Week 45 - Holiday Sales Forecasts: NRF vs Adobe's $275.1B Online Number, What Google's Mueller Says About AI SEO, and Early Black Friday Deals
Show notes
What the episode covers
The Checkout Point, Week 45: hosts Max and Rachel look at how big the 2026 holiday retail season is likely to be, where shopper traffic is shifting as AI referrals grow, and what early Black Friday deals say about margins and strategy. They compare the new NRF holiday forecast with Adobe's online projection, then work through the operational and ecommerce implications for retailers and online sellers.
Themes in this episode:
- Two forecasts, one holiday season: NRF projects Nov-Dec sales growth of 4.2% to $1.013 trillion, versus 3.1% to $972B last year. After roughly 2.5% core goods inflation, about half of that growth is real. Adobe's $275.1B online forecast (+6.7%) covers only the online slice. The hosts also look at NRF's 2025 overshoot (3.7% to 4.2% forecast versus 3.1% actual) and why a forecast works best as a planning input, with a plan B and triggers written early.
- AI referrals and where shoppers come from: Adobe's forecast, as summarized by Relevant Audience, projects AI-referred retail traffic up 130%, with social and affiliates gaining on paid search. The hosts question what that number means for conversion and ROI, and why clean, accurate product data with named owners matters for stale prices and feed mismatches.
- AI SEO and the basics that still win: Based on coverage from Search Engine Journal and Search Engine Roundtable, Google's John Mueller is skeptical of short-term AI SEO tactics, warns that mass-produced listicles and AI content are risky, and expects technical SEO to stay relevant. The discussion covers product data, redirect chains, and why a fix you can finish beats a trick you have to keep feeding.
- Early Black Friday deals and the electronics squeeze: Early deals reported by Mashable, including the M5 MacBook Air at $200 off at Amazon and the Dreame L40 Ultra Gen 2 robot vacuum at $250 off, raise strategy questions when 64% of consumers say they plan to wait for Thanksgiving weekend. The hosts also cover diesel and memory cost pressure on electronics gifting, cited by NRF's chief economist, and why knowing your cost per item matters.
Subscribe to The Checkout Point for weekly retail, ecommerce, and supply chain analysis. If this episode was useful, share it with a colleague who is planning holiday inventory, promotions, or search strategy, and leave a rating or review to help other listeners find the show.
📣 We Want to Hear from You!
Timeline
In this episode
6 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.
- 0:28Introduction
- 2:10Two Forecasts, One Holiday Season
- 7:13The Turn: AI Referrals Change Where Shoppers Come From
- 12:19Mueller on AI SEO: Boring Basics Still Win
- 16:36Early Black Friday Deals and the Electronics Squeeze
- 20:08Outro
Quick answers
Straight from the episode
The questions this one settles, without the listen.
- What is the NRF forecast for the 2025 holiday season?
- NRF forecasts November-December retail sales growth of 4.2% to $1.013 trillion, versus 3.1% to $972 billion last year. The episode notes about half of that growth is real after roughly 2.5% core goods inflation, and that 64% of consumers say they are waiting for Thanksgiving weekend sales.
Transcript
The full conversation
Every word of the episode, 3,679 of them, in the order they were said.
Read the transcriptHide the transcript
MaxWelcome to the Checkout Point, your quick dive into this week's ecommerce buzz with me, Alex, powered by Blicket. These 20 minutes pack the latest trends, news, and insights. Let's navigate the digital marketplace together. Ready? Let's go.
RachelI saw a holiday display in a store last week. Last week. There was a pumpkin sitting next to a snow globe.
Speaker 3Though nobody asked the pumpkin how it felt about that.
RachelRight. The season starts earlier every year, and I mean, come on, we haven't even finished the candy.
Speaker 3Early starts are fine, but what's the actual ROI of starting in October? That's what I wanna know.
RachelSee, that's why you're here. I'd just buy the snow globe.
Speaker 3Of course you would.
RachelAnd before anyone says it, yes, I know the stores aren't doing it just to annoy me. They're doing it because they hope it works. Every year, they pull the start line a little earlier and cross their fingers.
Speaker 3Hope is not a line item. We're gonna poke at that hope today politely with a spreadsheet.
