The Day the Forests Browned
Show notes
What the episode covers
Around 56 million years ago, during the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM), Wyoming's forests thinned as ferns and palms replaced broad-leaved trees in a greenhouse world.
This episode of Fault Lines asks a central question: is the PETM a true analog for modern carbon emissions, or does it only look like one? The hosts weigh 2026 studies on canopy loss and recovery, a fern spike recorded across several continents, and a newly proposed sink in which increased erosion boosted terrestrial organic carbon burial in the ocean. They also compare estimates of how fast carbon was released then and now, noting where the rock record is least certain.
It is for listeners who want to understand which parts of the PETM comparison hold up, and which strain.
Timeline
In this episode
7 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.
- 0:15Introduction
- 2:06Exhibit A: The Canopy Opens
- 5:51Exhibit B: Ferns Everywhere
- 9:22The Turn: The Ocean as Janitor
- 12:43Fast Release on Trial
- 17:17Verdict: Mirror or Lookalike?
- 20:03Outro
Quick answers
Straight from the episode
The questions this one settles, without the listen.
- What did the Science paper find about forests during the PETM?
- The authors report an abrupt opening of the forest canopy at onset, with about 60% canopy loss, increased erosion, and a shift from broad-leaved angiosperms to ferns and palms. They say recovery took well over 100,000 years, and they frame the PETM as an analog for rapid warming.
- Was the PETM fern spike just a local fluke?
- The hosts argue it was not. A PNAS January 2026 study reports a fern spike across several continents. The hosts say multiple continents narrow the excuses and strengthen the idea that warming reshapes land everywhere, though this evidence says nothing about rate.
- How did the ocean help absorb excess carbon during the PETM?
- A 2026 Nature Geoscience paper (Inglis et al., using a Bristol record) finds that terrestrial organic carbon burial rose about 10- to 50-fold. More erosion and faster coastal sedimentation sequestered excess carbon. Palaeoclimate models omit this sink, so simulations are missing a piece.
- Did forest erosion feed the coastal carbon burial?
- The hosts raise this question with hedging. The sources they cite do not link the Wyoming recovery time to burial, so a direct link would be needed to test the idea. It remains a possibility rather than an established result.
- How fast was carbon released in the PETM compared with today?
- A Nature Geoscience study of New Jersey shelf records puts onset release at no less than 4,000 years, capping the rate below about 1.1 Pg C per year, versus about 10 Pg C per year in 2014. The Science authors say humans release CO2 roughly ten times faster. A 2019 Gingerich paper finds modern emissions about 9-10 times the median onset rate, but says one-year extrapolation is poorly constrained.
- Is the PETM a good analog for modern climate change?
- The verdict is hedged. The record supports the analog for how ecosystems and carbon burial responded, but it strains on rate. Fast release is the lesson about today and slow recovery is the lesson about consequences, and both readings can be true.
Transcript
The full conversation
Every word of the episode, 3,166 of them, in the order they were said.
Read the transcriptHide the transcript
OlaPicture Wyoming about fifty-six million years ago. The canopy overhead is opening up, light hitting the forest floor where it never used to.
AmaraAnd what's moving into the gaps? Ferns, palms. Oh, the forest is basically losing its hair and getting a very tropical wig.
OlaAmara.
AmaraWhat? It's a hothouse. Everyone's dressing for it.
OlaFine, but the cause is serious. A huge burst of carbon pushed the whole planet into that hothouse, and the Wyoming forests thinned as ferns and palms took over.
AmaraOh, man, and we're the ones who keep pointing at it. Every time somebody talks about modern carbon, this event shows up as the scary mirror.
OlaWhich is where my notebook comes out. Is it a mirror, or does it only look like one?
AmaraHold on, you're already sounding like a judge.
OlaGood, because that's the plan. Welcome to Fault Lines. I'm Ola. That's Amara, and this episode puts the PETM on trial.
AmaraTwo rival readings on the stand. One says the carbon came fast. The other says the recovery was slow.
OlaFast release, slow recovery.
AmaraWait for it, because they might both be true and still ruin the comparison.
OlaWhich means the verdict has to be careful. Three 2026 studies are going to testify about what the carbon did to the land and to the sea.
AmaraAnd a couple of other papers show up as backup witnesses on the question of speed. So settle in. This is a proper trial.
