3I'm serious. If I'm running a store, which numbers tell me whether AI surfaces are helping me or hurting me?

RachelHonestly, I'd start with the impressions by page. Which product pages show up in AI answers at all?

Speaker 3Okay. And then?

RachelThen compare against your overall performance. Did the pages that show up in AI features keep their traffic, or did they slide?

Speaker 3See, that's the bottleneck. An impression with no click doesn't pay for a single pallet of inventory.

RachelTotally. Visible and unpaid is a rough place to be, like a billboard in an empty parking lot.

Speaker 3So I'd want revenue sitting next to it. Orders by landing page, same dates, same country.

RachelWhich means a lot of dashboard time. I'll be there with coffee, refreshing like it's a stock ticker.

Speaker 3You'll refresh it, and it'll say the same thing it said ten minutes ago.

RachelHey, it might change. Hope is a growth strategy.

Speaker 3It is not. But the device split is interesting to me. If mobile shoppers are the ones seeing AI answers, that changes what I'd fix first.

RachelRight. And the country cut helps if you ship internationally, because a drop in one market isn't a drop everywhere.

Speaker 3Let me make it concrete. Say you sell kitchen gadgets and one product page is your best seller. Step one: Check whether that page shows up in AI features at all. Step two: Put its organic visits next to that. Same dates. Step three: Look at its orders.

RachelSo three numbers on one page: impressions, visits, orders.

Speaker 3Right. And you only believe the story when they line up. Lots of impressions and flat orders, you're visible but not winning. Few impressions and steady orders, maybe AI isn't your issue, and you should look elsewhere.

RachelThat second one is underrated. Sometimes the scary headline just isn't about you.

Speaker 3Exactly. And keep a note of the date you checked, so next time you're comparing like with like.

RachelA dashboard diary. "Dear diary, impressions are up. Nobody clicked."

Speaker 3See? That's what I'd tell somebody. Don't chase the one big scary number. Ziff Davis gave one big scary number, and without the period behind it, you can't do much with it.

RachelYeah. Your own data is the thing you can actually read. Theirs is a headline.

Speaker 3Put that on a mug or a very small billboard.

RachelAnd honestly, the missing period is why I'd say check your own stuff over any headline, including ours.

Speaker 3Including ours, yes. A number without a measurement window is a mood, not a metric.

RachelBefore I forget, the holiday season is right around the corner, so let's check the forecast and the deals.

Speaker 3Please. I need something cheerful after all that dashboard talk, and maybe a discount or two.

RachelOkay, quick holiday refresher. Adobe's forecast reported back in late September put US online sales for November and December at about two hundred and seventy-five billion dollars.

Speaker 3That's a forecast, Max, not a result.

RachelTotally. And it also projects AI traffic to US retail sites up one hundred and thirty percent year over year, with the biggest jumps on Thanksgiving, Black Friday, and Cyber Monday.

Speaker 3So the agents we talked about may show up exactly when your site is most stressed, but it's a projection. What do I do with it on a Tuesday?

RachelWatch your own store. In the days left before Black Friday, look at how AI-driven and agent traffic shows up in your analytics and compare it to what Adobe projects.

Speaker 3So the forecast becomes a benchmark you check against, not a plan you bet on.

RachelExactly. Okay, switching gears because early deals are already listed. An Nespresso Vertuo Pop+, that's fifty dollars off at Amazon.

Speaker 3Fifty off a coffee machine? I mean, come on. That's a Monday morning purchase.

RachelDry. And the coverage is dated November ninth, so prices may have moved by the time you hear this.

Speaker 3Which is the first rule of early deals: screenshot it or lose it.

RachelThe other one is bigger, an EcoFlow Delta 3 Max power station, over three hundred dollars off at Amazon.

Speaker 3Wait, a power station? Like the thing you plug a whole campsite into?

RachelThat's how I picture it, yeah. Three hundred dollars off is a real chunk though.

Speaker 3Sure, but here's my merchant brain. Deals like these are already listed this early, so shoppers may already be comparing prices. Your margin math needs to be done now, not the night before.

RachelAnd if an agent is doing the comparing for them, even more so.

Speaker 3Oh, that's uncomfortable. A bot that finds the three hundred dollar gap in half a second. So know your floor price, compete on clear product info, shipping terms, and a fast checkout. And treat these deals as a signal about the climate, not a shopping list.

RachelSignal about the climate. Got it. All right, let's wrap this up. So big picture, software shoppers are showing up at checkout, and the two biggest stores can't agree on whether to open the door.

Speaker 3And meanwhile, the people who write about all this are watching their Google traffic go sideways.

RachelRough combo.

Speaker 3It is. But I want listeners to leave with one thing they can do on Monday. Check how your checkout and your product data would handle an AI agent as the buyer.

RachelWait, like actually test it?

Speaker 3Yes. Can a bot read your product titles, sizes, shipping times, and return rules without guessing? Does your checkout treat a non-human buyer like a fraud attempt? Because if a good order gets declined, that's margin you paid to acquire and then threw away.

RachelOuch.

Speaker 3And it costs you an afternoon. Compare that to rebuilding after the fact. I've cleaned up data messes at scale, Max. Nobody enjoys it.

RachelTotally. My product data is basically a junk drawer. Every item is called Misc Blue Thing.

Speaker 3Then an agent will buy you a blue thing, probably the wrong one.

RachelOkay, that's my sign-off material. If a robot ever shops my store, I just hope it has better taste than my uncle, who still thinks a fondue set is a personality.

Speaker 3You promised that one was retired.

RachelIt's a sequel. Find us at blicket.co and follow the show so you don't miss next week.

Speaker 3Go fix your product titles, and please rename every Misc Blue Thing.

More episodes

Keep listening

Other episodes of The Checkout Point, newest first.

All episodes of The Checkout Point

Sources

Where this came from

9 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.