Troubling Truths Podcast

In 1984, 16-year-old Marci Bachmann disappeared from Washington State. Her remains were discovered in Montana, but for more than two decades, nobody knew her name. Investigators would eventually connect her murder to suspected serial killer Wayne Nance, known as the Missoula Mauler.In this powerful episode of Troubling Truths, we sit down with Marci's brother, Derek M. Bachmann, who spent years searching for his missing sister. Derek shares the heartbreaking story of Marci's disappearance, the family secrets surrounding her childhood, and the promise he made to his grandfather to bring her home.We also explore the disturbing crimes linked to Wayne Nance, the investigation that eventually restored Marci's identity, and the emotional toll of spending 22 years without answers.Derek is the author of Silence Has a Name: A Brother's Search for the Sister the World Forgot, a deeply personal memoir about his sister, his search, and the family left behind.This is more than a serial killer story. It's about a brother who refused to give up and a young girl who deserved to be remembered.📖 DEREK BACHMANN'S BOOKSilence Has a Name: A Brother's Search for the Sister the World ForgotAuthor: D. M. BachmannBook listing: https://www.thriftbooks.com/a/d-m-bachmann/14439761/ ❤️ SUPPORT TROUBLING TRUTHSHelp us continue bringing attention to victims, families, and stories that deserve to be heard.Become a supporter: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support 🎙️ CONNECT WITH TROUBLING TRUTHSFor questions, sponsorships, or story submissions:troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.comSubscribe, follow, and leave us a rating wherever you listen to podcasts.🔥 Burn it down. 💥 Flip the table. 🎙️ Say it anyway.Troubling Truths is a Proper Reckoning Media production. © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

On September 30, 2026, Tennessee attempted to execute Christa Pike, the woman convicted of the brutal 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer. But what was supposed to end a case nearly three decades old turned into a night of repeated needle attempts, closed curtains, emergency calls, and an execution that left Pike alive.In Part 2 of our Christa Pike coverage, Troubling Truths Podcast examines the disturbing timeline of Tennessee's failed lethal injection, from a last-minute court ruling to witness accounts of Pike breathing and moving long after the execution began.We discuss reports of approximately 10 needle attempts, a severely bent needle, questions surrounding the medical personnel, and the emergency response that eventually sent Pike to the hospital. We also examine the earlier failed execution of Tony Carruthers, the resignation of Tennessee corrections commissioner Frank Strada, and the investigation ordered by Governor Bill Lee.Pike's reported recovery raises serious questions about what happened inside that execution chamber. Meanwhile, Colleen Slemmer's family has been left facing another painful chapter after waiting 30 years for justice.What went wrong? Who was responsible? And should Tennessee be allowed to attempt another execution?Through eyewitness reporting, attorney statements, emergency recordings, and news coverage, we examine the unanswered questions while separating documented events from allegations that remain under investigation.HAVE INFORMATION OR A STORY TO SHARE?Have information about a case, a story you believe deserves attention, or questions for our team? We'd like to hear from you. No information is too small.For confidential inquiries, story submissions, guest appearances, sponsorships, or partnerships:📧 troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.comSUPPORT TROUBLING TRUTHSIndependent reporting and true crime storytelling take time, research, and resources. If you believe these stories deserve to be told, consider becoming a supporter of Troubling Truths Podcast.❤️ Become a supporter: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support Follow Troubling Truths Podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Spreaker, or wherever you listen. Share this episode, leave us a review, and join the conversation. Your support helps us continue asking the difficult questions.🔥 Burn it down. 💥 Flip the table. 🎙️ Say it anyway.Troubling Truths Podcast is a Proper Reckoning Media production.Note: Certain details surrounding the execution, including allegations about IV access and medical procedures, remain disputed or under investigation. © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