RachelSo welcome to the Checkout Point week forty-five. I'm Max.
Speaker 3And I'm Rachel.
RachelOkay, two things are bugging me this week. First, the holiday forecasts are out, and there are a couple of big numbers floating around.
Speaker 3Mm-hmm, and big numbers always come with fine print. I've watched forecasts look great on a slide and then fall apart on the warehouse floor.
RachelSupply chain bottleneck energy.
Speaker 3Always. Fine print is where the bottleneck lives.
RachelSecond thing, where is holiday traffic even gonna come from this year? Because the answer might not be where you've been sending your budget.
Speaker 3Wait, really? That sounds like a spreadsheet nobody wants to open.
RachelOh, you'll open it. I promise.
Speaker 3Fine, but no hand-waving.
RachelDeal. So anyway, let's start with the big question. How big is this holiday season gonna be, and how does the new NRF number stack up against the Adobe one you've heard before?
Speaker 3Yeah. Let's see which one holds up.
RachelOkay, NRF first. The National Retail Federation says November and December retail sales grow four point two percent this year.
Speaker 3To what, though? Percent is cheap. Give me the dollars.
RachelAbout one point zero one three trillion dollars. That's the exact figure.
Speaker 3Trillion with a T.
RachelWith a T. And last year, NRF's own numbers had growth at three point one percent, landing at roughly nine hundred and seventy-two billion dollars.
Speaker 3So the jump is about a full point faster than last year. Sounds great, but what's the actual ROI of that headline?
RachelThere she is.
Speaker 3I'm serious. Inflation eats growth. If prices rise, you're not selling more stuff. You're selling the same stuff for more.
RachelTotally. NRF expects core goods inflation to average two point five percent.
Speaker 3So roughly half of that four point two is just price tags going up.
RachelRight. The other half is real spending, real people actually buying more.
Speaker 3Which is a lot less exciting on a slide.
RachelIt really is. And the half part is rough math, but the direction holds. Growth that is partly just higher prices doesn't mean more orders landing in your queue.
Speaker 3Right, and that's the trap. A merchant sees four point two in a headline, bumps the inventory order by four point two, and then wonders why the warehouse is full in January.
RachelThe January pallet problem.
Speaker 3It's always January. Then comes the clearance sale nobody planned.
RachelWait, there's another number in there that matters more for us. NRF ran a survey in October.
Speaker 3Uh-oh, I can feel a margin problem coming.
RachelSixty-four percent of consumers said they'd likely wait for Thanksgiving weekend sales to do most of their shopping.
Speaker 3Sixty-four, almost two out of three.
RachelYep.
Speaker 3Okay, that's a supply chain problem wearing a gift bag. Everybody shows up the same four days, and your inventory, your ad costs, your support queue, all of it spikes at once.
RachelAnd discounts get deeper because everybody's waiting for them. You know what I mean?
Speaker 3I've lived this. At Amazon, we planned around those days like a military operation, and the shoppers who waited were never the full price ones.
RachelNever. Funny, I watched a client try to dodge that crush once. They pushed a promo out early because they wanted to get ahead of the holiday. The dashboard looked fantastic for a few days. Then it went flat, and the big spike showed up right when everybody else's sales started anyway.
Speaker 3So the early push just-
RachelMoved the demand earlier, and it cost them margin. I remember telling them we threw a party and only invited people who were already coming.
Speaker 3And the snacks were discounted.
RachelDeeply discounted. Okay, that's my story.
Speaker 3Now, where does the Adobe number fit? Remind me because that's online only.
RachelRight. Adobe's forecast, published September twenty-eighth, puts US online holiday spending at two hundred and seventy-five point one billion dollars.
Speaker 3For November first through December thirty-first.
RachelYep, and that's up six point seven percent.
Speaker 3Hold on. Adobe says online grows six point seven. NRF says everything grows four point two. Those aren't fighting each other?
RachelNo, they're measuring different things. NRF is the whole retail pie. Adobe is the online slice.
Speaker 3And the slice is growing faster than the pie.
RachelThat's the read. Online takes a bigger share even in a decent year.
Speaker 3Which matters if you're an online-only store. The bigger number says the whole market is moving carefully, and the Adobe number says your channel is where the faster growth is forecast.