OlaI'm not telling you which way I lean. I want to hear the evidence first.
AmaraOf course you do. Okay, then.
OlaBefore we judge the analog, let's meet the witnesses in the forest. Start with what the science paper actually reports. The forest canopy opened abruptly right at the onset of the PETM. Not gradually, abruptly.
AmaraAbruptly, like a light switch?
OlaThe abstract says abruptly, so I'll stay there. It also says erosion increased, bare ground, rain, soil going downhill.
AmaraOh, man, so the trees thin out, and the hillside just leaves.
OlaThat's the implication, yes, and the vegetation that comes back is a different cast entirely. Broad-leaved flowering trees give way to ferns and palms.
AmaraHold on. Palms? In Wyoming?
OlaI know. My Oslo childhood did not prepare me for palm trees on a mountain basin postcard.
AmaraBut why does the swap matter? Trees are trees, aren't they?
OlaNot quite. Broad-leaved flowering trees and ferns and palms are very different kinds of plants, so a swap like that changes what the whole landscape looks like and what it's made of. The abstract describes a shift, and I'd call that a change of cast, not a few missing extras.
AmaraOkay, so get this. How much forest are we talking? Because opened could mean a few gaps.
OlaThe study's authors wrote up their own summary for the conversation. They say the Wyoming forests lost about sixty percent of their canopy.
AmaraSixty? Wow.
OlaPicture walking through a woodland where six out of every ten crowns overhead are just gone.
AmaraShut up. And the comeback, weekend project?
OlaDeadpan. Well over a hundred thousand years to come back. That's the author's number.
AmaraWait for it. That is longer than anything we call human history. Modern humans haven't been around for much more than that.
OlaCareful. That's your arithmetic, not theirs. I'd keep to what they say. The forest took well over a hundred thousand years to come back.
AmaraFair. Still a very long time to wait for your trees.
OlaAnd that's the slow recovery side of our fight sitting right there in the Wyoming rock.
AmaraLet me test that. If the canopy opened abruptly and the comeback took that long, the lopsidedness is the story, right? Quick damage, slow repair.
OlaThat's the shape the author's numbers give, abrupt at onset and well over a hundred thousand years to recover. I'd keep it at that because I can't tell you what happened in between, only the opening and the outcome.
AmaraSo why does anyone care outside Wyoming?
OlaBecause the authors frame the PETM as an analog for rapid warming driven by humans. The paper says regional data point to continental-scale landscape destabilization.
AmaraContinental scale from a Wyoming forest?
OlaThat's the claim, and it's a big jump, one basin speaking for a continent.
AmaraWhich is exactly what I'd side-eye. One forest could be a fluke, Ola.
OlaTo be fair to the authors, the abstract also talks about feedbacks in the hydrological and carbon cycles that played out over many thousands of years. So they're arguing for a bigger picture, not just a pretty fossil forest.
AmaraBut it's still a bigger picture built from regional data. That's an argument, not a closed case.
OlaAgreed. So the question is whether other continents show the same thing. And then there's the sea. If land was shedding that much soil, where did it all end up?
AmaraOoh, following the dirt downstream, I like it.
OlaOkay, other continents. The PNAS paper in January 2026 reports a fern spike across several continents at the onset of the PETM.
AmaraSeveral, not one lucky outcrop.
OlaRight. Ferns are the plants that show up when the neighborhood has been flattened.
AmaraThe first guest at the party after the fire department leaves.
OlaHa, fair. But I want to be careful with the word spike. The brief says a fern spike, and that is what I can vouch for.
AmaraMeaning?
OlaMeaning I can't tell you how big it was in each place or how long it lasted anywhere. I only have the headline.
AmaraOkay, so even the headline is a big deal. Ferns popping up on several land masses at the moment in the rock record is hard to blame on one bad local drought.
OlaHmm, unless several places had one bad drought each.
AmaraOla.
OlaI'm serious. Where does the spike come from? That's my question. Same cause or the same plant reflex?
AmaraThen listen to how the La Brea Tar Pits write it up. They describe a researcher reconstructing forests from fifty-six million years ago, and they call it a widespread browning of landscapes.
OlaBrowning, not just thinning.
AmaraBrowning, and they pin it on elevated CO2, warming, and reduced rainfall, all triggered by a volcanically driven carbon release.
