Mato just raised pre-seed Read more

The Inherited IRA Letter Said '10 Years.' The IRS Wants a Withdrawal by December 31.

  • Nov 16, 2026
  • 11 min

Show notes

What the episode covers

If you inherited an IRA from someone who died after 2019, a custodian's "10 years" letter may not tell you everything you need to know. This episode explains the missing half of the inherited IRA rule and walks through a simple three-question check you can finish in under ten minutes. It then applies the same kind of check to your own required minimum distribution (RMD), and covers what to do if you have already missed one.

The stakes are real. The IRS ended its grace period for missed inherited IRA withdrawals, the 2021-2024 waivers were transition relief, and the 25% excise tax can apply when a required withdrawal is skipped. With the Dec 31, 2026 deadline close, this is a good time to confirm where you stand rather than assume.

  • The rule split: under the July 2024 final regulations, the owner's status at death determines whether heirs take yearly withdrawals and empty the account by year 10, or can wait or skip years.
  • The key test: the owner's required beginning date, as described in IRS Publication 590-B, determines whether a withdrawal is due.
  • The three questions: did the owner die after 2019, were they already taking withdrawals, and have you taken this year's withdrawal yet?
  • Your own RMD: how turning 73, the April 1 delay for your first RMD year, and the two-withdrawals-in-one-year trap can catch owners off guard.
  • If you missed one: record what you know, set a calendar reminder, and see a tax professional about next steps.

Roth IRA beneficiaries follow the same rules, and responsibility rests with the account owner or heir rather than the custodian's letter. If your records are fuzzy, ask the custodian and bring in a tax professional.

This episode is general information, not tax advice. Confirm your situation with a qualified tax professional.

Made a decision? That's a win. Subscribe so you're ready for the next one, and if there's a money choice you're stuck on, drop it in the reviews.

Timeline

In this episode

4 moments worth skipping to. The timecodes match the player above.

  1. 0:00The Letter That Said '10 Years'
  2. 2:26What the Letter Leaves Out
  3. 5:17The 3-Question Check
  4. 8:11Your Own RMD, the April 1 Trap, and the Fix

Quick answers

Straight from the episode

The questions this one settles, without the listen.

Do I have to take yearly withdrawals from an inherited IRA and still empty it within 10 years?
It depends on the owner's status at death. Under the July 2024 final regulations, if the owner died on or after their required beginning date, heirs must take yearly withdrawals and empty the account by year 10. If the owner died before that date, heirs can wait or skip years, as long as the account is emptied by the end of year 10.
What is the three-question check for inherited IRA withdrawals?
Ask whether the owner died after 2019, whether the owner was already taking required withdrawals, and whether this year's withdrawal has been taken yet. If the first two answers are yes, a withdrawal is likely due this year. The key test is the owner's required beginning date, as described in Publication 590-B.
What happens if I miss a required withdrawal from an inherited IRA?
A 25% excise tax can apply. The episode notes that the IRS waivers for 2021-2024 were transition relief, not a permanent pass, and the limited 2020-2023 relief came with no make-up. If you missed a withdrawal, see a tax professional.
Can I rely on a custodian's letter saying I have 10 years to empty an inherited IRA?
Not by itself. Such a letter can leave out the yearly-withdrawal half of the rule, which applies when the owner died on or after the required beginning date. The heir who trusted the letter hit a penalty. You are responsible for the withdrawals, so ask the custodian about the owner's status and involve a tax pro if records are unclear.
What is the April 1 trap for my own required minimum distribution?
In the year you turn 73, you can delay your first RMD until April 1 of the following year. Doing so means you take two withdrawals in one year, your delayed first one and that year's regular one. The check is whether you are turning 73, whether it is your first RMD year, and whether this year's withdrawal is taken.
Do Roth IRA beneficiaries follow the same inherited IRA withdrawal rules?
Yes. The episode says Roth beneficiaries follow the same rules, so the same three-question check applies. Custodians may report the RMD amount, but you should still record the amount and date of your withdrawal and set a calendar reminder.

Transcript

The full conversation

Every word of the episode, 1,889 of them, in the order they were said.