RachelRight. But if you also have physical stores or you sell through a marketplace, the bigger number is more your world, and you'd wanna watch both.
Speaker 3Fair, but I wanna know how much to trust the pie. Has NRF been right before?
RachelUm, so Retail Dive flagged this. NRF's forecast last year was a range, three point seven to four point two percent.
Speaker 3And the actual?
RachelActual was three point one.
Speaker 3So below the bottom of their own range.
RachelRight? That's wild. They missed low end by a good chunk.
Speaker 3And this year's headline number is four point two, which was the top of last year's range.
RachelOh, nice catch. So the same number that overshot last year is the headline again.
Speaker 3I'm not saying it's wrong. I'm saying if I'm building a staffing and inventory plan, I'm not betting the whole budget on four point two.
RachelSame. I'd plan for the middle and keep a little cash flexible for the weekend rush.
Speaker 3That's a plan I can sign off on.
RachelAnd that's the thing about a forecast. It's a planning input, not a promise. You wouldn't build a bridge off one engineer's back of the envelope number.
Speaker 3And you'd want a plan B for each outcome. If the number comes in light, what do you cut first? If it comes in hot, can your fulfillment team actually handle it?
RachelHa. The honest answer to the second one is usually, "We'll figure it out."
Speaker 3That is not a plan. That is a prayer with a calendar invite.
RachelFair. So write down the trigger now. If the first big weekend lands light, here's what we cut. If it lands hot, here's who we call.
Speaker 3Decisions made when you're calm are cheaper than decisions made at midnight on a sales day. Write the plan when nobody's panicking, and your future self will send a thank you note.
RachelOkay. Now let's go see where those shoppers are actually coming from. Okay. Here's a number that made me spit out my coffee.
Speaker 3Go on.
RachelA writeup on a site called A Relevant Audience relaying Adobe's forecast says AI-referred traffic to retail sites is projected up a hundred and thirty percent.
Speaker 3Wait, a hundred and thirty?
RachelOne-three-zero. And the same writeup says social and affiliates are gaining share against paid search.
Speaker 3Hmm, paid search losing ground. That's going to make a few media buyers sweat.
RachelThink of it like a mixing board. Nobody's saying paid search goes silent, but a few other channels get louder.
Speaker 3Right. And gaining share is relative. It can mean someone else is shrinking, or it can mean everything is growing and some things grow faster. The writeup doesn't tell us which, and I'm not going to guess.
RachelTotally. Also, quick flag, this is a secondary writeup of Adobe's numbers. Adobe's own release is the primary source.
Speaker 3Good, because a percent growth with no base is a magic trick. Up a hundred and thirty from what?
RachelYeah. I can't tell you the base. The writeup gives the growth, and that's what I've got.
Speaker 3Right. So a big jump off a small number could still be a small number.
RachelCould be. Doesn't make the direction less interesting, though.
Speaker 3Interesting, sure. Let me ask the practical thing. If social and affiliates are gaining on paid search, what does a merchant actually do with that?
RachelHonestly, the writeup gives us a direction, not a playbook. But it's a reason to look at your own channel mix before the season starts, not in the middle of the rush.
Speaker 3Sure. But what's the actual ROI? More AI referrals only matter if those people buy.
RachelOkay. Fair.
Speaker 3I'm serious. At Amazon, we'd watch a traffic source spike, and everyone would cheer. Then you'd look at conversion, and it was people browsing with no intent. Great for a dashboard, useless for the P&L.
RachelThe vanity metric parade.
Speaker 3Exactly. A visit is not a sale. So if AI sends shoppers, do they arrive ready to buy or just curious?
RachelI don't know, and nothing in front of me says. Here's my take, though. Think about asking a friend where to buy a good blender.
Speaker 3Uh-oh.
RachelHear me out. If they say, "Go to that shop," you walk in already half sold, or they point you at the wrong store and you leave annoyed. Same recommendation, wildly different outcome.
Speaker 3So the quality of the recommendation matters more than the count of recommendations.
RachelFunny, I lived a version of that as an analyst. A client got a big wave of visitors from one link on a popular roundup page, and everybody high-fived. Then I looked at what those people did. Most of them landed on a page, read it, and left because the page they were sent to wasn't what the link had promised.
