The Overshare Hour

This week on The Overshare Hour , we’re tackling four situations. Is a woman overreacting for second-guessing her relationship after her boyfriend tells her he would kidnap their future children if they ever got divorced? Is OP the asshole for immediately ending a first date after his date deleted his carefully curated music playlist? Should a husband really be mad that his wife lied AND pinky promised during a game of Mafia? And years after his sister forced him out of the closet, does OP owe her forgiveness now that she wants a relationship?

Christa Innis from Here Comes the Drama joins me for a wedding-themed episode of The Overshare Hour ! Is OP the asshole for having a themed wedding with a strict dress code? Was a bridesmaid wrong for secretly recording the bride at her bachelorette party and showing the video to the groom? Should guests be expected to follow a wedding across FOUR different locations? And what do you do when the bride says conversations have to stay “on topic” at her wedding? Christa and I are breaking down some of the internet’s wildest wedding dilemmas and deciding who, if anyone, is actually in the wrong. - Christa’s IG: https://www.instagram.com/heychristainnis/ Christa’s Linktree: https://linktr.ee/christainnis

Brandon and I are back to unpack 4 wild stories: Is a groom the asshole for telling his fiancé she can't wear a white dress? Is OP the Asshole for announcing his pregnancy at his brother's wedding? Is OP overreacting after finding out her boyfriend's friends were fake, and she was communicating with him the whole time? And is OP the asshole for leaving a date after she brought a friend along?

Bethany joins me this week to unpack four messy situations that have us asking: who is actually in the wrong? Is someone overreacting after her boyfriend asks to have a threesome with one of her friends? Is it wrong to lie to a chronically late friend? And are you responsible for making sure your friend eats? Then, we get into a complicated family and money dilemma: is someone wrong for asking her mom to stop tithing to the church when she can’t afford her own medical bills? Bethany and I have THOUGHTS. - Bethany’s Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@bethany_joyful Bethany’s Deconstruction Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@bethanyjoy_deconstructed Bethany’s IG: https://www.instagram.com/bethany_joy_ful/ Bethany’s Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@bethany_joy_ful - Follow for more: Jubilee’s TikTok: ⁠https://www.tiktok.com/@jubileedawns⁠ Jubilee’s IG: ⁠⁠⁠ ⁠https://www.instagram.com/jubileedawns⁠

Bran joins me for four stories with a lot to unpack. Is someone wrong for not dedicating her first book to her twin sister? Should you respond when your former best friend apologizes for having an affair with your husband? And, after weeks of wondering what their neighbors were doing at their completely silent parties, WE HAVE AN UPDATE—and the mystery has officially been solved. Then, we dive into a listener write-in about a mother-sin relationship filled with financial betrayal, cruel comments and years of hurt. Now, with his brother's wedding approaching, the family is pressuring him to reconcile with their mom. Is he wrong for refusing? Submit: https://forms.gle/k8BnKgxgKUFiJkSDA

Ashley and Bailee from Praise Be To Pod are joining me for an especially chaotic round of Reddit stories! What would you do if your MIL told you she believes your baby isn’t saved and warned that if you don’t baptize her, she will ? Then, is it reasonable to be creeped out by neighbors who throw huge weekly parties that are somehow completely silent? And are you obligated to babysit your sister’s child when you're supposed to be enjoying your own Disney vacation? - Praise Be To Pod: https://www.praisebetopod.com/ Praise Be To Podcast IG: https://www.instagram.com/praisebetopod/ Praise Be To Podcast Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@praisebetopod

My sister Mia is on the podcast this week as we dive into some of Reddit's messiest family drama. We're debating whether it's ever okay to give away your child's pet, whether a boyfriend should ask a dad for permission to marry his daughter if she's against it, a mom who left her son's celebration after feeling snubbed, and the jaw-dropping family chaos that erupted at a $100,000 wedding.

This week we're diving into four Reddit stories. Should you support your spouse's dream of competing on Survivor if you're expecting a baby? Is an 18-year-old too young to vacation in Miami with her boyfriend's family? What do you do when a date tells you that you need to convert and become a tradwife? And one woman's closest friends seemed to support her relationship... until she got engaged.

This week we're diving into more Reddit stories. We discuss whether someone should secretly help their brother leave his Mormon mission behind their parents' backs, whether refusing to appear in an apology video makes someone the asshole, and whether a mom was wrong for refusing to replace her daughter's lost stuffed animal. Plus, we revisit the story of the boyfriend who refused to show his girlfriend where he lived to find out what happened next.