OlaHold on. Reduced rainfall is doing a lot of work there. That's drying, not only heating.
AmaraWhich would explain why ferns win. Wait for it. The Tar Pits piece even says trees are at the root of these drastic changes.
OlaAt the root. Somebody enjoyed writing that.
AmaraSomebody had a pun budget and spent it all.
OlaPun budget aside, notice what the write-up adds and what it doesn't. It adds a vivid label, browning, and a list of ingredients: elevated CO2, warming, reduced rainfall. It doesn't hand me numbers for any of them.
AmaraSo it's a good description of the scene, not a measurement of it.
OlaFine. But this is a museum write-up, so I treat it as a summary, not as the data.
AmaraSure. So does it make the analog stronger? Several continents, browning, a carbon burst. Looks like today's headlines to me.
OlaAll right. Stronger for the question of whether warming reshapes land everywhere. I'll give you that. For the question of whether it reshapes it the way it's doing now, no. Ferns on several continents tell me what happened, not how fast.
AmaraOoh, you're sneaking up on the rate thing.
OlaI'm sneaking. We aren't there yet.
AmaraBefore you sneak off, give me the fair-minded version. Why would several continents matter even if you can't say how fast?
OlaBecause it narrows the excuses. One outcrop can be a local accident. Several continents showing the same fern spike at the onset of the PETM points towards something bigger than local weather, even though I can't say how big or whether one cause explains every site.
AmaraFine. Then there's the other half of the story, because all that carbon had to go somewhere.
OlaNow the sea, which may have helped clean up the mess.
AmaraOh, you're gonna love this part.
OlaOkay, I need to check a number before I say it out loud. Yep. The Nature Geoscience paper, 2026, lead author Inglis, according to the University of Bristol record, says burial of land-derived organic carbon rose about ten to fifty fold.
AmaraTen to fifty. That's not a range. That's a shrug with a calculator.
OlaIt's wide, sure, but even the low end is ten times more carbon getting tucked into seafloor mud.
AmaraTucked in how? Give me the mechanism.
OlaTwo drivers per the record: more erosion and faster sedimentation along the coast. So stuff comes off the land, gets dumped near shore, and gets buried quickly.
AmaraBuried before it can rot and turn back into CO2.
OlaThat's the idea. The paper says this burial sequestered excess carbon, pulled it out of circulation.
AmaraOh, man. So the ocean is the janitor, mops up what the volcanoes spilled.
OlaA janitor that works with whatever the land sends down. And here's a detail I liked. The paper says paleoclimate model simulations leave this delivery out.
AmaraWait, out entirely?
OlaThat's what the record says. The models miss an important carbon sink.
AmaraWhy should a listener care that a model skipped a step? Models are simplifications anyway.
OlaThey are. But these are the simulations of the PETM climate. If a model leaves out the sink the rock record suggests was real, then any comparison between model and reality is working with a missing piece.
AmaraWhich means the models are cleaning a room with no janitor in it and then wondering why the real room recovered differently.
OlaCareful. I'd stop at what's stated. The models omit it. Whether that fully explains the recovery, nobody's claiming I can see.
AmaraFair, but let me poke at this. Ola, the forests we just talked through had erosion, bare slopes, loose soil, and now the sea has a burial surge fed by erosion.
OlaHmm, same word, two locations.
AmaraRight? Could the landscape falling apart upstream be the thing feeding the burial downstream?
OlaIt's a tempting line. Wait, though. I want to be plain about this because I grew up with a mother who edited out every sentence a reporter couldn't source.
AmaraTough editor.
OlaIt's a source issue. The sources here don't tie the Wyoming recovery time to the burial. Nobody connected those two. So that link is us guessing out loud.
AmaraA hedged guess. Plausible, not proven.
OlaExactly. Erosion shows up in both stories. That's a reason to ask, not a reason to conclude.
AmaraAnd honestly, it's kind of a lovely question. The forests browned, the dirt moved, the sea might have swallowed the evidence of the crime.
OlaSwallowed some of the carbon anyway.
AmaraAnd if somebody wanted to test our guess, what would they need to show?
Speaker 3Something none of our sources do, a direct link between the landslide erosion and the coastal burial with the recovery time attached. Until somebody draws that line, it stays a question we asked out loud.