Speaker 3So the recommendation was wrong?
RachelThe recommendation was fine. The landing page was the one that lied. We spent a week celebrating a traffic spike that was basically a very large group of people knocking on the wrong door.
Speaker 3So the visits counted and the sales didn't. Wrong door, big crowd.
RachelYeah. And that's where a sponsored piece on Retail Dive comes in. It's from Glance, published November second, and it's labeled sponsored, so keep that in mind.
Speaker 3Noted. Ad with a byline.
RachelBasically. Its argument is that your catalog may already be visible to AI agents.
Speaker 3Already? Without anyone doing anything?
RachelThat's the pitch. And the next step, it says, is making that catalog trustworthy.
Speaker 3Trustworthy how? Accurate prices, stock, product data?
RachelThe headline is all I'd lean on. The writeup promises three barriers to what it calls agentic optimization, but I'm not gonna guess what they are.
Speaker 3Fine. But think about it logically. If an AI agent recommends your product and the price is stale or it's out of stock, you paid for nothing. That's a supply chain problem showing up in a chatbot.
RachelOoh, that's good. The shelf has to match the sign.
Speaker 3And it ties back to the forecasts. Shoppers are cautious. A lot of them are waiting for deals, and they're comparison shopping.
RachelSo a wrong answer from an AI costs you the sale to whoever has the right one.
Speaker 3Right. In a cautious season, you don't get many second chances.
RachelLet me play that out for a small store. Say you change a price on your site, but the product feed that goes elsewhere updates later. Now a shopper or an agent shopping for them sees one price and meets another.
Speaker 3And the shopper doesn't blame the feed, they blame you. That's trust, and trust is hard to win back when everyone has a dozen tabs open.
RachelWhich is why I keep coming back to the unglamorous side of this. Somebody has to own the product data.
Speaker 3And that somebody needs a name next to the task, not a committee.
RachelAnd a schedule. Like, who checks the feed against the site before the Thanksgiving weekend rush?
Speaker 3Right? And who checks it again after the first wave of price changes? Ownership is not a one-time job. It's a checklist with a name on it.
RachelSo wait, so does that mean the boring stuff like clean product data is suddenly the growth strategy?
Speaker 3I'd bet on boring over clever. Yes, every time.
RachelSpeaking of getting found by AI, here's what Google's John Mueller had to say about it.
Speaker 3Oh, this is gonna be good. Go.
RachelOkay, so Mueller, Google's John Mueller, the search guy who answers everyone's search engine optimization questions with the energy of a man who has answered them before.
Speaker 3Many times.
RachelSearch Engine Journal ran a piece on November 2nd, written by Roger Montti. The gist is that Mueller doubts the short-term AI SEO tactics and says traditional technical SEO still matters.
Speaker 3Wait, so the boring stuff survives?
RachelThat's the pitch. After all that agent talk, it's a little funny.
Speaker 3Is it funny or is it predictable? Every time a new channel shows up, somebody declares the old rule's dead.
RachelBoth. The way it's framed, the doubt is aimed at the short-term tactics, and the technical basics are still on the table.
Speaker 3But what counts as a short-term tactic? Because every agency I've dealt with has a shiny new one.
RachelRight, and that's where the second source comes in. Search Engine Roundtable covered an interview with Mueller by David Iwanow.
Speaker 3Okay.
RachelMueller says leaning on mass-produced listicles or AI-generated content to rank an AI search is risky. The reason is that search systems eventually discount spam tactics.
Speaker 3Eventually. That word is doing a lot of work.
RachelIt is. It means you can get a bump first, then the systems catch up.
Speaker 3And I've seen that movie. Years ago at Amazon, a vendor stuffed thousands of near-identical listings into the catalog. Looked great for a quarter, then they were all buried, and the cleanup cost more than the lift.
RachelOuch. So the ROI on spam is borrowed time.
Speaker 3Borrowed time with interest, and someone still has to pay the content team.
RachelAlways the content team. I saw a shortcut look like it worked once on the analyst side. A client had a page that suddenly climbed after a round of content tweaks, and the whole team treated it like a victory parade. A few weeks later, it slid right back, and I was the guy holding the chart explaining why the line looked like a ski slope.