Bail Reform, Politics and Public Safety: Attorney Ken W. Good | Troubling TruthsAre politics and judicial policies putting public safety at risk? And when dangerous offenders are released back into our communities, who should be held accountable?Across America, the debate over cashless bail, electronic monitoring, and judicial accountability is raising serious questions about how our criminal justice system operates.In this episode of Troubling Truths, Sheri, Pauline, and Benna sit down with attorney Ken W. Good, a longtime bail law expert, author of Good's on Bail, and board member of the Professional Bondsmen of Texas.We discuss the politics behind bail reform, the authority judges have when determining pretrial release, and whether electronic monitoring is an effective way to supervise defendants accused of violent crimes.Who is responsible when someone violates the conditions of their release? Are political agendas influencing criminal justice policies? And are we doing enough to protect innocent people while preserving constitutional rights?From judicial discretion and repeat offenders to government accountability and the future of cash bail, this conversation takes a closer look at the policies shaping America's justice system.Are we prioritizing the right things when it comes to public safety, or is it time to rethink how our courts handle dangerous offenders?Join us for a conversation that's sure to spark debate.SUPPORT TROUBLING TRUTHSHelp us continue bringing you independent true crime investigations, victim advocacy, and stories that deserve to be heard. https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support HAVE INFORMATION OR A STORY TO SHARE?Have a tip, information about a case, or a story you believe deserves attention? We want to hear from you.No information is too small.For confidential inquiries, story submissions, guest appearances, or sponsorship opportunities:troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.comJOIN THE CONVERSATIONSubscribe, follow, and share Troubling Truths as we continue investigating difficult cases, asking uncomfortable questions, and giving a voice to stories that should never be forgotten.🔥 Burn it down. 💥 Flip the table. 🎙️ Say it anyway.Troubling Truths is a Proper Reckoning Media production. © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

Alphanso Talley Chicago Police Shooting: Did Bail Reform Fail?Was the death of a Chicago police officer preventable?On April 25, 2026, Chicago police officer John Bartholomew was fatally shot, and fellow officer Nelson Crespo suffered devastating injuries during a violent encounter at Swedish Hospital. The accused gunman, Alphanso Talley, had a criminal history and had previously been released on electronic monitoring despite prosecutors' objections.But what happened in the months leading up to that tragic day? Why was Talley released despite concerns about public safety? What warning signs emerged, and could authorities have intervened before an officer lost his life?In this episode of Troubling Truths, Sheri, Pauline, and Benna investigate the Alphanso Talley case, the controversial decisions made in Cook County courtrooms, reported electronic monitoring violations, and the growing debate surrounding Illinois' SAFE-T Act and no-cash bail policies.We examine the events at Swedish Hospital, the questions surrounding police search procedures, and the role judicial discretion played in Talley's release. We also discuss whether electronic monitoring provides adequate protection when defendants face serious violent charges.Was this a failure of judicial judgment, electronic monitoring, or a series of missed opportunities that could have prevented a tragedy?Join us as we examine the evidence, question the decisions, and discuss who should be held accountable.SUPPORT TROUBLING TRUTHSHelp us continue bringing you independent true crime investigations, victim advocacy, and the stories that deserve to be heard. https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support HAVE INFORMATION OR A STORY TO SHARE?Have a tip, information about a case, or a story you believe deserves attention? We want to hear from you.No information is too small.For confidential inquiries, story submissions, guest appearances, or sponsorship opportunities:troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.comJOIN THE CONVERSATIONSubscribe and join us as we continue investigating difficult cases, asking uncomfortable questions, and giving a voice to stories that should never be forgotten.🔥 Burn it down. 💥 Flip the table. 🎙️ Say it anyway.Troubling Truths is a Proper Reckoning Media production. © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