AmaraOkay, but here's what's nagging me. A cleanup crew only matters relative to the mess. A big spill and a slow mop is one story. A small spill is another.
Speaker 3Right. And all this burial tells us about the cleanup, nothing about the spill.
AmaraSo if the pulse had a cleanup crew, how fast was the pulse itself?
Speaker 3That one has a sharper edge than you'd think. Okay, rate. A different Nature Geoscience paper, not the burial one, uses New Jersey shelf records. It looks at the relative timing of climate change and carbon cycle change.
AmaraAnd the punchline?
Speaker 3The carbon release at PETM onset took at least four thousand years. That caps the sustained rate below about one point one petagrams of carbon per year.
AmaraPetagrams. Remind me what a petagram looks like.
Speaker 3A billion metric tons, so roughly one billion tons every year for four thousand years at the fastest.
AmaraOkay, that sounds enormous already.
Speaker 3It is. Now the comparison. The same study puts human release at about ten petagrams per year, and that figure is for twenty fourteen.
AmaraTen times the ceiling?
Speaker 3Roughly, yes. And the paper concludes the modern rate is unprecedented in the past sixty-six million years.
AmaraSixty-six. So the PETM isn't even the record holder for fast. We're beating it, and it's the one we keep calling the fast one.
Speaker 3Right.
AmaraWait, though, four thousand years is a floor, at least four thousand, so the real rate could be even slower than that cap.
Speaker 3Correct. And that only widens the gap. The cap is the fastest it could have gone.
AmaraOkay, but does anyone else land on that tenfold number? Because I don't trust one paper with my whole worldview.
Speaker 3Fair. The authors of the science paper, in their own write-up for the Conversation, say humans are releasing CO2 roughly ten times faster than natural processes did then.
AmaraHold on. Those are the Wyoming forest people?
Speaker 3Same team. They also call the PETM the closest natural analog to today's warming.
AmaraHuh. So the star witness for the analog is the one saying the analog runs ten times slow.
Speaker 3Both at once, yes. Closest analog and ten times gentler on the release side.
AmaraGentler. Tell that to the ferns.
Speaker 3Fine. Gentler on rate only. Now, I fact-checked one more before we got here. A two thousand nineteen paper by Gingerich argues you have to compare rates on a common timescale.
AmaraMeaning what, practically?
Speaker 3Meaning you can't set a slow average over thousands of years next to a single fast year and call it a contest. Put them on the same clock, and modern emissions come out roughly nine to ten times the median PETM onset rate.
AmaraHuh. Same answer, different route.
Speaker 3Which is the reassuring part for the tenfold claim. I wouldn't call them independent confirmations, though. They land in the same neighborhood, and that's all I'll say.
AmaraAnd the not reassuring part?
Speaker 3The same paper cautions that stretching the PETM rate down to a one-year timescale is poorly constrained.
AmaraSo nobody actually knows what the PETM looked like in its worst single year.
Speaker 3The rock can't resolve it. Thousands of years of mud don't give you a daily record. It could have had bursts we can't see.
AmaraPlot twist, the tenfold number is solid on the long clock and fuzzy on the short one.
Speaker 3Exactly that, and it matters for the argument because fast release is the whole case against the analog.
AmaraSo if the PETM had hidden spikes, the gap shrinks.
Speaker 3Possibly. The sources don't say how much, so I won't invent it.
AmaraGood. I'd have fact-checked you mid-sentence.
Speaker 3That's my job. So fast release, slow recovery, and a rock record that's fuzzy at the exact scale we care about.
AmaraAnd honestly, that's the part I keep chewing on. The comparison is clearest where the rock is clearest and blurriest right where our own lives happen.
Speaker 3Well put. Okay, Amara, you've earned the gavel.
AmaraGavel time. Time for the verdict.
Speaker 4Okay, verdict on the verdict. Mirror or lookalike? I'm going to say both, and I want to be allowed to explain.
AmaraOh, you're hedging already. Fine, go.
Speaker 4On what the planet did, the record holds up. Forests opened, ferns spread, the land eroded, and the coast buried carbon. That chain looks like a response we can reasonably expect from a warming world.
AmaraSo the mirror part is the response.
Speaker 4The response, yes. Rate is where the glass gets wavy.
AmaraWavy glass. Ola, you have been saving that one.
