Forgive Me! tells the story of Father Ben, a try-hard young Catholic priest who was recently reassigned from Binghamton to St. Patrick’s, a new parish in the fictional Texarkana, NY, under mysterious circumstances. Each episode follows Ben into the confessional with another eccentric parishioner from around town, exploring the intertwined lives of this new community and the funny, sad, and sometimes painful experiences that come out of the Catholic experience.
Forgive Havoc! Live at KGB Bar (TWO THOUSAND AND LATE Crossover)
Father Ben meets a woman named Harper who is experiencing some Havoc in her life. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) and Atypical Artists (https://www.atypicalartists.co) Written by Lauren Shippen with Story Editing from Bob Raymonda Cast: Lauren Shippen as Haper and Havoc Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben Josh Rubino as Fr. Klem Dialogue editing and mixing by Adam Raymonda. Two Thousand and Late theme music by Brian Grugle Crossover theme arranged by Adam Raymonda Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For early access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue In a small town in upstate New York, Harper lives a completely mundane existence. After years trying to get an artistic career off the ground, she’s retreated to her tiny hometown, working minimum wage jobs and trying to ignore her chronic pain. All her days are exactly the same–wake up, have a cup of instant coffee, go to work, go home, have a microwave meal, watch TV, go to sleep. With the exception of her girlfriend–the one bright spot in Harper’s life–existence is tedious and never-ending. TWO THOUSAND AND LATE is the story of Havoc, a demon from hell, sent to bring along the apocalypse. Only, when they arrive, they find that the end of the world isn’t as straightforward as they thought. But that doesn’t mean they can’t still sow a little chaos–Harper, the human they were assigned to, is incredibly ordinary but has more rock bottom to find. In an altogether different small town in Upstate New York, Forgive Me! tells the story of Father Ben, a young try-hard Catholic priest has been reassigned to St. Patrick's Catholic Parish under mysterious circumstances. Each episode follows Ben into the confessional with another eccentric parishioner from around town, exploring the intertwined lives of this new community and the funny, sad, and sometimes painful experiences that come out of the Catholic experience. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Small Forgiveness (Small Victories Crossover!)
A slightly older, slightly wiser Marisol pays a visit to St. Patrick's. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions with WGC Productions Written by Jade Madison Scott. Cast: Mo McKynzie as Marisol Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda Small Victories original theme by Sterlyn Termine GRAPHIC DESIGN: Small Victories logo by Julia Patrick Forgive Me Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Learn more about Small Victories here. Find a transcript of the episode here. Sign up for Bobby’s Snacks here. For early access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Live Show Announcement! & Presenting: Two Thousand and Late
We’re excited to introduce you to TWO THOUSAND AND LATE, a dark comedy series from Lauren Shippen & Atypical Artists of The Bright Sessions Fame. In a small town in upstate New York, Harper lives a completely mundane existence. After years of trying to get an artistic career off the ground, she’s retreated to her tiny hometown, working minimum wage jobs and trying to ignore her chronic pain. All her days are exactly the same–wake up, have a cup of instant coffee, go to work, go home, have a microwave meal, watch TV, go to sleep. With the exception of her girlfriend–the one bright spot in Harper’s life–existence is tedious and never-ending. And then, on her thirty-sixth birthday, a demon possesses Harper. So. Not so mundane after all. TWO THOUSAND AND LATE is the story of a demon from hell sent to bring along the apocalypse. Only, when they arrive, they find that the end of the world isn’t as straightforward as they thought. But that doesn’t mean they can’t still sow a little chaos–the human they were assigned to is incredibly ordinary, but has more rock bottom to find. We’ll be producing FORGIVE HAVOC: A TWO THOUSAND & LATE x FORGIVE ME! Crossover LIVE at KGB Bar on Friday, June 12 in New York City during the 2026 Tribeca Film Festival. Learn more about the series and find tickets to the performance below. TWO THOUSAND & LATE FORGIVE HAVOC TICKETS Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Presenting: Metra: A Climate Revolution with Songs
Hey Pals, We’ve been pretty hard at work behind the scenes producing season 4 of Forgive Me!, but while we don’t have a premiere date to officially announce quite yet, we’re excited to introduce you to another podcast we love: Metra, a Climate Revolution with Songs by married couple team Emily & Ned Hartford. Metra E1 - Let the Story Begin Meet the Tree Nymph Chorus. Don't worry, they'll guide you through the story. We begin at the end, in 2045--facing down a line of armed security forces at the edge of the Bubbles. And then, we jump back to 2015 and a remote Greek island. An ancient tree nymph recruits the central player in her climate revolution. They begin a dangerous journey. Songs: "Welcome From the Nymphs" "Back to the Past" "Cori, Come Near" "Cascade" Written by Emily and Ned Hartford Music and Lyrics by Ned Hartford Dialogue Directed by Emily Hartford Produced by MythMakers Media Featuring: Jeannette Bayardelle, Cherrye J. Davis, Fred Inkley, Corinna Schulenburg, Alia Munsch, Cristina Obando Sanchez, Sierra Rein, Luke Wyngarden, William Peden, Matthew Trumbull, Corey Allen, and Stephanie Willing. Sound Editing and Design; Instrumentation Arranged and Performed; Vocals Arranged; and all Audio Produced, Engineered, and Mixed by Ned Hartford Follow the show: https://pod.link/1843713183 IG and Bluesky: @metrathemusical metrathemusical.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Presenting: UN-TITLED