What happens when abuse leaves no bruises, but slowly takes away everything that makes someone who they are?In Part 4 of our Mica Miller series, Troubling Truths welcomes special guest Michelle Larson, a registered nurse with more than 25 years of experience, domestic violence survivor, advocate, and author of The Seasons of Staying.Michelle joins us for a powerful conversation about coercive control, psychological abuse, manipulation, and the warning signs that are too often overlooked. Drawing from her own experiences, she explains how someone can gradually lose their independence, confidence, and sense of self, and why escaping an abusive relationship is rarely as simple as walking away.We also discuss Michelle's advocacy surrounding Mica Miller's case, the federal charges against John-Paul Miller, and the fight to pass Mica's Law, proposed South Carolina legislation that would recognize coercive control as a form of domestic violence and strengthen protections for victims.Mica's story has raised difficult questions about how our legal system responds to stalking, intimidation, and psychological abuse before physical violence ever occurs. Could stronger laws help prevent another tragedy? And how many victims are suffering in silence because the abuse they're experiencing isn't something others can see?Michelle also shares the inspiration behind her book, The Seasons of Staying, and her mission to help others recognize coercive control, find support, and reclaim their lives.If you haven't listened to Parts 1, 2, and 3 of our Mica Miller series, we encourage you to go back and hear our previous coverage, including our conversation with investigative reporter Jenn Wood.This is more than a conversation about one woman. It's about recognizing abuse, protecting survivors, and making sure Mica's story helps bring meaningful change.CONNECT WITH MICHELLE LARSONWebsite and book information: https://michellelesleyauthor.com Facebook: Michelle Lesley – Author of The Seasons of StayingSUPPORT MICA'S LAWLearn more about Mica's Law and how you can support the effort to strengthen domestic violence protections: https://passmicaslaw.net DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SUPPORTThe Hiding Place provides support, advocacy, safety planning, and resources for survivors of domestic violence in Upstate South Carolina.Website: https://www.thehidingplacepickens.org 24/7 Crisis Hotline: 888-341-9568National Domestic Violence Hotline: 800-799-7233SUPPORT TROUBLING TRUTHSHelp us continue bringing attention to important stories, speaking with survivors, and giving a voice to those who deserve to be heard. https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support HAVE INFORMATION OR A STORY TO SHARE?Contact us confidentially at: troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com#MicaMiller #MicasLaw #CoerciveControl #DomesticViolenceAwareness #TroublingTruths © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

What is really happening inside the Spartanburg County Coroner's Office? In this explosive episode of Troubling Truths, we sit down with two special guests who are raising serious questions about death investigations, disputed rulings, and the handling of sensitive crime scene and autopsy photographs.Former Spartanburg County coroner's detective Jonathan Nodine joins us to discuss his experiences inside the office, including his allegations that death rulings were changed and his refusal to sign off on findings he disagreed with. He shares what led to his resignation and the concerns he believes deserve public attention.We're also joined by Alex Henderson, brother of Skylar Henderson, whose story we've previously covered. Alex brings text messages and information surrounding allegations of improperly shared photographs, troubling personal decisions, and questions that remain unanswered.We also revisit the heartbreaking case of Gabriel "Gabby" Mitchell and allegations involving Tarra Carter sharing sensitive photographs with her daughter.With firsthand accounts, text messages, and serious allegations on the table, this episode raises one important question: Who holds the people responsible for investigating deaths accountable?These allegations deserve scrutiny, and the families involved deserve answers.🚨 CALLING ALL WHISTLEBLOWERS: If you have firsthand knowledge, documents, evidence, or information involving the Spartanburg County Coroner's Office or related investigations, we want to hear from you. If you've been afraid to come forward, your voice matters. No piece of information is too small.📩 Contact Troubling Truths: troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com🎙️ Support Troubling Truths and help us continue bringing these stories to light: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