Speaker 4Since the third coffee. But look at what each hypothesis actually teaches. Fast release is the lesson about today. We are the fast part.
AmaraAnd slow recovery is the lesson about the consequences. Wyoming didn't bounce back in a human lifetime or a thousand of them.
Speaker 4And notice they don't compete as much as we pretended in the cold open. The fast release evidence says how unusual our rate is, and the slow recovery evidence says what the land paid last time.
AmaraSo they might both be true, which I did say in the intro. I would like credit for the prediction.
OlaRight. And the sea sink, if it did help, is a possibility, not a settled mechanism. I wouldn't bet a notebook on it.
AmaraYou'd bet a notebook? That's serious. You guard that thing.
OlaWith my life.
AmaraOkay, but here's my worry. If the rock record is only a partial mirror, does anybody in a negotiating room care?
OlaWell, there's a room scheduled. The United Nations says COP thirty-one runs nine to twenty November twenty twenty-six in Antalya, Türkiye.
AmaraSo negotiators will be arguing over decades, and we're over here with a fifty-six-million-year-old fern spike.
OlaWhich is useful, honestly. Nobody in that room gets a rock record of how their own decision plays out. We get one finished experiment, imperfect with a different starting world.
AmaraImperfect experiment. I'll take it over a vibe.
OlaSame. The record can't tell them what to do. It can tell them what the land did last time carbon came up fast.
AmaraAnd how long it sulked afterward.
OlaSulked. Yes, a long sulk.
AmaraGive me the one-sentence version for someone skimming. What holds? What strains?
OlaAnd what holds is the response, canopy loss, erosion, ferns and palms, carbon buried at the coast. What strains is the rate, because the release then looks gentler than the release now, and the rock can't resolve the very short timescales.
AmaraSo the case is made, the jury is hedging, and the notebook is safe.
OlaThen that's the case. Let's close it out. Amara, I keep coming back to those Wyoming trees. Whatever the sea did afterward, the canopy was gone first.
AmaraOh, the brown forest. Hold on, I have a mental image now, and it's a bunch of palms standing around looking embarrassed.
OlaFair, but that's the part I'd carry out of here. The leaves were the first witnesses, and they're still testifying.
AmaraMm, and the rock's been keeping the minutes, even if the sea may have helped keep the books.
OlaSo where does that leave our trial? I'd say the analog holds for how the land and coast responded, and it strains on rate, hedged because the rock can't resolve the shortest timescales.
AmaraHedged, but not mushy. A mirror for what happens, a bit wavy on how fast, and I still like picturing that canopy opening up, light on the forest floor, ferns and palms moving in like they'd been waiting for the door to open.
OlaRight. A forest can take the long way back. That's the image I'd keep.
AmaraOkay. Housekeeping because you earned it. If this was your thing, subscribe and leave us a review. It helps other rock nerds find the show.
OlaAnd write to us. The address is hello@heymato.com. Tell us your favorite epoch.
AmaraOr tell us a theory you think we got wrong. Ola will take notes in his notebook.
OlaI will. Probably in pencil so I can revise.
AmaraThanks for listening to Fault Lines.
More episodes
Keep listening
Other episodes of Fault Lines, newest first.
- The Day the Plates Started MovingNov 11, 2026 · 21 min
- The Day the Ocean SuffocatedOct 28, 2026 · 21 min
- The Hour the Sky Turned to BroilerOct 21, 2026 · 20 min
- The Volcano That Never EruptedOct 14, 2026 · 22 min
Sources
Where this came from
7 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.
- Ancient forests took 100,000 years to recover from the last global warming period similar to todaytheconversation.com
- Enhanced marine burial of terrestrial organic carbon through the Palaeocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum (University of Bristol record)research-information.bris.ac.uk
- Forest canopy decline under elevated CO2 during the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (Science abstract, PubMed)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Anthropogenic carbon release rate unprecedented during the past 66 million years (Nature Geoscience)nature.com
- COP31 to take place 9-20 November 2026 in Antalya, Türkiye | United Nationsun.org
- Paleocene Eocene Thermal Maximum Carbon Release Studytarpits.org
- Temporal Scaling of Carbon Emission and Accumulation Rates: Modern Anthropogenic Emissions Compared to Estimates of PETM Onset Accumulation (Gingerich 2019)agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com