Read the transcriptHide the transcript

Derek WuPicture an heir who gets a letter from the custodian of the IRA she just inherited. The letter says ten years, so she does what most of us would do. She leaves it alone and lets it grow. That's the story in a twenty four seven Wall Street piece by Vilma Rios, published in November twenty twenty-six. It describes a woman who trusted that letter and let her inherited IRA compound untouched. Then the IRS ended its four-year grace period, and her quiet strategy turned into a penalty. Nobody told her she'd done anything wrong because for four years she hadn't. The IRS had been waiving the penalty. Doing nothing was safe, and then the rule changed under her. Here's what ended. A secondary explainer on IRA dot com says the IRS penalty waivers covering twenty twenty-one through twenty twenty-four were transition relief. That relief is over. From twenty twenty-five on, heirs who owe annual required withdrawals are expected to take them, and the penalty applies if they don't. Now the stakes, and I'll give you the one number worth remembering. If you inherited an IRA from someone who died after twenty nineteen and that person was already taking required withdrawals, a yearly withdrawal is due by December thirty-first, twenty twenty-six. Miss it, and the excise tax is twenty-five percent. Twenty-five percent of the amount you should have taken out, not of the whole account, but of the shortfall. Still, picture a missed withdrawal and then picture a quarter of it going to the IRS for no reason except a letter that skipped a sentence. I want to be dry about this because it's a boring topic, and I respect that. Nobody wakes up excited to read IRA paperwork. Leaving it in the drawer feels like the careful move. It feels like the safe do-nothing option. Nobody puts an IRA deadline on the fridge, and that's exactly how this one sneaks up. It isn't. Doing nothing is a decision. It's just one you make without looking at it, and this year it comes with a deadline. The good news is that finding out whether this applies to you doesn't take a weekend. I'm going to give you a three-question check, and it takes under ten minutes. You'll need the account statement and one date, and you probably have both within reach. So why does a letter say ten years when a yearly withdrawal may be due? Because the ten-year part is only half of the rule. Start with the date that decides everything. In July twenty twenty-four, the IRS finalized its regulations on inherited IRAs. They settled a question that had been hanging around for years. The answer depends on one thing. Was the person who died already required to take withdrawals? The tax code calls that moment the required beginning date. It's simply the point where the owner has to start pulling money out each year. If the owner died on or after that date, you have two jobs. First, take a withdrawal every year during the ten-year window. Second, empty the account by year ten. Kiplinger's tax coverage lays out both requirements, and the letter you got probably mentions only the second one. Now flip it. If the owner died before that date, you get much more freedom. You can wait. You can take money every year. You can skip years entirely. The only hard line is that the account has to be empty by year ten. So two heirs can get the same letter with the same ten-year language and have completely different obligations. One can sit still. The other has a withdrawal due by the end of the year. Same letter, different rule. The difference isn't how much money is in the account or how close you were to the person. It's the owner's status on the day they died, and a generic letter has no way of showing that. You might wonder about the people who inherited a few years ago and heard nothing. Kiplinger says beneficiaries who inherited from twenty twenty through twenty twenty-three got limited relief. They did not have to make up the years they missed. That's a real break, and it's worth knowing it was limited, not a blanket pass. Now back to the letter itself. IRA dot com, a secondary explainer, walks through what a full version of the rule looks like. For years one through nine, the yearly amount comes from the single life table. That's an IRS chart that turns your age into a divisor, and it sets how much you take out. Year ten is the emptying deadline. Whatever is left has to go. So when a custodian says ten years, it's describing the last line of the rule and skipping the nine years of instructions in front of it. Nobody's lying to you. The message is just incomplete, and the incomplete part is where the trouble starts. Think of it like a lease that says move out by year ten and leaves off the part about monthly rent. Technically true. Expensive if you stop reading there. That's why the letter alone can't tell you what to do this year. Now the part you can use, three questions that tell you whether you owe a withdrawal. The key test is the required beginning date, the point when the original owner's own required withdrawals begin. IRS Publication five ninety B draws the line there. It says no required withdrawals due to beneficiaries for the year the owner dies if the death came before that date. It also covers what happens to distributions after that date. Now let's put it in three plain yes or no questions. You can answer them with a folder of paperwork and a cup of coffee. Question one: Did the owner die after two thousand nineteen? If the answer is no, you're in an older set of rules, and this check isn't built for you. Question two: Were they already taking required withdrawals when they died? Look at the old statement. Look at the tax forms. If withdrawals were coming out every year, that's a yes. What if the records are fuzzy? Maybe the paperwork is scattered, or you weren't the one who handled their money. Don't guess. Ask the custodian what the account history shows about withdrawals before the death. An answer from them beats a hunch. And a tax pro can read the history with you.