More than a decade after the Pendleton quadruple murders shocked South Carolina, the case is once again making headlines. Major evidence has been thrown out, Ross Vilardi's murder trial has been postponed, and Amy Vilardi is appealing her conviction. But behind the courtroom battles is a deeply personal story that deserves to be heard.In this powerful episode of Troubling Truths, we sit down with Savannah, the daughter of convicted murderer Amy Vilardi, as she shares her experiences with remarkable grace, courage, and dignity.Savannah opens up about her childhood, her complicated relationship with her mother, and her allegations of years of sexual abuse by Ross Vilardi. Her story offers a perspective on the Pendleton quadruple murders that goes far beyond the investigation and courtroom proceedings.We also examine the latest developments, including the judge's decision to suppress crucial evidence, Ross Vilardi's fight for bond, and what the pending appeals could mean for both cases.But this episode is about more than a murder investigation. It's about survival, finding your voice, and the strength it takes to share experiences that have remained painful for years. Savannah's willingness to speak openly is a reminder of why these stories matter and why survivors deserve to be heard. FOLLOW SAVANNAH Connect with Savannah and show her your support.Instagram: @Savvy._mt TikTok: @Savvy._mt STAY UPDATED ON THE PENDLETON QUADRUPLE MURDERS The legal battles surrounding Amy and Ross Vilardi are far from over. We will continue covering the latest hearings, appeals, bond decisions, and major developments.Follow our Troubling Truths Facebook page, where we'll post updates and breaking developments as new information becomes available. SUPPORT TROUBLING TRUTHS Your support helps us continue bringing you important stories, exclusive interviews, and voices that deserve to be heard.Become a supporter: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support SPONSORSHIP & CONTACTInterested in sponsoring Troubling Truths or partnering with our podcast? We'd love to hear from you.Have information about the Pendleton quadruple murders or another case we should investigate? Reach out to our team.Email: troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.comSubscribe to Troubling Truths and join us as we uncover the stories behind the headlines.🔥 Burn it down. 💥 Flip the table. 🎙️ Say it anyway.Troubling Truths is a Proper Reckoning Media production. © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

Is there a serial killer in Lansing, Michigan? Five men have died along a relatively small stretch of the Lansing River Trail, raising disturbing questions about whether someone has been deliberately targeting the city's homeless population.Between October 2025 and August 2026, Gino Chouinard, Denis Dunnebacke, Robert Smith, Daniel Lusk, and Louis Woodruff were found with devastating injuries near the trail. Four suffered significant injuries to their heads or faces, while one was fatally stabbed. Investigators believe some of these men may have been attacked while sleeping, leaving police to consider whether the deaths are connected.In this episode of Troubling Truths, Sheri, Benna, and Pauline examine the timeline of all five deaths, the similarities investigators have identified, and the growing questions surrounding the Lansing Police Department's response. Police reportedly recognized similarities between cases in July, months before a public briefing addressed all five deaths. We also discuss the families demanding answers, concerns about surveillance along the trail, and whether the city's treatment of homeless encampments may have left vulnerable people even more exposed.One man, Edward Joseph Smith, has been charged in connection with Daniel Lusk's murder, but authorities have not publicly linked him to the other deaths. Police have not confirmed that a serial killer is responsible, and important questions remain unanswered.Could someone have been hunting vulnerable men along the Lansing River Trail? Were warning signs missed? And could there be other victims or surviving witnesses who have yet to come forward?HAVE INFORMATION ABOUT THESE DEATHS?If you have any information that could help investigators, no matter how small it may seem, please contact the Lansing Police Department.Lansing Police Dedicated Tip Line: 517-483-6023Crime Stoppers: 517-483-STOP (7867)Your information could help bring answers to the families of these five men. SUPPORT TROUBLING TRUTHS: Help us continue bringing attention to overlooked cases, unanswered questions, and stories that deserve to be heard.Become a supporter: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support INTERESTED IN SPONSORING TROUBLING TRUTHS?We're welcoming sponsorship and advertising inquiries from businesses and organizations interested in reaching our growing true crime audience. If you're interested in sponsoring an episode or exploring a partnership with Troubling Truths, we'd love to hear from you.Sponsorship Inquiries: troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com Have a case you'd like us to investigate, information to share, or questions for our team? You can also reach us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Subscribe and follow Troubling Truths for more true crime investigations, breaking developments, and conversations that aren't afraid to ask difficult questions.Flip the table. Burn it down. Say it anyway.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.© 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved. © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

For nearly two decades, Chuck Wright was one of the most powerful and recognizable figures in Spartanburg County. He built a reputation as a tough-on-crime sheriff, dominated local elections, and became a familiar face during some of the county’s biggest cases.Then it all started to unravel.In this episode of Troubling Truths, we look at the fall of former Spartanburg County Sheriff Chuck Wright through the eyes of Benna, who was raising questions long before the federal case exploded into public view. We revisit her “Shut Down the Dope Compounds” billboard campaign, the ethics complaints, the investigations, Wright’s sudden leave and resignation, the money, the pills, the guilty plea, and the prison sentence that followed.We also discuss the reporting of Andy Fancher and FITSNews, the unanswered questions surrounding Wright’s time in office, and the newly emerging Chuck Wright tapes that could add another chapter to a story many thought was already over.Support Troubling Truths and help us keep telling these stories: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support Have information about the case? No information is too small. Contact Troubling Truths Podcast at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Subscribe and join us as we dig into the stories that deserve a closer look. © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