Speaker 3A ski slope.
RachelUp the lift, down the mountain. Fun ride. Terrible for the quarterly slide.
Speaker 3Mm. But here's my question. If a chatbot is reading my pages, why does technical SEO still matter? Isn't it all just text?
RachelMueller expects technical SEO to stay relevant. Those are the write-up's words, and I'm not going to invent his reasoning beyond that.
Speaker 3Fair. Don't put words in the man's mouth.
RachelTotally. But the interview also touched on two things merchants live with. One is e-commerce product data.
Speaker 3Ooh, that's my love language.
RachelOf course it is. The other is redirect chains.
Speaker 3Redirect chains, the thing nobody wants to own.
RachelRight? You relaunch a site, you move some URLs, and then there's a hop, and another hop, and another hop.
Speaker 3And every hop is a place where something can go wrong. I'd call that a plain old maintenance problem.
RachelAnd the thing is, it's invisible until it isn't. Nobody sees a redirect chain on a normal day. You find it when someone asks why an old link takes forever or lands in the wrong place. To be clear, the interview only touched on them, and I'm not claiming more than that.
Speaker 3I'd frame it as an audit task. Pick your most important URLs, follow each one from the old address to the final one, and count the hops. It's an afternoon of work, and nobody is going to give you a trophy.
RachelWhich is kind of the point. Product data and clean redirects aren't exciting. Nobody posts a victory lap about fixing a redirect.
Speaker 3Nobody posts it, but I'd be curious what it does to conversion.
RachelYeah, and neither write-up gives us a number on that, so we don't get to claim one.
Speaker 3Good. I'd rather have no number than a made-up one.
RachelSame. What we do have is a direction. Don't build your plan on a trick that the systems are expected to discount, but you can fix what's broken on your own site.
Speaker 3Right. A fix is something you can finish and check off. A trick is something you have to keep feeding.
RachelWhich for most stores is a to-do list that's already sitting there.
Speaker 3Ugh, mine has been sitting there since spring.
RachelMine's got cobwebs. Okay, now the fun part, early deals. Merchants, this is where it gets real for your margins.
Speaker 3Fine, show me the discounts, and then I'll ask what they cost.
RachelOkay, so I went looking for early Black Friday deals, and they're already here. It's November 2nd.
Speaker 3Of course they are. Of course.
RachelMashable ran a piece with the headline that the M5 MacBook Air is two hundred dollars off at Amazon, but there's a catch.
Speaker 3There's always a catch. What's the catch?
RachelHonestly, the write-up teases it in the headline, and the excerpt I have just says Apple Intelligence is here, and you don't have to pay full retail to get in, so I'm not going to invent the catch for you.
Speaker 3Fair. Saying a number I can't verify is worse than saying nothing.
RachelTotally. Second one, also Mashable, same writer. The Dreame L40 Ultra Gen 2 robot vacuum is two hundred and fifty dollars off.
Speaker 3Is that the one that cleans its own mops?
RachelYes. Reaches in corners, doesn't complain about pet hair. Better employee than most of us.
Speaker 3Speak for yourself. Okay, but those are both reported as of November second. Deals move. By the time someone hears this, the price could be gone.
RachelRight, so treat them as a signal, not a shopping list.
Speaker 3That's the right instinct. A competitor's price is a data point, not an instruction.
RachelYeah. I watched a client once copy a rival sale banner word for word and then act surprised that their margins look different. Their costs weren't the rival's costs. Same banner, different math.
Speaker 3And the signal matters for merchants. Remember NRF's October survey where sixty-four percent said they'd likely wait for Thanksgiving weekend sales?
RachelWait, so people are waiting, and retailers are discounting now.
Speaker 3Exactly, which makes early discounting a strategy question, not a reflex.
RachelOkay, but if the competitor's already at two hundred dollars off and you're not, you look like the expensive one.
Speaker 3Sure. That's the bottleneck. Everybody's afraid to be the last one holding a full-price shelf.
RachelFull-price shelf. Sounds like a horror movie.
Speaker 3To a merchant, it is. And there's more pressure underneath. Retail Dive reported that NRF's chief economist said higher diesel and memory prices are pressuring electronics gifting.
RachelMemory prices, as in the RAM stuff we've been seeing?