Hi Friends! This week, we’re excited to introduce you to UN-TITLED, an Arthurian Medieval sitcom on the Fable & Folly Network. Episode 1, MIDDLE-AGED: UN-TITLED follows Faylin, a middle-aged squire, having a midlife crisis in the Middle Ages. In short, he’s too olde for this shit. Old with an e. The show follows the anti-hero scheming to get promoted to a knighthood, all while fending off an annoying wunderkind on the rise - the future King Arthur. Learn more about the show here. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Presenting: Re:Dracula
Re: Dracula is a bite-sized audio adaptation of the horror classic, featuring a full cast and immersive sound design. Every entry in this epistolary novel is turned into an episode and set to your podcatcher on the day it happens. Find out more about this award-winning audio drama at redracula.live. May 5: Jonathan Harker arrives at Castle Dracula. This episode references the racist pseudoscience of craniometry. Transcript here. This episode featured: Ben Galpin as Jonathan Harker; Sivan Raz as the Hungarian Man and additional voices; Mihai Matei as the driver and additional voices; Madi Opincaru as theGerman-speaking traveler and additional voices; Ioana Adăscăliței with additional voices;GrahamRowat as Peter Hawkins; and Karim Kronfli as Dracula. Directed by Stephen Indrisano.Dialogue editing by Stephen Indrisano. Sound design by Tal Minear. Featuring music by TravisReaves. Produced by Ella Watts and Pacific S. Obadiah, with executive producers StephenIndrisano, Tal Minear, and Hannah Wright. A Bloody FM Production. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Forgive Root (Windfall Crossover Republish)
Somehow, Captain Root meets Father Ben and confesses to some light patricide. Support Forgive Me! Season 4 on Indiegogo: https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/forgive-me-season-4#/ Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written and directed by Bob Raymonda, Jess Clark, and Jack Marone. Cast: Casey Callaghan as Father Ben Josh Rubino as Captain Root + Father Klem Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For ad free access to episodes and bonus content become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Easter 2025 Special: High Holiday
Father Ben’s sweet tooth is bound to get him in trouble someday… and that day is today. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written, directed, and dialogue edited by Bob Raymonda. Cast: Josh Rubio as Father Klem Casey Callaghan as Father Ben Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda. Help us make Forgive Me! Season 4 a reality here. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For ad-free access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
The Pranking Priests of St. Patricks (April Fools' Special)
Father Klem had a terrible, horrible, no good, very bad day. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written, directed, and dialogue edited by Bob Raymonda. Cast: Josh Rubio as Father Klem Casey Callaghan as Father Ben Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda. Help us make Forgive Me! Season 4 a reality here. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For ad-free access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
A Christmas Clara
Father Klem gives Father Ben a Christmas gift. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written and directed by Bob Raymonda and Jack Marone. Cast: Casey Callaghan as Father Ben Josh Rubio as Father Klem Krystal Osborne as Clara Martin Giancarlo Herra as Joseph Martin Hannah Schooner as Horse Clara Michael Larkin as Judge Joe Walters Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda. Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For ad-free access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Thanksgiving With the Colony
Pat & Gayle host Thanksgiving. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written and directed by Bob Raymonda and Jack Marone. Cast: Casey Callaghan as Father Ben Emma Sherr-Ziarko as Gayle Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda. Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For ad-free access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Where Angels Fear to Tread
Dave recalls the incident at the Texarkana Terror Entrapment and Hayride of Heck Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written and directed by Bob Raymonda and Jack Marone. Cast: Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben Jeffery Cranor as Dave Nightvale TTRPG Crowdfunding Campaign! Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda. Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For ad-free access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Crossover: Forgive Arden - The Pranked Priests of St. Patrick's