What happened to Jared Davis?In December 2012, 24-year-old Jared Davis left his mother’s home and hours later was found unresponsive in the back of a van after a relatively minor accident on Highway 11. His heart had stopped, doctors could not determine why, and his death was ultimately ruled undetermined.In this episode of Troubling Truths, Jared’s mother, Becki Genobles, joins us to walk through what happened that day, the conflicting witness accounts, questions surrounding evidence and toxicology, the investigation that followed, and why she is still fighting for answers nearly 14 years later.Becki is not claiming she can prove someone killed her son. She is asking a much simpler question: was everything possible actually done to find out what happened to Jared?This is Jared’s story, in his mother’s own words.Support Troubling Truths and help us keep telling these stories: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support Have information about Jared Davis’s case? No information is too small. Contact Troubling Truths Podcast at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Subscribe and join us as we dig into the stories that deserve a closer look.🔥 Burn it down. 💥 Flip the table. 🎙️ Say it anyway.Troubling Truths is a Proper Reckoning Media production. © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

Gabriel “Gabby” Mitchell was just 17 when she died in July 2020. Her mother, Michael, and grandmother, Juanita, join Sheri, Benna, and Pauline to share her story and the questions her family still wants answered.We discuss the family’s account of the circumstances surrounding Gabby’s death, their concerns about the investigation, and the fentanyl crisis in Spartanburg County, South Carolina. We also examine published reporting about the Broome High School incident, distinguishing disputed allegations from documented facts.At the heart of this episode is Gabby and a family determined to have her story heard.If you have any information about Gabby’s death or the circumstances surrounding it, please reach out. No information is too small. Contact Michael Chavis on Facebook or email Troubling Truths Podcast at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths and help us keep telling these stories: Become a supporter . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

In Part Two of our Mica Miller series, we take a closer look at the final days of her life and the events of April 27, 2024.We walk through Mica’s final court filings, her movements that Saturday, the firearm purchase, her final drive, the heartbreaking 911 call, and what investigators discovered at Lumber River State Park. We also examine the medical examiner’s findings, why her death was officially ruled a suicide, and what investigators established about JP Miller’s whereabouts.There is significant evidence surrounding Mica’s final hours, but questions remain about the circumstances leading up to her death. We believe those questions deserve to be examined carefully, without losing sight of the woman at the center of this story.We're joined by Jenn Wood of FITSNews, an investigative journalist and former private investigator who has spent more than two years following the Mica Miller case.Jenn takes us behind the headlines and walks us through her personal experiences investigating this story, including her firsthand interviews with Mica’s family, friends, and others connected to the case.She shares what those conversations were like, what stayed with her, what she learned while retracing Mica’s final route, and the details she believes deserve more attention.This is an opportunity to hear directly from someone who has spent years digging into this case and speaking with the people closest to Mica.Contact Jenn Wood: jenn@fitsnews.com Website: https://www.fitsnews.com A Message From Troubling Truths. This episode discusses suicide, mental health, alleged domestic abuse, and controlling behavior. We understand these topics may be difficult for some listeners.If you or someone you love is struggling, confidential support is available.Suicide & Crisis Lifeline Call or text 988 (United States) https://988lifeline.org Available 24/7.National Domestic Violence Hotline Call 1-800-799-SAFE (7233) Text START to 88788 https://www.thehotline.org Confidential support is available 24/7.If you are in immediate danger, call 911.At Troubling Truths, we believe conversations about mental health and domestic violence matter. Someone can struggle with their mental health and still experience abuse. One does not invalidate the other.Mica Miller was more than the circumstances of her death. Her story deserves to be told with care.#MicaMiller #JPMiller #JennWood #FITSNews #TroublingTruths Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