Speaker 3That's the connection, yeah. Electronics are the classic early deal category, and the cost of building and shipping them is going up.
RachelSo wait, deals start early, but costs are climbing.
Speaker 3Right. Margins get squeezed from both ends.
RachelThat's rough, because a two hundred and fifty dollar off sticker on a robot vacuum looks great to a shopper, but somebody's eating that.
Speaker 3Somebody always is, and for a smaller merchant without Amazon's scale, eating it for a month is a very different thing.
RachelNo way around it. You've gotta pick your spots: which products, how deep, and how long.
Speaker 3And how long is the one people skip. An early deal with no end date turns into the new normal price in the shopper's head.
RachelThat's the part that scares me. You can run a promotion for a short stretch, but a customer remembers the lowest price they saw, not the date it stopped.
Speaker 3Before you cut anything, know your cost on that item today, not what it was in the spring.
RachelBoring advice, but I like it.
Speaker 3Boring pays the bills.
RachelAnd for electronics specifically, that cost line is the one I'd check twice, since memory prices are named in the pressure.
Speaker 3Right. If the product is electronics and your cost has moved, a deal that worked before may not pencil out now. Check the math per item, not per category, and write down what you'd stop discounting if costs keep climbing so the decision is already made.
RachelOkay, quick landing. Four stories, one takeaway each. Forecasts first, both come with fine print, so read the footnotes before you plan inventory.
Speaker 3Shoppers are finding products through AI and social now, not just search boxes. Your product data has to be clean enough for a machine to read.
RachelMueller says shortcuts get discounted eventually. Boring technical work sticks around.
Speaker 3And the early deals, fun to watch, dangerous to copy.
RachelWait, so what's the homework, Rachel?
Speaker 3One action. Before you match anybody's early discount, pull your landed cost on your top ten sellers and write down the lowest price you can run without losing money. Then ask the question I always ask.
RachelWhat's the actual ROI?
Speaker 3Thank you. Spreadsheet first, sale second.
RachelTotally. And if you want more of this, head to blicket.co and subscribe so the next episode just shows up.
Speaker 3It's free, which is the only discount I fully trust.
RachelNice.
Speaker 3See you next week.
RachelAnd if your spreadsheet says the sale doesn't pencil out, blame Rachel.
More episodes
Keep listening
Other episodes of The Checkout Point, newest first.
- Week 47 - Adobe Black Friday Forecast: Shopify Sidekick Print-on-Demand, Everyday Essentials Stock-Up, and Early Amazon DealsNov 16, 2026 · 22 min
- Week 46 - Agentic Commerce Checkout: Amazon vs Walmart on Shopping Agents, Ziff Davis' Google Referral Drop, and Early Black Friday DealsNov 9, 2026 · 20 min
- Week 45 - ChatGPT Brand Mentions: Why Cited Pages Don't Guarantee a Name Drop, Plus Shopify's Agent Checkout, an Adobe Forecast Refresher, and New Ecommerce ToolsOct 26, 2026 · 21 min
- Week 44 - Holiday Spending Forecasts: Adobe's $275.1B Number, Deloitte's Second Opinion, Prime Big Deal Days Results, and Shopify's Canvas ToolOct 19, 2026 · 24 min
Sources
Where this came from
9 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.
- Consumers remain the bright spot heading into the holidays (NRF)nrf.com
- NRF forecasts 4.2% holiday sales growth, muted seasonal hiring (Retail Dive)retaildive.com
- Adobe: $275.1B US holiday online spend, AI traffic +130%relevantaudience.com
- Adobe: U.S. Holiday Shopping Season to Hit Record $275.1 Billion Online, Rising 6.7% YoYnews.adobe.com
- Early Black Friday robot vacuum deal: The self-emptying Dreame L40 Ultra Gen 2 is $250 offmashable.com
- Google Says Technical SEO Remains Key For AI SEO via @sejournal, @martinibustersearchenginejournal.com
- John Mueller Says Eventually Systems Will Catch The AI Spamseroundtable.com
- The M5 MacBook Air is $200 off at Amazon, but theres a catchmashable.com
- Your catalog may already be visible to AI agents. Making it trustworthy is the next step.retaildive.com