Fr. Ben and Fr. Klem had their first ever podcast appearance on the true-crime investigative show, Arden. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions with Wheyface Radio Written by T.H. Ponders and directed by Chris Dole, T.H. Ponders, and Bob Raymonda. Cast: Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben Michelle Agrestti as Bea Tracey Sayed as Brenda Ben Watts as Andy Wheyface Josh Rubino as Fr. Klem Sarah Rhea Werner as Darla James Oliva as Tennessee Krystal Osborne as Clara Jordan Stillman as Tanna Sam Twardy as Emma Leslie Gideon as Caitlin T.H. Ponders as Jeremy Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda Sound design by Chris Dole and T.H. Ponders Music by Christopher Hadfield and Adam Raymonda GRAPHIC DESIGN: Arden Logo by Dylan Farr Forgive Me Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Learn more about Arden here. Find a transcript of the episode here. Sign up for Bobby’s Snacks here. For early access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Forgive Apollyon! A Crossover
Reese, a school principal living in the early 22nd century, unburdens herself with the Confessions 3.0 App. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions with Observer Pictures. Written by Faith McQuinn and directed by Faith McQuinn and Bob Raymonda. Cast: Marisha Tapera as Reese Williams Kyle Nishimura as Lincoln Larson Drea Silvertooth as DIPA Brian Huey as PSA Narration Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda Sound design by Faith McQuinn. Apollyon credits music by Katharine Seaton Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Learn more about Apollyon here. Find a transcript of the episode here. Sign up for Bobby’s Snacks here. For early access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Forgive Me! St. Kilda: A Crossover
Cormac, a visitor from St. Kilda, is going to be a father. The Secret of St. Kilda is written by Naomi Clarke and created by Michael Ireland. Forgive Me! is a Rogue Dialogue Production that was created by Jack Marone and Bob Raymonda. Here's our cast in order of appearance: Rhys Lawton as Cormac Casey Callaghan as Father Ben And Josh Rubino as Father Klem Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda. Sound design, score, and mixing by me, Adam Raymonda. The Secret of St. Kilda credits music by Shane Rutherfoord-Jones. The Forgive Me! logo was designed by Sam Twardy. (www.samtwardy.com) And Scott McCartney designed the Secret of St. Kilda logo. You can find a transcript of this episode here. Learn more about St. Kilda here. Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Confessions By Usher Pt. 2
These are Steve's confessions Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written and directed by Jack Marone and Bob Raymonda . Cast: Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben Adam Raymonda as Adam Jack Marone as Steve Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda. Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For ad-free access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Arbor Day Special: It's Turtles All the Way Down
Meredith killed the Eagle Creek Development Deal. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written and directed by Bob Raymonda and Jack Marone. Cast: Mary Benjamin as Meredith Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda. Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For ad-free access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
St. Patrick's St. Patrick's Day Special - Oops, All Snakes!
Curtis comes to collect on services rendered. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written and directed by Bob Raymonda and Jack Marone. Cast: Nick Stag as Curtis Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben Special thanks goes out to our Executive Producer Curtis Dibrell Jr. Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda. Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. For ad-free access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
One of the Dogs (LIVE SHOW!)
David the Pig enters the Salty Dog Central New York Canine Expo. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written and directed by Jack Marone and Bob Raymonda Cast: Adam Raymonda as Adam Emily Elizabeth as Clara Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben Natasia White as Shannon Mo Moshaty as Eileen Michael Larkin as Joe Walters Dialogue editing and mixing by Adam Raymonda. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Find a transcript of the episode here. Sign up for Bobby's Snacks here. For early access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Forgive Colette: The Kingmaker Histories Crossover
Fr. Ben helps Colette deal with her guilty, time-displaced conscience. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) and Meg Molloy Tuten Written by Meg Molloy Tuten and directed by Jack Marone and Bob Raymonda Cast: Blythe Renay as Colette Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben Josh Rubino as Telesphore Taqi Nazeer as Eisen Josh Rubino as Fr. Klem Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram Learn more about The Kingmaker Histories here. Find a transcript of the episode here. Sign up for Bobby’s Snacks here. For early access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Ranking source
Apple Podcasts rankings supplied by Mato Topic Intelligence Platform.
Observed July 31, 2026.
Apple and Apple Podcasts are trademarks of Apple Inc., registered in the U.S. and other countries.