In Part 2 of our Mica Miller series, we walk through Mica’s final days and the events of April 27, 2024. We break down the final court developments in her separation from JP Miller, her movements that day, the firearm purchase, her drive to Lumber River State Park, and the 911 call she made shortly before her death. We also examine the search for Mica, the evidence recovered at the park, the medical examiner’s findings, why investigators ruled her death a suicide, and where authorities determined JP Miller was that day. The official evidence tells us a lot, but there are still parts of Mica’s story that leave questions. Next, we’ll be joined by FITSNews reporter Jenn Wood, who has spent more than two years investigating the Mica Miller case and interviewing her family, friends, and others connected to the story. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

Christa Pike’s scheduled September 30 execution was temporarily halted by a federal appeals court as her legal fight continued. Pike was sentenced to death for the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, and the case has renewed debate over her age at the time, childhood abuse, and mental health. In Episode 14 of Troubling Truths, we walk through the crime, the evidence, and the fight over Pike’s death sentence. We also want you to know who Colleen was and who her family is, because behind every argument about Pike’s future is a young woman whose future was stolen. Follow Troubling Truths on Facebook for updates on the stay and what happens next. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

Mica Miller’s death became national news, but the story didn’t begin on April 27, 2024. Long before that day, Mica was trying to leave her marriage to pastor JP Miller, talking to family and friends, seeking mental health treatment, and repeatedly reaching out to law enforcement. In Part One of our deep dive into the Mica Miller case, Sheri, Benna and Pauline go back to the beginning. We look at who Mica was before she became a headline, how JP Miller came into her life, their relationship and marriage, life inside Solid Rock Church, Mica’s documented mental health history, and the growing problems that eventually led her to seek separation. We also walk through the police paper trail leading up to her death, including repeated calls involving alleged tracking devices, vehicle issues, privacy concerns and other incidents Mica reported while trying to separate herself from JP. Throughout the episode, you’ll hear Mica in her own words along with audio and interviews from people who knew her. We separate documented facts from allegations and ask a difficult question: when someone has a documented mental health history, can that change the way police, family, doctors and everyone around them interpret what they are trying to say? This episode takes us right up to the night before April 27. In Part Two, we’ll examine Mica’s final day minute by minute, the official investigation into her death, JP Miller’s public response, what former Solid Rock members began saying afterward, and the federal criminal case that would eventually follow. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

Who killed Caroline Lake? In Episode 12 of Troubling Truths, investigative journalist Andy Fancher with FITSNews joins Sheri, Benna and Pauline to lead an in-depth discussion about this nearly forgotten Spartanburg County cold case.Caroline was only 20 years old when she disappeared from Duncan, South Carolina, in August of 1990. More than two years later, rabbit hunters discovered her skeletal remains in a wooded area off Bradley Drive in Wellford. More than three decades have passed, and no one has ever been charged with her murder.Throughout the episode, Andy walks us through the case from beginning to end. He lays out Caroline’s timeline, explains how the case first came onto his radar and shares what he has learned from people who remember Caroline and the investigation.Andy also examines the missing links and unanswered questions surrounding Caroline’s disappearance, the discovery of her remains and the way the original investigation was handled. He discusses the rumors that were circulating before Caroline was found and why information from multiple independent sources convinced him that this case deserved another look.What happened after Caroline left her grandparents’ home? What happened to her white Toyota Corolla? Did people in the community already know she had been killed? Was important information overlooked? And could evidence from the case still provide answers through modern forensic testing?This episode brings Caroline’s name back into the public eye and asks the question that has gone unanswered since 1990: Who killed Caroline Lake?If you have information about Caroline’s case, or another case you believe deserves investigation, contact Andy Fancher Social media: @RealAndyFancher Email: andy@fitsnews.com Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