This week, I'm joined by Bailee from Praise Be To Pod to dive into another round of Reddit's messiest relationship and friendship dilemmas. We debate whether someone was wrong for refusing to let their friend bring a random guy back to their shared cabin, react to a first dance song choice we absolutely weren't prepared for, and discuss whether it's fair to uninvite someone after they complain about how inconvenient it is to attend your wedding. Lastly, what happens when your best friend of eleven years says they can't support your marriage because you're gay? - Bailee’s IG: https://www.instagram.com/paynebailee Praise Be To Pod: https://open.spotify.com/show/3XkmQGWnGRq7SalxjjtOmD Praise Be To Pod IG: https://www.instagram.com/praisebetopod/ Praise Be To Pod Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@praisebetopod

This week we're diving into four Reddit dilemmas that had us debating what we'd actually do. Would you question someone's decision to ask for donations for a mission trip? If one friend cancels a group vacation, should everyone else be refunded? Is it your place to tell your brother's fiancée that he lied about missing their anniversary? And after three months of dating, is it reasonable to give your boyfriend an ultimatum if he refuses to let you see where he lives?

This week on The Overshare Hour, we debate whether it's okay to sell concert tickets you originally bought for your now ex-boyfriend, discuss a boyfriend who was shockingly rude to friends who cooked for him, and unpack whether it's ever worth telling your fiancé that you were disappointed by their proposal. Plus, one listener reveals that the guy she's dating refuses to tell her what religion he practices... and naturally, we have questions. Is it a harmless quirk, or are we looking at some major red flags?

This week, we're diving into four wild stories from Reddit. One woman can't escape her husband's mistress, who seems to be stalking her every move . Another attends what he thought was a wedding, only to discover it was actually a commitment party with no legal marriage involved and wonders if he has a right to feel misled. We also discuss a mother-in-law who refuses to display her daughter-in-law's artwork because she simply doesn't like it, and a woman whose mother-in-law showed up unannounced to dig up her flower bed... because her husband's ex-girlfriend asked her to. Plus, Jubilee shares stories from her recent trip to New York, and Brandon talks about his new bike.

One year ago, The Overshare Hour launched. To celebrate, I’m digging into the vault and sharing a never-released episode from the early days of the podcast. In this throwback episode, Kenzie and I swap some of the wildest stories from our religious upbringings and deconstruction journeys. We talk about eating blended Happy Meals in youth group, spitting crickets, purity culture, hell houses, being told we wouldn't recognize our loved ones in heaven, and some truly unhinged church comments that still make us laugh. Happy one-year anniversary, friends!

A mother is unhappy after being excluded from her daughter's proposal and wants to show up anyway. A father refuses to attend his daughter's graduation unless his girlfriend gets an invitation too. Someone wins the lottery, and suddenly everyone has opinions about who deserves the money. Plus, what do you do when your boyfriend practically lives at your house, drives up the bills, and still doesn't contribute?

This week, we’re diving into some truly chaotic Reddit stories. From a groom hiring a magician to crash his own wedding as a prank, to a mother-in-law confessing that her husband isn’t actually the biological father of her son because she’s terrified of an upcoming DNA test... We also debate whether it’s wrong to make a 12-year-old pay their portion of a family vacation, and whether someone should tell their partner they converted to a completely different religion.

I’m joined by Abigail again and we are diving into some absolutely chaotic Reddit stories. From a friend’s boyfriend joking about burning someone’s pet tarantulas (???) to neighbors who keep flipping over a spooky doormat, things escalate quickly. We also get into a tough dilemma: should you warn your husband if his parents are planning a surprise visit you know he wouldn’t want? Plus, is it wrong to ask for a refund after finding out your counselor lied about being faith-based? And is a wife a the asshole for not making her husband listen to them? - Abigail’s IG: https://www.instagram.com/fabigailinsta/ Abigail’s Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@fabigail11 Abigail’s Podcast: https://www.tiktok.com/@readirectpodcast?lang=en - Follow for more: Jubilee’s TikTok: ⁠https://www.tiktok.com/@jubileedawns⁠ Jubilee’s IG: ⁠⁠⁠ ⁠https://www.instagram.com/jubileedawns⁠

This was the very first Reddit episode of The Overshare Hour! Newer listeners may have missed, and it’s honestly a chaotic one. In this episode, we’re diving into some truly chaotic Reddit stories. We discuss whether it’s weird to tell your mother-in-law way too much about your relationship, if someone was wrong for laughing when a kid swallowed an AirPod, and a VERY uncomfortable joke involving a cousin that did not land. We also get into family drama, including a mother-in-law who posted wedding photos without the bride, and whether it’s fair to expect guests to pitch in $100 for Thanksgiving dinner. As always, we’re breaking it all down and deciding who’s actually in the wrong.

This week we’re diving into some truly unhinged situations and trying to figure out… who’s actually in the wrong here?? We talk about a MIL who shut down her DIL’s plan to give birth in her living room, a bride who asked a guest not to wear her engagement ring (??), and whether it’s inappropriate to sleep with your boyfriend in a shared bedroom. We also get into a crying baby in church that sparked tension, a brother who refused to watch FOUR kids during a birth, and a name drama situation between sisters.

This week on The Overshare Hour, Bran picked the order of the chaos… and he saved movies for last. We react to a woman discovering her boyfriend has been secretly using AI to cheat at chess, an older sister being told to “cover up” around her younger sister’s boyfriend, a marriage completely imploding after lingerie photos were sent to the husband, and a movie theater situation that left kids in tears.