Speaker 2Question three: Have I taken this year's withdrawal yet? That one is just a calendar check. If you haven't, and December 31st is getting close, you want to know today, not in January. Here's how to read your answers. If the first two are yes, a withdrawal is likely due by December 31st. Likely, not certain. So confirm the amount with the custodian or a tax pro before you move any money. Let's walk through a few combinations. Owner died after two thousand nineteen, withdrawals were already coming out, and you haven't taken anything this year. That's the one to act on now. Owner died after two thousand nineteen, but withdrawals hadn't started. That points to the other path from the last segment, where you may have more freedom, though the account still has to be empty by year ten. Owner died before two thousand twenty, this check isn't built for you. And you don't have to calculate the number code. IRS Publication 590-B says custodians have an obligation to report the required amount or to offer to report it. So call them and ask for the number. The phrase to use is, "What is my required minimum distribution for this year?" It's a short call, and they've heard it before. One more thing people assume: Does any of this change if the account was a Roth? It doesn't. The IRS required minimum distribution FAQs say the same RMD rules apply to Roth IRA beneficiaries. The tax-free label on the account doesn't excuse you from the schedule. Think of the three questions as a smoke detector. It won't put anything out. It just tells you whether to go look. Most heirs who answer yes will spend the next ten minutes on the phone with a custodian and be done. Now flip it around. Same check, other direction. You're the account owner, and your own withdrawals have a first-year trap with an April one date. Now the account is yours. Owner means you, not the person who died. Same habit, different set of questions, and there are only three. Question one: Is this the year you turn seventy-three? The IRS says your first required minimum distribution is for that year. Question two: Is this your first RMD year? If so, you're allowed to delay it until April 1st of the following year. Later ones are due December 31st every year after that. Question three: Have you taken this year's withdrawal yet? If the answer is no, keep reading because the first-year delay has a catch. Here's the trap. If you take that first RMD late in the spring, you still owe the next one for the year you're in. The IRS says taking the first one late means two withdrawals land in the same year. Two taxable withdrawals stacked into one tax return. Nobody plans their income around that by accident. Picture a friend who waits until March because April 1st feels like plenty of time. He feels organized. Then December arrives, and there's another one waiting. The delay didn't cancel anything. It just moved the first bill next to the second. Now, you might think your custodian handles all this. Many of them calculate the amount for you, and that's helpful. But the IRS says the account owner is ultimately responsible for the correct amount, even when the custodian does the math. A letter from your custodian is a starting point. It doesn't replace your own check. So what does skipping it cost? A twenty-five percent excise tax on the amount you were supposed to take out and didn't. Take a withdrawal that should have been a few thousand dollars, and a quarter of it goes to a penalty for doing nothing. You'd have paid income tax on that money anyway. Now you pay extra for the delay. So here's the action list, and it's short. This week, run the three questions for your own account and for any inherited one. It takes under ten minutes, and a cup of coffee is optional. Then call or message the custodian and ask for the amount. Get the number in writing or at least in your account portal. Then take the withdrawal before December 31st. Don't wait for the last week when everything is slow and everyone is on vacation. Put the date on your calendar now so December doesn't surprise you. Once it's done, write down the amount and the day you took it, so next year starts with a record instead of a guess. If you already missed one, take it now. Don't sit on it hoping it fades. Then talk to a tax professional about next steps because that's their job and they've seen it before. The show's called Coin Flip, and most money choices really are close calls. This one isn't. Run the check, take the money, and go back to your life.

More episodes

Keep listening

Other episodes of Coin Flip, newest first.

All episodes of Coin Flip

Sources

Where this came from

6 reports behind the episode. Every one of them opens where it was published.