Welcome to Troubling Truths. I’m Sheri, here with Pauline and Benna. Tonight, we are doing something a little different and bringing local stories to the table from our home states of South Carolina and Arkansas. These are three separate stories, but every one of them raises serious questions about trust, accountability, and the people we expect to do the right thing. Benna is digging into the allegations surrounding former Spartanburg County Coroner’s Office investigator Skylar Henderson. Those allegations involve the sharing of private case information and photographs, along with questions about what else may have been happening inside that department. She is also going to connect this discussion to Katie White’s reels about Crystal Freeman and Spartanburg County Coroner Rusty Clevenger. Pauline is bringing us the Arkansas story involving former Hot Spring County Sheriff Scott Finkbeiner. He is out of federal prison, breaking his silence, and making some explosive accusations against prosecutors, judges, law enforcement officers, and other powerful people. We are only scratching the surface tonight because Scott is expected to join us in the next few weeks and answer our questions himself. And I’m bringing the crossover story connecting both states. Brandon and Sierra Britten are an Arkansas couple accused of grooming and abducting a 12-year-old girl from Spartanburg County before Brandon allegedly raped her inside their Arkansas home. We’re going to explain how investigators found her, what Sierra is accused of doing, and the serious charges both of them are now facing. Three local stories, two states, and a whole lot to bring to the table. Let’s get into it. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

In Troubling Truths Episode 11, Sheri, Pauline, and Benna cover the disturbing Siders family case out of Vinton County, Ohio, where authorities say 16 children were found living in horrific conditions inside a Hamden home. This episode breaks down the latest major updates, including the two new arrests connected to the broader investigation, the new sex-crime charges involving Gary Siders Jr. and Elizabeth Siders, and the major ruling that Gary Siders Sr. has been found incompetent to stand trial. We also walk through how investigators ended up at the Siders home, why the case appears to be much bigger than the original child-endangerment charges, and the questions surrounding missed warning signs, including reports involving Dollar General clerks, prior child-welfare concerns, family claims, and public sightings. A major part of this episode also focuses on Elizabeth Siders’ timeline. She was reportedly only 15 when she married Gary Siders Jr., and questions continue to grow about grooming, isolation, pregnancy history, and whether Elizabeth may have been a victim before becoming one of the accused adults. As always, we separate confirmed reporting from online speculation. We discuss the current pregnancy rumor, DNA rumors, stillbirth claims, family knowledge questions, and other allegations circulating online while making clear what has and has not been verified. At the center of this case are the children. The biggest question remains: how did this go on for so long, and who had a chance to step in before authorities finally found them? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

In this episode of Troubling Truths, Sheri, Pauline and Benna take a deep look at the Pendleton quadruple murders in Anderson County, South Carolina. In 2015, Mike Scott, Cathy Scott, Barbara Scott and Violet Taylor were found brutally murdered inside their home near Pendleton, just minutes from Clemson. For nearly eight years, the case remained unsolved before Cathy’s daughter, Amy Vilardi, and Amy’s husband, Ross Vilardi, were arrested and charged with all four murders. We walk through the family tension, the bloody footprints, the missing red ASICS, the money trail, text messages, Amy’s 911 call, the early interviews with Amy and Ross, and the later confrontation where investigators told them they believed they were responsible. We also hear from Amy’s daughter Savannah, who speaks about the people she says raised and cared for her, and shares serious allegations about abuse she says she suffered within the family. Amy Vilardi has since been convicted of all four murders and sentenced to four consecutive life sentences. Ross Vilardi has not been convicted and is awaiting his separate trial. This episode also carries a personal connection for the show, as Benna knows relatives of the victims. Tonight, we remember Mike Scott, Cathy Scott, Barbara Scott and Violet Taylor, and examine the evidence, the unanswered questions, and the case that shook a small South Carolina community. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support

In Episode 8 of Troubling Truths, Sheri, Pauline, and Benna take a closer look at the tragic case of Saylor Hayes. We walk through the timeline, the searches, the tracking device, the arrests, the court history, and the events leading up to Saylor being found. We also discuss the major questions that still remain and what investigators have said about the case. This episode focuses on what is known, what has been reported, and the troubling details that continue to raise questions around Saylor Hayes and the people involved. Join us as we break down the case, the investigation, and the unanswered questions surrounding the death of Saylor Hayes. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support . © 2026 Proper Reckoning Media. All Rights Reserved.Troubling Truths is produced and published by Proper Reckoning Media.Questions, case tips, or story submissions? Contact us at troublingtruthspodcast@gmail.com.Support Troubling Truths: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/troubling-truths-podcast--7257062/support